Early last year a girl wrote a letter to YM magazine about a bunch of guys in her almost all-White school who were harassing her because she was Asian. They called her names like “Ch-k” and made other racist comments, she said. “It makes me really uncomfortable,” she wrote, “and mad…I just want to be normal.” The letter is signed “Confused.”
In her February column, the magazine’s editor, Christina Ferrari, answered the letter. “I don’t blame you for being mad,” she said. “Racism is totally disgusting…but what gets me really furious is that these guys are making you feel like you’re not normal because you’re Asian.”
She then goes on to say that “small-minded jerks feel threatened by people who are different from them.” And she ends the article by telling the poor, helpless and confused Asian girl that “educating and reprogramming them is totally not your job.”
A Sea of Whites
Ferrari doesn’t think the letter-writer should have to be responsible for fighting racism. And I agree. But apparently Ferrari and her colleagues at YM don’t feel it’s their responsibility either. That same issue of YM had pictures of 12 minorities compared to the sea of 138 White people (including the advertisements). In the July 1997 issue, to give another example, there were 10 minorities compared to the 121 Whites (as nearly as I could tell).
While doing the research for this article, I flipped through five teen magazines before coming across one picture of an Asian teen. I had to laugh when it was the picture for the article described above. Teen magazines constantly give the message that if you’re not White and blond then you’re not normal, so why is it shocking when these guys follow the same motto and treat this Asian girl as if she is abnormal?
In her parting words, Ferrari belittles the girl’s concerns, telling her: “Though it may be hard for you to believe right now, this experience will make you a stronger…person in the long run.” It makes me wonder if the lack of Black people in the section on “Happenin’ Hipsters” in YM’s March 1997 issue is their way of helping non-White teens become stronger.
IsThis Diversity?
When I finished reading the letter, I also wondered what the point was in telling this tragic story. Was it to make the magazine appear more diverse and make non-White teens feel that YM is really in touch with the whole picture?
Again and again, teen magazines like YM, Seventeen, Teen and Sassy plaster their magazines with White teens and then stick a light-skinned Black girl in the middle, trying to prove how diverse their magazines are. In a spread on soap opera studs from the September 1996 issue of YM, for instance, there was only one minority, Ricky Martin (Miguel from General Hospital). And even he looked White surrounded by so many White soap ‘hotties.’
Stuck in the Back
Seventeen is a little better than YM and Teen in trying to include non-Whites. “School Zone,” a six-page section profiling groups of friends, often features minority students from around the country. This is the editors’ way of showing how much they value teen difference.
But am I really supposed to be impressed when we’re condensed and stuck in the back of the issue? Aren’t we important enough to be plastered all over the magazine?
I wanted to get some answers from someone on the inside, so I spoke with Heather Keets, a young, black associate editor at Seventeen.
An Easy Answer
Asked how she felt about the lack of minority representation, Keets said: “It disturbs me that there are so many teenagers who are not White, and their experience is not represented as well as it could be.” But “Black consumers need to voice their opinions,” she explained. “If you’re not happy with what you paid for, then write to the editor…African-[Americans] and Latinos need to know that they make things happen.” Keets believes that if non-White teens write letters, things may change.
This may be so. Minority teens do need to make our voices heard. But I also wondered if saying that wasn’t an easy way for the editors to avoid taking the responsibility for their decisions. It is the editors’ job to find out if they are fully representing teenagers. As a journalist, it’s my duty to make sure what I write is accurate. I think these magazines should try harder to give us an accurate reflection of our world.
Just the Beginning
I’m glad there are people like Heather Keets who are trying to change things. In the August 1997 issue of Seventeen, Keets published an article, “Runway Girls,” by Tricia Jimenez, a Latino teen who described her experience interning as a pilot (unfortunately Tricia’s picture was dwarfed by the photo on the opposite page of the White girl who wrote an article on her experiences in the world of fashion design). And in April 1996, the editors of Seventeen chose to run a picture of pop star Brandy on the cover. Last October, their cover featured a photo of an African-American model.
But again and again when I open a teen magazine and see a Black girl stuck in the middle of a group of White teens, I have to ask myself, who do they think they’re fooling? And I’m skeptical when Seventeen runs articles on Indian culture as it did in it’s August, 1997 issue. Oh I’m not saying that the brief fashion summaries of Indian culture and religion aren’t enlightening. I’m just wondering whether it would have been such a big deal if Gwen Stefano and Pamela Anderson hadn’t worn Indian styles.
Keets calls the changes at Seventeen progress. She believes that even though these efforts are a weak attempt to appeal to everyone, any effort at all is a step in the right direction.
“A long time ago there would [have] been no minorities in these magazines,” she says.
I’m glad that there are people trying to make changes. But I think they need to know that it’s not enough to do the minimum and call it progress. It’s their duty to do the maximum and call it just the beginning.
You Call That Diversity?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.