Can We Keep This Family Together?

Young people, think ACS is not listening to us? Well, I’ve come to realize that they are. (Not as often as they should, but they’re trying.)
On January 16, ACS asked 14 young people (including me) who are or have been in foster care to join some of their staff in a meeting. We were to look at some specific family cases in order to help ACS figure out the general needs of these families, such as housing, food or money (you know how that goes). Basically, we acted as if we were caseworkers deciding how to help a family we’ve just met for the first time. Our job was to give feedback about what services these various families need, and how this affects whether or not the children get moved into foster care, or whether the family is kept together while necessary services are provided. “I came with a whole mouthful to say,” said one young lady who, like me, was surprised to find the meeting to be a lot like a class in school. We sat at a table, our papers and pens in hand, with an easel in front of us (something like a chalkboard), ready to work.
Real Life Crisis
We each got a package with real family cases to look at. Most families we looked at had a substance abuse problem, which shows that drugs play a major role in so many lives within the city. (But we already knew that, didn’t we?)
Man, I almost pulled out my hair trying to figure out what steps I would take with these families if I were a caseworker (a career, by the way, I’m interested in). I thought it would be easy, but boy, was I in for a surprise. I found it very hard to look at a troubled family and find its “most pressing need” at the moment, without wanting to take care of everything at the same time. First Things First
For example, I got a family case where a baby is born with drugs in her system, while the mother and her two other kids live in an overcrowded apartment with an abusive boyfriend and an alcoholic grandmother. I wanted to save the baby, fix the mother’s drug problem, and get them a better apartment, all at the same time. But as the saying goes, “first things first.” I could only do one thing at a time. Those were the rules-to find the one thing the family needed first.
When I presented my case to the group, things got even more complicated. Almost everyone had a different view on what should be done first. Sometimes we argued for 15 to 20 minutes while a staff member sat there with her marker waiting for our decision. “OK guys,” she finally said, “three minutes to argue. Then we must have an answer-what’s the most pressing need of the family?”
What About the Baby?
Here’s the shortened discussion:
“I say mama dukes need to get off the drugs and kick the boyfriend to the curb,” said a young lady on my left. From my right came, “Yeah, but what about the baby?”
“Detox the baby,” someone else answered.
“Well, if the baby is in the hospital it will be detoxed.”
The discussion became more chaotic.
“Well where is the baby going to live? It can’t live in the hospital, you know. How long do you think the hospital is going to keep it there?”
“And grandma needs to leave the booze alone.”
“Yeah, but what about the baby?”
“Who should be first here, mom, the baby, or the rest of the family?”
“I say child safety is the most pressing need here.”
“The baby is gonna go to foster care?”
“Not necessarily,” the staff explained, “child safety doesn’t always mean foster care. It just means that right now the baby needs a stable home while the rest of the family gets worked on.”
This might be a case where the child is placed in care temporarily. Need for Counseling
In the next case, a 12-year-old girl lives with her grandmother. They have a good relationship, but the child is emotionally unstable. She has moved from being a good student to failing. She does not know how to bathe and dress herself properly. “What you mean she don’t know how to bathe herself at 12!?” came a voice from across the room. “When I was 12â”
“Well, maybe she wasn’t taught how to,” someone chimed in.
“Where’s her mother?”
“Mom’s not around.”
“Maybe that’s why she’s emotionally unstable.”
“Well, she needs some counseling and lessons in hygiene.”
“Well, I think grandma needs some type of help in raising a pre-teen.”
“Yep!”
“What about school?”
“Try addressing the emotional problem, then she could get tutoring to bring her back up in school.”
This case wasn’t as difficult as the first, but it was sad. In my opinion, what this family really needed was some psychological help for the 12-year-old so she could become stable. That does not mean medication, as most people think. It could just mean someone to talk to.
It was issues like these that had us picking our brains all day. At one point I did not want to look at any more cases. I wanted to go home. I had run out of ideas.
Sometimes we had to “beat around the bush” in order to come up with answers, but that’s what it’s all about-tossing ideas to and fro in order to figure out the answer. I learned that it’s not easy for caseworkers to determine the first thing to do when a family’s case is before them. This is not to excuse the system’s past failures. It’s just very hard to know the perfect answer to the problems troubled families face. That’s why ACS needs youth in care to give them insight and advice on these issues. Waking Up?
One young person asked the question, “What will happen to all the ideas that we gave?” The reply came, “Well, we are going to have another meeting with the commissioner and some other folks where they will take a look at the responses you gave, and try to see how and where they can use them.” My only hope is that ACS doesn’t “gas” us up and have us waste our time and brain cells.
For now, I have to give props to ACS, because after being asleep for so long they are finally waking up to the fact that they need the expertise of the most important people in the system-you and me. Let’s hope they use it.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.