Dear Peter:
This letter is my gift to you, to your brother Hector, to your sister Mindi, and to the little one who came afterward. It will tell you how you came to be in foster care. I will keep this letter safe until the time when you are able to read it, along with the few pictures I have and my memories of all of you.
Even as I write this letter, I still hold a place inside myself for hope, that perhaps things will change long before you read this: that your mother will get the help she needs, and that her boyfriend will either disappear or get off the crack pipe.
But just in case that doesn’t happen, Peter, here is my explanation to you of why you’re in foster care today. I know there was a time in my own life when I longed for such an answer, because when I was a child, I was in foster care, too.
January 1989
This is where our story-yours and mine-begins.
Peter, you were born in March 1989, to your mother Rayona-who was 17, unmarried, out of school, and still living with your grandparents in the Bronx.
You were born on my 19th birthday, about one year after your uncle and I broke up. But we were still friends, and as I was helping your uncle move out of the neighborhood, I saw Rayona on the corner, her belly filled with you.
She was small and thin and young, except for her rounded stomach, and a shy smile crossed her face as we talked about your arrival. I asked Rayona if she was eating well. She said she ate a slice of pizza every day. I suggested that maybe she needed to eat more. She said she couldn’t afford to.
Your father, Ted, lived across the street. I don’t know what the story was there. At first he and Rayona looked like they were going to try to be a team in your upbringing, but that soon faded. I hardly saw him around when Rayona was pregnant with you.
After you were born, Peter, the hospital didn’t let you go home with your mother right away because they found cocaine in your blood. I did not know at the time that Rayona smoked the stuff. She would only admit to marijuana, and I wanted to believe her.
But I did see you in the hospital. You were in the maternity ward of North Central Bronx. The place had broken plastic chairs in the waiting room and stank of piss.
A Small Angel
You were small but perfect. Rayona picked you up out of the hospital crib, and you started to fuss. She placed quick, light, little kisses all over your face to comfort you.
Years later, she admitted that, yes, while you were being born and pushing your way out through her loins and causing her pain, she did smoke crack to take the edge off, just before the ambulance came.
You did not come home until you were three months old. Rayona had to go into rehab, and after she was discharged, they felt that she, with your grandmother’s help, could take care of you.
I saw you again when you were one year old. You looked like a small angel, Peter-a Christmas tree ornament with rosy cheeks and loose blond curls framing your face. You crawled around on a dirty carpet while your grandmother and Rayona smoked cigarettes and bragged about how smart you were, how much you’d grown. I thought to myself, Well, it’s not the cleanest place to raise a child, but I’ve lived in dirtier foster homes, and he seems happy.
Anthony, my boyfriend at the time, thought otherwise.
A Call to Social Services
“Diane,” Anthony said, “that kid is in trouble. Did you see that house? And he’s crawling around on a dirty carpet with plastic bags lying around!”
“Well, what do you want to do?” I asked.
“I’m calling social services. They need to look at that house.”
In my gut, I knew he was right. But having survived seven foster homes, I knew there was no guarantee, Peter, that the system would be better for you.
Anthony called. Social workers came. They looked and found no problem. Rayona was furious. She never found out who reported her.
May 1993
Rayona and I lost touch. She was busy with you, and I was 21 and busy with college and still living with my foster parents, the last and best ones I would ever have. It was your Aunt Myra who first told me how serious things had become.
“Diane, we have to talk,” Myra said to me one day.
“What’s the matter?”
“Well, I called Rayona’s house because I hadn’t spoken to them in a long time. Rayona answered the phone, and we decided to get together to bring the kids to the park.”
“And?”
“And, Diane, Peter looks like a starving orphan.”
I paused. “What do you mean?”
“I mean,” Myra said, “that my daughter Rachel and him are both four years old-Peter’s three months older than her, in fact. And Rachel towered over Peter. I mean towered. He looks maybe two years old. He’s not potty trained. He’s still in diapers. And he can’t talk. When we brought him to the park it seemed like he was afraid of the kids and the sunlight, and he screamed when we put him on the swing.”
“Oh, wow.”
“And,” Myra said, the sound of tears in her voice, “when Rayona changed his diaper, I could see…I could see his hip bones poking through the skin.”
It was time for me to get back into your life, Peter.
I’m sorry I didn’t do it sooner.
July 1993
I figured the Fourth of July would be a good way to reintroduce myself back into your life, so I called Rayona.
“Long time no see,” I said, and so on. “How about I pick you and Peter up and we have a picnic in Van Cortlandt Park?”
