On Wednesday, January 29, I met with ACS Commissioner Nicholas Scoppetta, to discuss the new plan for reforming the child welfare system. And don’t we all know this system needs lots of changes!
The plan talks a lot about strengthening child protection procedures to prevent tragedies like the killing of Elisa Izquierdo. I am pleased to see the report talk about family unification strategies and better training of foster parents and social workers.
But during my 13 years in care, I’ve heard so many promises about change that I don’t have full faith or confidence in this one. When I told the Commissioner how I felt, he assured me that this plan is different. He said there is a lot of attention now focused on the child welfare system, due to the death of young kids like Elisa. He promised that there will be better investigative services in order to decrease the number of deaths of innocent children (sounds very promising). But only time will tell if changes will be made for the sake of young people in care.
James: I’ve been in the foster care system for 13 years, and I’ve heard many promises about change. How is this report and this reform different?
Scoppetta: We’ve had 48 reports that were done over the last 20 years on child welfare. They have a lot in common with each other, but the recommendations were not implemented. For this report, we interviewed hundreds of people in and out of the agency. We had focus groups of caseworkers, supervisors, and managers. We also talked to people in…Philadelphia, Cleveland, Seattle, Los Angeles, and Baltimore…
The report is very self-critical and self-analytical. We analyzed the agency [ACS] and didn’t hesitate to say what was wrong with it. Why is this report different? I think the most important thing about it is that we did it ourselves, on ourselves. We are in existence this past year as a separate free-standing agency for the first time. And I report directly to the Mayor. There’s nobody in between unlike the old structure, where CWA was under HRA [Human Resources Administration] and HRA had to report to the Deputy Mayor, and the Deputy Mayor had to report to the Mayor, etc.
The structure is different, the fact that the agency stands alone is different, and the fact that the Mayor has made this a very high priority. We are the only agency that is exempt from budget cuts and hiring freezes. Following the death of Elisa Izquierdo, there was tremendous attention focused on child welfare. Now that has happened before, and then it died down and went away. It hasn’t happened this time, because the Mayor has kept the issue on the front burner…I’m confident we’re going to get funding for the reforms that we will be able to implement during the coming year.
James: Were any youth in foster care involved in making this report?
Scoppetta: Oh, sure! We’ve talked to FCYU and there was a speakout of foster care kids at Hunter College. They were really helpful. A lot of the things that relate to foster care come out of our conversations with youth–in particular through the independent living programs…I was also in foster care myself.
James: The report says that the “culture” of foster care in New York City must be changed. Describe what you mean by the culture of foster care.
Scoppetta: The culture of the agency I think comes from decades of neglect of the child welfare system. It has been one of demoralization, sort of a conviction that things could not be changed… That was the state of affairs for many, many years…
For example, when I came here, while there was this big budget, the agency was dramatically understaffed. So, you have this budget that says you could have 3000 caseworkers, but you’re limping along at 2000 caseworkers. It doesn’t help you to have that big budget if you’re not able to staff up to budget.
James: From my personal dealings with foster parents, I’ve seen that they were only in it for the money. How do you plan on changing that attitude among foster parents? How do you plan to recruit better foster parents who aren’t in it for the money?
Scoppetta: Recruitment and training of foster parents are very important factors. We have a lot of programs in mind. In recruiting additional foster parents, I think it’s important that you get the best foster parents possible. One program in particular is very appealing because it does more than just give us more foster parents. It’s modeled after something called “One Church, One Child,” which is based in Chicago. The idea is quite simple–every house of worship would produce one set of adoptive parents every year. If we did that, we would more than double the adoptions in New York, because we have thousands of houses of worship… When we started this program we had one meeting in Brooklyn with more than 20 pastors.
Maybe 98% of our adoptions last year were a combination of Latinos and African-Americans. We’re starting in the communities, hoping that this will produce more adoptive parents. Not only to give us more adoptive parents, but to give us foster parents in the neighborhoods where we need them most.
In addition, it gives us an opportunity to do lots of other things. Through the church, we have access on a local level to the communities. And I think another problem that the agency has is it doesn’t necessarily have the trust and confidence of all the communities. People think of us as people who are here to take the babies or the kids. But we do so much more than that.
James: Currently, it takes ACS four and a half years on average to find permanent homes for children in foster care. But what are your plans to assist biological families to reunite instead of immediately putting kids up for adoption? Are there preventive services provided for biological parents to keep families together?
Scoppetta: Well, that’s an average time of stay but it’s skewed. It’s a little misleading because if you have a child who comes in as a one-year-old and stays until 18, your really skewing the average. Eighty percent of the kids go back to their family or relatives. That’s why I think keeping family together is important. We spend $53 million a year for preventive services for biological parents. We also try to provide biological parents with help and services in order to get their children back.
James: During my 13 years in the system, I was never invited to a case conference [a conference where you have the right to meet with your agency to discuss your goals and future plans]. Will young people be more involved in these meetings and in planning their own futures?
Scoppetta: Lots of things weren’t being done, but I’ll try to enforce that over a certain age. I haven’t decided that yet. I don’t think it makes sense to have a four year old or five year old to [go to these conferences].
James: The report mentions preparing young adults for aging out of the system. How do you think youth can be involved in planning and shaping the new independent living program you’re working on?
Scoppetta: I don’t think we do a good job on independent living training. I think we have to do a couple of things at a minimum, such as job training, how do you do a decent resume, and how do you conduct yourself at a job interview. Our goal is to help youth access the job market. I also think a lot of the youngsters need a little help in furthering their education.
James: How do you believe that young people should be involved in changing the system’s culture? And what is the best way for FCYU or other youth organizations to be involved in reforming the city’s foster care system?
Scoppetta: I would say one way is by doing things like this publication and other foster care groups. The fact that you’re well-organized makes it very easy for me to access your thinking. We set up a meeting [with youth] and discuss concerns and problems…I think this is one way that youngsters can participate. I also think it would be very useful if the contracted agencies would have meetings with youngsters in their care.
A Note From James:
I had mixed reactions to this interview, mainly because I’ve already heard the excessive verbal ying-yang (talk) of changes and reform. I’m not dogging the plan. I did get answers from the Commissioner, but they weren’t always concrete answers. I think it would take two or three more interviews to get a better understanding of where the Commissioner is coming from and where ACS is heading.
I know it took a lot of hard work and patience to come up with a plan such as this one, so I give Commissioner Scoppetta and child welfare officials their props for putting it together. I only hope that they will keep their word in making these changes.
Exclusive FCYU Interview: Commissioner Scoppetta Talks About Change
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.