According to the Citizens Committee for Children of New York, 41% of children admitted into foster care come from families that have not received preventive services that might have kept the family together, such as family counseling, parenting classes, job readiness training, day care, and substance abuse treatment. Over 70% of the families with children in foster care have substance abuse problems, but these services have been cut.
How the Money’s Spent
Robert Little, former head of the Child Welfare Administration (now the ACS), was quoted in 1993 in an interview in FCYU as saying, “I don’t believe we ought to remove a child because the family lives in a raggedy apartment. I think it would be money better spent to try to find a way to help that family move into a better apartment, than to just remove the children. If we removed the children, we’re gonna pay $20,000 a year, at least, to keep a child in foster care. And for probably an additional $300 a month, we could relocate the family into a better situation.”
That $20,000 per child includes the cost of medical care, psychological testing and treatment, caseworker salaries, and a whole range of other services that are offered.
When I was in foster care, I remember having blood work done by a private medical organization every time I had a six-month check up, carfare money that was given by the agency, and the list goes on and on. Like I said before, there’s a lot of money and help given to families that are apart. More financial assistance should be given to keep them together.
Welfare vs. Foster Care
It’s been said that people who go on welfare are cheating the system. But if the State took a survey of the foster parents who spend the money they receive on their mortgages and save it in their bank accounts, rather then spend it on the children in their care, the number would be surprising. My biological mother spent the whole check on us, and many a time she did without food so that we could have something to eat.
It is not uncommon for some foster parents who have taken care of a lot of foster children over their long careers to move down south (or other places) with fat bank accounts. Compare this to people on welfare, who on average aren’t able to accumulate enough money for food by the end of the month, let alone save enough to relocate.
(For the foster mothers and fathers who are sincere in word and deed, this article isn’t aimed at you. It is pointed at those foster parents who aren’t doing right by the funds that they are given-funds that would have been better spent helping my mother maintain her home rather then lose her children to something as large as the New York City child welfare bureaucracy.)
There is also a different level of respect that foster parents receive, as compared with people on welfare. People on welfare often have to go through a lot of b.s. just to get by, while foster parents are given the utmost respect for making a living by taking care of someone else’s children. Sometimes children are taken from abusive homes and are put into a more abusive home than the one they were in. To me, this kinda defeats the purpose.
The lack of respect for poor families can be seen in foster care agencies, in the way caseworkers sometimes treat foster mothers as opposed to the children’s real mothers. Sit back and watch the way each is treated. (It doesn’t have to be your own family, which might make you take a more emotional approach to peeping what’s happening. Watch how they handle someone else’s case when that family comes to visit their own.) See the difference in the attitude the worker has when he/she approaches the foster parent as opposed to the child’s real mother or father.
Divided Loyalties
First listen to the tone of the conversation, then look at the difference in body language that caseworkers sometime show to real mothers and then foster mothers. See if you can peep the confused looks on the faces of the children. Confusion brought on because the child is torn between loyalties.
This touches on the matter of pride families with children in foster care have, and it is being stripped away from them. How does a family feel if their children are taken away, when they did their best in almost impossible conditions to raise their children? This just doesn’t seem fair, or even logical to me. I don’t know if this is about racism, but I do know that the numbers speak for themselves.
Racial Stats
African-Americans make up 59% of all the children in care in New York City. Hispanics make up 18% of the children in care. Only two percent of these children are White. These numbers aren’t surprising in the face of some of the other statistics about the communities so-called minorities live in. Some 885,000 children live in poverty in New York City, most of them Black and Latino. And the numbers are increasing. Do a little research and you’ll see what I’m talking about.
“So what does this all mean to me?” is a question that I know a great many of you must be asking yourselves by now (or should be asking yourselves!). How do you feel about all of this?
I know that I feel angry, upset, and a little bitter to have seen and to still keep seeing the people in my neighborhood dying every day. Fighting over things that people in other communities have so much of and take for granted. Brothers and sisters just struggling to survive, while others waste what they have. This says a lot about the world we’re living in, the city we’re living in.
Longer Time in Care
It angers me to know to know that the community where I live (Harlem), which is located in the richest and most powerful city in the world, has the greatest percentage of low birthweight babies in the city. It is a neighborhood with one of the highest concentrations of children, yet the least number of libraries per child.
The more funding cut from our communities, the higher the rate of children entering foster care. From 1991 to 1995, the length of time children spend in care has gotten longer. Over 80% of children ages 6 to 17 in care in New York City are staying more than three years in the system.
This in the face of our “savior” Bill Clinton, who passed a crime bill which approved nearly $8 billion in funding for new prisons over the next five years. Prisons which are filled with people from neighborhoods that you and I most likely come from. This is going on all over the country, while welfare received massive cuts. It makes me really wonder what this country’s so-called leaders are doing. They seem prepared to do nothing for the poor but build more prisons.
Less Help for the Poor
All of the New York City neighborhoods that I grew up in were crippled by poverty and were failed by the system turning its back on the poor-and by system, I mean all the way from the White House to City Hall. The numbers show this to be true.
What makes them think that less help for the poor and more prisons are going to save the poor? Do they really even give a damn?
When Is Foster Care Necessary?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.