“Sure,” Rayona said. “By the way, I’m expecting again.”
“Oh,” I said. “Congratulations. Ted’s?”
“Hell, no!” she laughed. “My husband’s name is Hector. He’s the building super.”
“Oh, you got married!” I said, truly happy for her.
“Ah, no…” Rayona said. “He’s my man.”
So “husband” meant “man” meant “boyfriend.” I would learn a lot of street lingo in the next few years.
Tiny and Frightened
Peter, when we got together in the park, you looked just as Aunt Myra had described. You were skinny and small, way underweight for your age. At four years old, you knew three words: yellow, ball, and key. Your diaper did nothing to keep your ill-fitting pants from falling down on your waist.
Rayona looked like I’d last seen her-the same glasses she’d worn for years, the same unkempt, light brown hair, no makeup, home-girlish-type clothes, trying to hide the very obvious fact that she was a White girl in a mostly Black and Latino neighborhood in the Bronx. You were happy to see me and my boyfriend, Anthony. Anthony cared about you very much, Peter. You brought out a side of him I’d rarely seen.
In the park you were very frightened of everything-the swings, the kids, the sand. We didn’t push you; we just let you explore at your own pace.
Eventually, you loosened up a little bit. You were sucking your thumb, something you must have done a lot because it was callused from your teeth.
July 1993- March 1995
During this time, Anthony and I tried to schedule at least one outing with you a month: to the park, to the zoo, to the beach. Rayona gave birth to your brother, Hector Jr., and stopped coming out with us. Sometimes when we picked you up she wasn’t home, and your grandmother had no idea where she was. Sometimes she disappeared with Hector, her “man,” and Hector Jr. for days.
You needed preschool badly, Peter, otherwise you would have never made it through kindergarten. You still weren’t talking very much and were still scared of lots of normal things other kids weren’t scared of. My foster father, James, suggested we get you into a Head Start program, and the application required you to get a full physical exam.
That’s when Rayona started getting weird.
“I have all his papers,” she said. “Why does he need to go to the doctor again?”
“Because it’s required to get into school, Rayona,” I said, “all the kids have to.”
“Well, I can’t get an appointment for him until next month.”
“That’s too late,” I said. “He’ll miss the deadline.”
Peter, your mother did not want you to go to the doctor. Under protest, she allowed me to bring you, and I made her sign a permission slip.
Terrified of the Doctor
I found out why she didn’t want you to go. First, you acted as if you’d never seen a doctor before. Most kids are scared of the doctor, but Peter, you were absolutely hysterical. We had to wait a long time until you calmed down, and even then, one of us had to hold you down to get examined. You kept screaming, “No! No! No!” in absolute fear of your life.
“Where is this kid’s mother?” the doctor angrily demanded.
“She couldn’t come,” I said.
“I have half a mind to call social services,” the doctor said. “Look at this kid! Look at the way he’s dressed-his hair, his clothes, the way he thinks we’re going to kill him! He has the height, weight, and language of a two-year-old! This is neglect!”
“If that’s what you need to do, Doctor,” I said, “then by all means…”
When your blood test came back, it showed lead poisoning. By law, the Department of Health had to visit your house. They came and, like the social workers before, found nothing wrong.
Anthony and I tried calling social services many times, always anonymously, because we didn’t want Rayona to stop us from seeing you and your brother. We had started to see one too many bruises on your back and your face, and Rayona couldn’t possibly have been caring very well for you and Hector Jr., we thought, if she was always still asleep by noon.
But every time it was the same story: The social workers would call and warn Rayona they were coming, she’d quickly clean up you kids and the house, dance for them, and off they’d go.
Peter, I was over your house one time before the social workers came, and I heard your mother and grandmother have the following conversation:
“Damn, ma! These f-cking people in this f-cking building can’t mind their damn business!” Rayona said. “BCW is coming again, saying there’s a report that I mistreat my kids.”
Your grandmother, who had all of her own six children in foster care at one time or another (including Rayona), just smiled.
“This is what you do when they come,” she told Rayona. “Make sure they don’t have any bruises, then dress them all in white outfits.”
“Why?”
“Because,” your grandmother told your mother, “it makes it look like you have nothing to hide.”
Roaches and Pot
Peter, another conversation I had with Rayona was even more disturbing. It was right after one of the social worker visits. We were talking about a woman who had been in the newspaper for getting high and killing her child.
“That’s bullsh-t!” Rayona said. “You know how many times I’ve gotten booted in front of my kids, and I haven’t killed them?”
