If pregnant substance abusers are prosecuted for harming their fetuses, it will only be part of the U.S. government’s historical pattern of “blaming the victim.”
Drug abuse is a direct result of our society’s structure, where poor people are worth less than rich people.
Our taxpayer-supported government does not attempt to make deep changes in this structure, but rather seeks to persecute and control the poor, who, unlike the rich, powerful people who reap the profits of the “Illegal” drug trade, can’t afford to fight back individually.
The Father’s Responsibility
Women naturally have more control over reproduction. The fate of the human population lies with them. Control them and you can control a particular population.
But what about the father?
‘The father!?,’ you may be asking. Fathers aren’t immune to drug abuse. Their behavior-which can run from physical abuse to substance abuse-also determines whether a child is born healthy or born at all. Yet there is no talk of prosecuting them for harming their child.
And what about women who use “legal” toxicants, such as cigarettes, alcohol, and even the polluted air we all breathe? Are we going to prosecute them if their children are born with birth defects?
Why are we not instead demanding that companies that pollute the environment be prosecuted and shut down? If we don’t, we see where our “priorities” lie and can immediately drop the moral argument. We can then admit that this is all about control-who wields it and who is subject to it.
If we really wanted to prevent the tragedy of children born with drug addictions and worse, we would demand that our tax-supported government provide prenatal care for all women, make abortion an affordable, available choice for all women, and make sure that after our children are born they have the same “rights” that some say a fetus deserves-to live in a safe environment and not death-trap welfare hotels.
Help the Victim
Finally, we must help all women who abuse substances to recover before they even become mothers. “Blaming the victim” is an act with a definite purpose behind it. When we understand that reasoning, we will see that throwing drug-addicted mothers in jail only serves the purpose of the powerful few who control society.
What we need are real programs (most drug rehab centers don’t accept pregnant women) backed up by real money. Only then can we truly help, rather than blame, those who are so desperately in need.
Why Should Women Be Scapegoats?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.