Young Playwrights: The Drama of Their Lives

You were probably assigned to read “Hamlet” or “A Raisin in the Sun” for school. Maybe you got to see “Cats” or “Sarafina” on Broadway. But did you ever stop and think about where these plays came from, about the people who wrote them?
“A writer can only write what he knows,” declared prize-winning playwright David Rodriguez, 19, of Julia Richman HS. “Every writer writes about [his own] experience.”
David’s play “I’m Not Stupid,” which won first prize in the Young Playwrights Festival’s New York City High School Playwrighting Contest last year, deals with an autistic boy whose mother has a drinking problem. David’s own brother has autism, (a mental illness where people withdraw into their own private world) and his mother is a recovering alcoholic. Like the boy in his play, David has also been in psychiatric counseling.
Writing From Experience
In the second scene of “I’m Not Stupid,” the boy’s psychiatrist, Dr. Stein, pays the mother a visit. She is drunk and refers to her son as an animal: “I love Roger. It’s the kind of love you have for a pet…a dog, maybe. You give it a bath, feed it, clean up after it. Don’t get me wrong Dr. Stein. Did you expect me to love him as a son?” she asks. “How can I? He can’t do anything, except eat and sleep, like a dog.”
She insists that a dog will love anyone that feeds it. “They don’t know where the food comes from as long as it tastes good. They’ll eat it, then they’ll go back to sleep…Roger sleeps a lot. In a way, Roger isn’t a person. He’s a dog.”
In much the same way that David wrote “I’m Not Stupid” to help deal with some of his own problems, Nadirah Ameerah Fareed, 17, of Benjamin Cardozo HS, wrote her first play “The Only Way Out” after her best friend killed herself last October. “This was my way of dealing with the pain,” she explained. “I was crying as I was writing…It helped to write it out.”
At the beginning of the play, the character of Sheila is alone in her room praying to God, asking why her friend, Elisa, killed herself and wishing there were a way for Elisa to somehow explain.
Suddenly, Elisa’s ghost appears in the room. “I know that you’re still hurt and angry,” she says. “That’s why I came. When you understand why I did what I did, then I can rest in peace.”
A Second Chance
The two friends talk: Sheila about feeling “abandoned” and betrayed, about not being a good enough friend to Elisa. Elisa talks about feeling overwhelmed and needing a way out, about wanting to be forgiven, to be set free. In the end, the two friends hug, tell each other they love each other, and say good-bye.
“This was my way of expressing myself to [my friend],” said Nadirah, “my way of getting it out…and it helped.” Nadirah said she wished she had had a chance to speak to her friend again. In a way, the play gave her that chance.
Playwright Carla Debbie Alleyne, of New York University (NYU) has also lost people close to her. “A lot of friends of mine were dying and I wanted to put a stop to it,” she said. “I lived in the Crown Heights area and the drug problem was all over…in my high school, in my community…One day I just decided to write a play about drug dealing.”
The play is called “Hey Little Walter” after a song by the singing trio Tony Toni Tone! and uses rap music to tell the tale of two friends, Walter and Rakim, who become drug dealers and get killed by a rival gang. Where they leave off, Walter’s little brother, Albert, takes over.
Anti-Abuse, Anti-Suicide, Anti-Drug
All three of these plays contain their own messages about family, suicide, and crime that the writers draw from painful and destructive first-hand experiences. They are anti-abuse, anti-suicide, and anti-drug.
Carla pointed out that all but one character in her play is, in one way or another, a seller. They sell out themselves, their people, and their community. “Walter [does it] by dealing; Rakim by dealing also-all for money; Nicky for jewelry and attention; Mama by not paying attention to what her son was doing. The only strong character was the little sister, Latoya.”
“Both Walter and Rakim are confused,” she continued. “That’s why it’s easy for them to just jump in front of bullets, because deep down inside, they hate themselves. They have no identity, and that goes for a lot of people I grew up with.” By writing plays that allow people to take a good look at them-selves, Carla hopes to give them a greater sense of who they are.
Nadirah had something more specific in mind. She wanted to show others what it’s like to lose a friend to suicide. “I was trying to show people who were thinking of committing suicide the pain they bring to other people in their lives,” she said.
“Suicide is something serious and I don’t think people talk about it enough.”
While David’s play doesn’t have as direct a message about alcoholism or abuse, “I’m Not Stupid” is a portrait of one abuser/alcoholic. She is bitter, resentful, unaware of the damage she is causing and unwilling to seek help.
Getting the Message Across
If you are in any way a changed person when you walk out of the theatre,” said David, “that’s what makes a very good play work because [I as a playwright] got [my] message across.”
Getting that message across isn’t always such an easy task. For Carla, “[It] usually starts with a catchy title. Then I get the characters and make them interact and the play starts there.” But she added that sometimes getting started is the toughest part.
David agreed, “You have to be able to create people from scratch and…give them voices.” He said it was a challenge to “catch the reality…especially when you yourself don’t even know how you would react [in that situation.]”
Once you’ve gotten it off the ground, “A play must take on a life of its own,” he continued. “You must trust it to lead you wherever it’s going.”
Carla admitted that, even after her plays are finished, they always need to be worked on again and again. Like the others, she has been lucky enough to hear her play read aloud by real actors and to see the audience’s reaction. “It’s exciting to finally see the characters alive and moving,” said Carla. “But it just makes me want to work on the piece more and more until it’s perfect.”
In the case of “Hey Little Walter,” one of the things that meant was adding five powerful monologues known as “ghetto illusions” as well as the rap. “I put rap music in because I felt it was very pertinent to the play and the community Walter grew up in.”
The Young Playwrights Festival
Carla entered “Hey Little Walter” in the Young Playwrights Festival, a contest for writers under 19 years old. “I started entering the competition in high school in my ninth [grade] year and each year I would place higher than the year before. Then “Hey Little Walter” went on to winning the National Competition.”
As a result, the play ran for a month last year in a full off-Broadway production. Carla is now studying dramatic writing at New York University and has just finished a play called “Shackles in Nacirema” (that’s ‘American’ spelled backwards.) “It’s an African fairy tale,” she said. She is also adapting “Hey Little Walter” for the movies.
David entered his first play in the same competition as Carla. “The Little Subway Car That Couldn’t,” is about a clash between a businessman and a crazy clown asking him for money. It was one of ten finalists out of more than 600 entries. When they called and said he’d have to try again next year, David didn’t despair. He told New York Magazine, “I’m not going to let a contest dictate my worth.”
After that, he entered “I’m Not Stupid” in the Festival’s “New York City High School Playwriting Contest” where he won first prize. David has had staged readings and full productions of several of his plays and is now under contract with FOX Television to write a TV movie.
Maybe I Do Have Talent
Unlike David and Carla, Nadirah doesn’t consider herself a playwright and she has never entered any competitions. Nadirah is more interested in dancing, singing, and acting. “[But] ever since I wrote this [play,]” she said, “they [her drama coach and others] have been encouraging me to write more.”
As a matter of fact, all three have received encouragement from the people around them. “Your high schools have a tremendous resource of teachers who are there to support you,” said Carla, who graduated from John Jay HS. “Reach out to them and you can achieve your dreams. Don’t let anyone silence your voice.”
Nadirah’s “The Only Way Out” was read aloud on February 16th this year at the New Federal Theatre’s Zora Neale Hurston Writer’s Workshop, a series of readings of plays by women writers. “It made me feel like maybe I do have talent,” she said. “And if I decide to pursue a writing career that I would have a way of reaching out to other people about different things that are important to me.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.