The new welfare bill that was passed by Congress and signed by the President over the summer takes away the federal government’s guarantee of food, money, and medical insurance for the very poor, gives the money to the states and tells them to design their own programs. There are, however, a few regulations the states have to follow. These are the most important:
o No one can receive welfare for more than five years in a lifetime. “Let’s say I have a kid that’s three years old. I’m receiving welfare and I stay on it for five years,” said Liz Kreuger, associate director of Community Food and Resource Center, which works with families on welfare. “My child has already used up her lifetime limit for assistance.” If when her daughter grows up she needs assistance, “She’s already used up her five years. The clock doesn’t start going [again].”
While the law also says that no person should receive welfare for more than two years in a row, Krueger said the states have the flexibility to extend that up to the five-year lifetime limit.
o Teen mothers will not be eligible for welfare unless they are living with an adult and are going to school or getting their GED as soon as their child is at least 12 weeks old. The only way for them to avoid living with an adult is if they can prove (with a police report, for example) that there is some kind of abuse going on at home. Teen mothers whose parents are on welfare will now be counted as part of the same family, instead of a separate one, which means a lot less money.
o Non-citizens will no longer be eligible for any benefits. The only exceptions are immigrants who come here with a status of a refugee and are running away from political persecution (seeking asylum). People who will have their Medicaid cut off as a result of the new law may be able to keep it for up to a year, however.
o Single mothers have to name the father of their child. If they don’t, their benefits will be cut by 25%.
o People convicted of drug felonies will not be eligible for cash assistance or food stamps. The only exceptions are pregnant women and people undergoing drug treatment.
The states can choose to eliminate welfare, child care, social services, and non-emergency Medicaid, beginning January 1, 1997. People who apply for benefits now will be subject to the new restrictions effective immediately. Others will have their benefits cut off and reduced as their cases come up for review.
In addition, Krueger said the states can make up any number of their own rules. For example, “If I have one child and I’m on welfare, the state can choose not to give me money for [a] second child,” said Krueger. Another example of the things the states could, theoretically, decide to do is require anyone under 21 on welfare to be in school or to require all recipients to be in some kind of government work program.
On the other side, some states may be forced to find the money elsewhere to provide for needs not being met by federal funds. The New York State constitution has a section requiring that the state provide “the aid, care, and support of the needy.”
But according to Krueger, “There’s already noise from the Republicans that [they] will fight [to change the constitution]…some people started to say that…it’s too expensive for New York to have to take the responsibility. New York is the only state out of 50 [to have this law]. It looks like they are going to [change it].”
This is Going to Hurt
In the meantime, she estimates that 150,000 people in New York City alone will lose their foodstamps (a federal program). “There’s going to be a lot of pain,” she said, “an increase in homelessness, families having to give up their children to foster care, hospitals [overcrowded], illness and disease that should have never happened…”
“There’s all kinds of complications in families,” she explained. “For example, if you come to the U.S., and I’m the one who sponsored you. I’ve got a job. I earn $1,000 a month. You and your parent earn $1,000 a month each. We also live with your grandmother who receives SSI and Medicaid. We have two families-six people living in the same apartment. One family gets cut off SSI and Medicaid. We went from $3,000 to $2,000 a month. Grandma needs health care. She has heart problems. Now we spend $500 on her health care every month out of our own pocket. The rent is $900. That leaves us with $600 a month for six people. That’s $100 a month for each person for food, clothing, utilities, school supplies, etc.”
‘Kids Falling Apart’
Krueger expects poverty to increase as a result of the new bill. “We [already] have 700 soup kitchens who have to turn away like 1,500 people,” she said. “We will see more people on the streets.”
Krueger said kids will start “falling apart” because many of them won’t have enough to eat and won’t do as well in school. If they share a room with 10 people and don’t get any sleep at night, either, they might not care as much about what happens during the day, she explained.
“Crime will go up, we’ll put many people in jail, which is the most expensive model we have, and the stupidest. You can’t create a society where everyone is put in jail.”
But she said it will take a while before the effects of the new law become clear. “When five years [have] passed, that’s when we’re going to see the explosion,” she said. “Families losing their apartments, families having to give up their child to the government because they would rather give them up than have them live on the streets with them.”
‘Deeper in the Hole’
Asked how she can be so sure, Kruger said, “because we can look at other countries,” that didn’t help poor people. In Central America, for example, “children [were] abandoned by families [who] couldn’t take care of their children,” she said.
“There is nothing good about the bill,” Krueger emphasized. She said we are giving a little more money to child care, but the number of children who need it will triple. She said that we are going to spend more money than we can possibly save. We will put more people in prison, since there will be more crime. We will spend more money on child care, foster care, and homeless shelters. “It puts us in the hole further than we were.”
As to what people can do, Krueger said, “They can educate themselves better about what the real causes of poverty are” and undo the stereotype that people are poor because of something they did-that it’s their own fault. She said people should contact their legislators and the governor and let them know how they feel.
It’s All About Jobs
Krueger agreed that the welfare system we had before wasn’t perfect. “It had flaws in it, but because we didn’t have enough money to invest in it. We kept cutting. What was broken is this country’s failure to recognize that we don’t have enough jobs for the people.”
For her, “helping people to find jobs-that’s the only way this program can work. But I think New York doesn’t have any intention [of doing that]. We don’t have the money.” Krueger says the day will come when the whole country wakes up, looks at this welfare bill and says, “What have we done?”
The New Welfare Reform Bill: What It Really Means
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.