I’ve lived in two group homes and two foster homes in the past five years. (For the past year I have lived in a foster home.) Now that I have had both experiences, I’ve found out I much prefer being in a foster home.
In the foster home I live in now, I get treated better than I did in the group homes. One of the most important differences for me is being able to talk to my foster mother about my problems. She listens to me and gives me advice or tells me what to do about my problems.
When I had problems in the group home the staff would listen, but I felt that they didn’t really care. And since I felt that they didn’t care about me, I didn’t care about anybody else. It wasn’t just me who felt that way-all the other girls acted like they didn’t care about anybody else around them.
More Respect and More Freedom
Now that I’m in a foster home I’ve changed. I care more about others, I’m more respectful and I control my anger better.
There are lots of other differences in the way I’ve been treated since I’ve moved from a group home into my foster home. Most things are better. In my foster home I don’t have to deal with a lot of things that I used to deal with in the group home. I have much more respect and a little more freedom.
For example, in a group home the staff tells you what time to go to sleep. In the group home I lived in, you had to go to sleep at 9 p.m. on school days and at 11 p.m. or 11:30 on weekends. (Actually, we were lucky if we could stay up until 11 p.m.; if the girls made too much noise or argued, we had to go earlier.) In my foster home you can go to sleep when you’re ready.
I don’t think it’s fair that the group home has bedtime rules because sometimes you want to stay up and bug out or there’s a good movie that’s coming on late and you want to stay up and see it. But you can’t because when they say bedtime, it’s bedtime. There’s no question about it or you’ll be punished.
In my foster home I can stay up as late as I want. I turn off the TV when I’m tired of watching it. On weekends I usually go to sleep at 1 a.m., but I sometimes stay up till 3 or 4 a.m. if I’m watching another good movie on HBO. On a weekday I usually go to sleep at 11 p.m., but if I’m watching something I can stay up later. Although my foster parents don’t set any limits on bedtimes, on school nights they sometimes say I should go to bed so I’ll be able to wake up for school.
Always Asking Permission
Another thing that bothered me in my old group home was that you had to ask permission to turn on the TV or radio, use the phone, or even go down in the basement to play pool. You had to ask permission for most everything. You had to let them know when you were hungry so they could give you the stuff you need from the fridge to make yourself a sandwich. (They don’t allow residents in the fridge without permission.) But in a foster home you don’t have to ask permission for those things. They let you do it yourself because they know you’re old enough to fix your own lunch.
In a group home there’s a day that you’re supposed to do laundry and you can only do it that day. The group home that I was in two years ago had a chart with people’s names and the weekday and the weekend that each person could do laundry. Now I can do my laundry any day I want. I don’t have to wait until it’s all piled up in a corner and making the room stink.
I know some group homes have washers and dryers too. But that doesn’t mean you can do the wash whenever you feel like it. It’s the rules, like they always say.
In a group home you have to eat dinner when they serve it. My old group home served dinner at 7:30 p.m. By that time I’d be starving to death. Sometimes I had to go to the store to get a snack before dinner so I wouldn’t starve. In my foster home, dinner is ready by the time I get to the front door from school. If my mother comes home from work late, my foster dad cooks.
In my last group home you were allowed to stay on the phone for 10 minutes. By the time you were getting into a good conversation you’d have to hang up. In my foster home I can stay on the phone for at least an hour.
Although I like almost everything about my foster home better than the group homes, there are a few things I miss, like being with other residents my age who I could talk to, and knowing some nice staff.
No Nose Rings
And there are some rules in my foster home which are set by my foster agency that I don’t like. My agency, Boys Town, is headed by a priest who makes the rules for the foster homes as well as the Boys Town group home. He doesn’t allow two holes in your ears, nose rings, or any sort of other piercing in your body. I happen to have four holes in my ear-I got the two extra holes before I came into the agency. So I only wear extra earrings when I’m going out. I don’t wear my nose ring, but that doesn’t bother me anymore because a lot of people say I look much better without it.
But I feel lucky to be in my foster home. It’s much easier for me to express my feelings to my foster mother than to group home staff. I trust her and don’t have to worry that she’s gonna tell a resident or the whole staff about my personal problems. Since there’s only one or two foster children, it’s much easier to talk to a foster parent than a staff.
I’d Rather Live in a Foster Home than a Group Home
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.