Rayona had a third child, your sister Mindi. She was born healthy and chubby. Rayona seemed happy to have a girl. But the roaches in the room where the six of you lived (your mother, Hector Sr., Hector Jr., Mindi, you, and your Aunt Barbi) were so bad that Rayona had to have a zippered screen over Mindi’s crib at all times. She was always sick and running a fever. All of you had trouble breathing because the house was always filled with pot and cigarette smoke.
A Suicide Attempt
Somewhere during this time, your mother tried to kill herself. She was in the mental ward of Jacobi Hospital for a week. She never said why, and later denied that she had tried to commit suicide. The story from the neighbors was that she and Hector got into a fight, and he hit her. She grabbed a knife and either cut herself on purpose or accidentally. You and your brother and sister were in the room when it happened.
“Mommy cut!” you told us, Peter, waving your hand in a slashing motion.
There was also another time when your mom and Hector Sr. got into a fight with the landlord. As your grandmother told it, the landlord barged into the apartment waving a gun, with you and your brother sleeping nearby.
By June 1994, Anthony and I decided you needed to be out of the house for the summer and offered to pay for a special summer camp that would pick you up from your house every day and drop you off back home. All Rayona had to do was wake up to bring you downstairs in the morning and make sure she was at the corner in the afternoon.
After two weeks, Anthony and I found out only by accident that Rayona had pulled you out of summer camp and was living in a shelter on the Grand Concourse. Rayona had asked the camp director for a refund of the money we’d spent to send you to the day camp, cashed the check, and split. Rayona was on a bender, with all of you in tow.
“What are we going to do?” I pleaded with Anthony.
“It’s time,” he said, “that we put something in writing to the BCW.”
“But then they’ll go into foster care!” I said. “I don’t want to put them into foster care! That might not be better than what they have now! It might be worse!”
“Diane,” Anthony said, “right now, as I see it, those kids have a zero percent chance of making it. If they go into foster care, they automatically get a 50% chance at a better life.”
Contacting Foster Care
“That’s a hell of a way,” I said, “to make a decision about someone’s life.”
But so it was done. With a heavy, heavy heart, Peter, and with your medical records, school reports, and pictures, I sent a letter in triplicate to the heads of social services for the state, city, and Bronx county.
In the letter, I told the heads of each department what Anthony, your Aunt Myra, your uncles Stan and Paul, and I had witnessed over the years- Rayona’s disappearances, your obvious malnourishment, the bruises-and told them that if they didn’t come and give you and your mother the intervention services you desperately needed, I would make sure the letter was in every newsroom in New York. All of us signed it, along with my own foster parents.
Into a Foster Home
Within days, I received a personal letter from CWA Commissioner Kathryn Croft that said-surprise, surprise-that a worker had visited your home in response to our letter and deemed the family “in need of intervention services.” A nice social worker then practically lived with you kids and your mother for 10 weeks.
But on March 8, 1995, shortly before your 7th birthday, Peter, and right after the nice worker left, your teacher called BCW to report that you had come to school with cigarette and match burns on your face. You and your brother and sister were removed immediately.
Anthony and I, along with your aunt and uncles, were subpoenaed by the Bronx County Family Court three times following your placement in care. Each time, your mother didn’t show up. The fourth time, Rayona did-by now she knew that we had reported her-and her belly was again big with another child.
We asked your mother’s caseworker what was going to happen to this child once it was born. The caseworker looked surprised and said, “She’s pregnant?”
Peter, Please Understand
After a year of court delays, Rayona pleaded guilty to a neglect charge, which gave the three of you an automatic extension in the foster home where you’d all been placed.
I still don’t know if your mother had a boy or a girl, Peter. But I do try to talk to your social worker at least once a month.
Your mother and Hector Sr. said Anthony and I are forbidden to visit or talk with any of you, but the social worker said she’ll share with you any letters we send. I hope she has shared at least some of them.
You three have been in the same foster home for almost two years now. The social worker says you are all growing up healthy and strong-that you, Peter, are on a soccer team and doing well in special ed classes, that Hector Jr. is in Head Start, and that Mindi is walking and talking up a storm.
I hope all of you are really as happy as she describes.
So, Peter, if you one day read this letter, please understand. I didn’t want to have to put you guys into foster care. Having been there myself, I was torn apart inside.
But as Anthony wisely said, sometimes it’s half a chance-or none.
Love,
Diane, Anthony,
Myra, Stan, and Paul
Diane West is a financial reporter who lives in Manhattan. She was in the foster care system from 1979 through 1991.
Half a Chance-Or None: Dear Peter…
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.