Would You Place Your Child There?

(All names in this story have been changed.)
“How does the system let these things happen? How can they put children in a house so dirty? I can’t believe this!”
These were the thoughts that ran through my head when my social worker, Mr. Clark from the Brooklyn field office, took me to my temporary foster home in Manhattan. As I walked into the house, I thanked God that I was only going to be spending the weekend in that filthy apartment.
As I looked around the living room, I saw broken down chairs and all types of junk. The shelves were coated with dust, as if they had not been cleaned for years. On the floor was spilled food, which could have been from the kids. (Well, at least clean it up!)
The kitchen had dishes piled in the sink, and there were uncovered plates of food on the counter. I saw roaches crawling over the counter and going into open cans of food.
‘Get Me Out of Here’
I hadn’t yet seen the bedroom when I turned to my social worker, held onto his hand, and said, “Get me out of here.” He said to me, “Don’t worry, it’s only for the weekend, Monday you’ll be out of here.”
I asked him, “Do you see how filthy this place is and you’re still gonna leave me here?” There was no response.
Mr. Clark introduced me to the foster mother, Mrs. Sanchez, who could not speak English very well, so her daughter interpreted our conversation. Before I knew it, Mr. Clark was walking out the door.
As they showed me to the room where I was supposed to sleep, horror struck my eyes. The door was almost on the verge of falling off the hinges. Although the room was very small, it had three beds, a closet, and a night stand where the telephone rested. The room was cluttered with paper, shoes, toys, and clothes thrown all over the floor.
Crowded Quarters
In one corner of the room stood an old sewing machine and in another corner was a basket overflowing with dirty laundry. The sheets on the bed were filthy and had an awful odor. “Didn’t they inspect this house before they decided to put me here?” This was the question that went through my mind.
It was late, so I decided to go to bed and make myself as comfortable as I could. But before I did, two other foster children came to the house, who were also supposed to be moved when the weekend was up.
I shared that small room with six other people: myself, Marilyn (the other foster girl), Lea (who was my foster mom’s daughter), and Mrs. Sanchez’s three grandchildren. I slept on the bottom of the bunk bed and Marilyn slept on the top. Lea slept in the bed on the opposite side of the room with the other three children.
Filthy Conditions
The sight of the bathroom immediately sickened me as I saw it the next morning. It smelled of urine. The floor was wet with water that seemed to be coming from the ceiling, the tiled walls of the bathroom were covered with grime, and the bathtub-which was supposed to be white-had rings and rings of dirt, which proved that it had not been cleaned for a while.
I refused to even look twice at the toilet bowl for fear that I would throw up at the sight. Had these people never heard about flushing the toilet after using it? Was it a mistake that the toilet bowl was left so filthy, or was it a lack of training? I didn’t know the answer to these questions, so I didn’t want to judge. Again, I began to feel anxious as Monday was three whole days away.
I did not speak very much to my foster mother because it was very difficult to communicate because of the language barrier between us. That Saturday morning I was very anxious to get to church. I just needed to see some order, since the house that I was in had none. A sigh of relief came over me as I walked into my church and saw a familiar place. I spent the whole day at my church, so I passed Saturday quite well. For me, the fact that I was in care was not the problem-the house that I was placed in was the problem.
I spent Sunday trying to clean the kitchen the best way I could. I washed the dishes, wiped the cupboards, and swept the floor. That is as far as I was willing to go. For the rest of the day I watched television and read periodically. Almost everyone had gone out somewhere except for myself and Lea, who was laying in her bed. Marilyn was outside hanging out.
The Monday that I’d waited so long for finally came. Someone from my agency called and told me that they would be picking me up at 10 o’clock. I was dressed and waiting. My bags were packed and I was ready to go. A short while later I was out of there, on my way to my new and permanent foster home (which is clean and well-kept, by the way).
Was There An Alternative?
As I look back on the days I spent in that house, I believe no one should have to live in a situation like that. Why did my social worker leave me there after he saw the mess the house was in? Was it because there was no alternative? Was it because he did not care, so he pretended he was blind to the existing conditions? Or was he just too busy to look for another home for me? Was that home the only one available?
I strongly feel that when a home is not appropriate, the child should not be allowed to stay there, and the foster parents should be held accountable.
Foster homes-whether temporary or permanent-should be visited frequently by social workers and other officials in the system. It is also important to make surprise visits, in order to really see what the homes look like. If a visit is announced, it allows time to clean a home that has been in chaos for months.
For some foster parents, it is very hard to keep a clean home. It takes extra effort to do so, but a caring parent should be willing to go that extra mile for the safety of the child. A home that is not in order can cause problems to little children. For example, children can hurt themselves on items left lying around.
Is it fair to us that we as foster children should be placed in dirty homes? Why does it seem as if not much effort is put into finding clean homes for us? Would any of the social workers or officials like to see their children living in some of the dirty homes that foster children are placed in?
I don’t think so. Children in care are just as important as any other child who is not in care, yet that sometimes does not seem to be the case.
No Excuse for Dirty Homes
Reading this story, someone might say, “Well, there aren’t enough foster homes out there. Besides, that home was only a temporary placement, and it was the best the system could do.”
Well, this is my response: If that’s the best the system can do, then I don’t want to see the worst. The system needs to run a tighter ship and keep abreast with the conditions of the homes. There is no legitimate excuse for any home to be so dirty, whether there are foster kids there or not, whether the stay is temporary or not. To me, an unsanitary home is an unsafe home and that’s that!
The system can assist foster parents by giving workshops on how to keep a clean and tidy home. They should be taught the importance of having a home free of pests, and full of happy, clean, and well-cared for children.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.