Can you imagine Harlem-a neighborhood that has been for decades the symbol of Black American culture (and also, unfortunately, poverty)-becoming a mostly-White or all-White area?
According to Neil Smith, a professor of geography at Rutgers University, this could happen if the City of New York is successful in “gentrifying” Harlem.
Maybe you haven’t heard of the term “gentrification,” but it is fast becoming a household word-especially in New York.
Gentrification is “the changing of a previously working-class neighborhood into an upper-class neighborhood,” explains Smith, who has been studying the effects of gentrification on New York City neighborhoods.
Forced Out Of Homes
This change occurs because a low-income or middle-income neighborhood is seen as a prime area for the renovation and new development of commercial buildings and luxury homes, such as co-op apartments and condominiums.
Of course, most of the people who already live in such a neighborhood can’t afford the new housing when it is built or renovated. Because landlords can charge much more for apartments and homes in the area after such renovations, these people, have to move-even if they don’t wish to. This is often called “displacement,” a nice way of saying “thrown out.”
Many neighborhoods in New York City have become gentrified over the last 15-20 years: Soho, Chelsea, the Lower East Side, and the Upper West Side. All of these areas are in Manhattan, which seems to be the “hot spot” for gentrifying, and for a good reason-most businesses are there, and it is the ideal place for high-rise co-ops and apartment buildings.
Because it is located in an area many developers consider ideal (directly north of Central Park), Harlem could be next in line. But because of its history and present condition, many people (such as Smith) question the motives of the city and others who want to gentrify the area.
Fixing It Up For Whom?
“[Mayor] Koch will get up in front of reporters and announce that ‘We are redeveloping Harlem for the people of Harlem,’ and clearly that’s not what is happening,” explained Smith.
As an example, he pointed to Towers on the Park, a 599-unit condominium building built in Harlem at an estimated cost of over $70 million.
“There was hardly any money being put into Harlem before projects like Towers on the Park,” Smith adds. “And to say that this type of project is for the residents of Harlem is ridiculous.”
Right now, most of the gentrifying that is going on in Harlem has been taking place in East Harlem. Not much attention has been paid to Central Harlem, whose residents are mostly poor or working-class and Black.
But according to Smith, Central Harlem is the area developers really have their eyes on.
“By buying up most of the businesses and homes around Central Harlem, they can more easily make their way into it. It’s just a case of taking the area from the outside in.
“This approach is even sneakier than you think. When people start to complain that the city coming in and taking over property is wrong, the city and others can say that the residents of Harlem didn’t take care of the neighborhood, and that they are finally doing what they were told to do for years-fix it up.
“Unfortunately, it’s who they are fixing it up for that is a cause of concern,” Smith said.
Smith said that the city will downplay the fear that Harlem is being taken away from Blacks by saying that many of the high-priced apartments and homes being built can be bought by middle-class and upper-middle-class Blacks.
Who Can Afford It?
“But that’s a myth,” Smith claimed, “as well as the claim that middle-class and upper-middle-class Blacks are such large groups in this country, especially in New York.”
He’s not kidding.
According to the 1980 U.S. Census, only 262 Black households out of almost 100,000 in Central Harlem had incomes above $50,000. In Manhattan there are only 1,800 such Black households, and just 8,000 in all of New York City.
While these figures may have increased somewhat since 1980, chances are that there aren’t nearly enough middle-income and upper-middle-income Blacks living in New York to occupy the new homes being built or those being rebuilt in Harlem.
This is not to say that there will be no Blacks earning high incomes moving into the area. Smith argued that when the rehabilitation really begins, Harlem will first experience “Black gentrification.”
But continued gentrification in Harlem will depend on those households in New York City that can afford to live in a townhouse worth between $50,000 and $75,000 or a co-op apartment or condo ranging from $60,000 to $100,000.
And the majority of those households will be White.
Will Whites Move In?
But would Whites want to move into Harlem?
“If the price is right, yes,” says Smith. “Harlem is not the ghetto many people think it is.
“Add to this the reopening of the Apollo Theater and several restaurants and clubs that seem to be drawing Whites. As Whites slowly become more comfortable with Harlem, living in it won’t be a problem.”
The City of New York will benefit the most from gentrification because it owns most of the housing in Central Harlem (mainly five- and six-story tenements or “projects,” and townhouses). But others will also profit, especially Columbia University, located in the Hamilton Heights area of Harlem.
Smith says that Columbia has been slowly buying up property, moving closer and closer to Central Harlem, and has been quietly talking with the City about participating in a project called “Harlem on the Hudson.”
“Harlem on the Hudson” is now only a vision many have of a new residential and entertainment district lying near the Hudson River off 125th St. But if the gentrification of Harlem happens, it may become a reality.
Displacement-people being thrown out into the streets-is one major reason that many people object to gentrification. Some deny it happens; others recognize that it does occur but claim it’s not such a big problem.
“People would be surprised at how many of the families who are now living in shelters or in welfare hotels actually got kicked out of their homes because of gentrification,” explained Smith.
And if Central Harlem is gentrified, displacement will no doubt be the fate of many of the area’s current residents.
“The City doesn’t see displacement as a problem, so there is no contingency plan to rehouse people who are victims of it. So what happens to them?” asked Smith.
Another issue is whether Harlem will lose its historical heritage.
“Think about it-Harlem is the mecca of Black American culture. It is known throughout the world. Will it lose that distinction if it becomes gentrified? There’s a good chance it might,” Smith said.
Need To Organize
It doesn’t have to happen.
“People have got to get organized, start community groups, and let the city know how they feel,” he explained. “It can’t happen unless it’s allowed to happen.”
The community can make sure that if any housing is built, residents can afford it and will be considered first as tenants.
“The real problem is that people don’t know gentrification is actually happening until they are faced with an eviction notice,” Smith said.
“Harlemites and others are in a Catch-22 situation,” he continued. “Without gentrification, the chances that their neighborhoods will be cleaned up and made better are slim. So they would probably welcome a ‘rehab’ program.
“But in the end, their neighborhood being fixed up won’t mean anything if they aren’t living in it.”
Will Harlem Be Only for the Rich?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.