Why Foster Care Can Never Be Reformed!

Jessica Watson-Crosby, who spent 17 years in foster care, is Administrator of the National Association of Former Foster Children. For more information on this group, call 212-332-0078.
Removing children from the home to save them from abuse and neglect has been going on since the beginning of the century. One hundred years later we are still trying to figure out how to do it.
Last December, New York City Mayor Rudolph Giuliani and Administration for Children’s Services Commissioner Nicholas Scoppetta released “Protecting the Children of New York.” It is a plan to “reform” New York City foster care, but it is also the 51st “why we have failed” report on that system in the last 21 years. No other business or social institution could have or would have survived so many reports of failure.
Foster care is called “Protection of Children,” but it isn’t that. Since a report of abuse can only be made AFTER a child is suspected of being hurt, we guarantee that children are harmed instead of saved from harm. We disrupt a family forever by snatching the children first and asking questions later. And after we make a mistake, we say, “Oops! Sorry!”
If a mother handed her children over to total strangers, allowed them to be examined and questioned without her permission, and then these strangers gave the children to four or five more strangers every year (while the mother saw the children for only two hours each month), surely that mother would be guilty of abuse and neglect.
The Cure Is Worse Than the Disease
Yet this is what happens in foster care.
Foster care begins with the terror of suddenly losing family, friends, toys, clothes, siblings, relatives, neighborhood, and home. A child faces strange surroundings, strange people, the indignity of a medical strip search, and questions that aren’t nice. And that is why foster care can never be reformed.
There always have been and will be children whose families are not able to take care of them. But ACS admits that 80% of the children they snatch are eventually returned to family. That is a huge number of children whose families could have been helped BEFORE snatching. By the time these families come to the attention of the authorities, they have been in trouble for some time-and others knew about it. That is the time to make help available-when the cure won’t be worse than the disease.
One of the proposals in Scoppetta’s plan is the “72 Hour Case Conference.” After a child is removed from the home, a conference will be held within 72 hours, involving birth parents, foster parents, agency workers and other officials. The conference will help to determine what is best for the child, including alternatives to foster care.
Excellent idea! But this conference should be held BEFORE the children are removed from the family, not after.
There is no doubt that the families that come to the attention of ACS are families with problems. Most families have them.
But if we remove a child before we try to help the family, we guarantee that children are harmed instead of saved from harm. Snatching children without a proper review teaches them that the way you solve family problems is to run away from them.
No Family Therapy
For example, one family (whose mother asked me for assistance in dealing with the system) had four children between the ages of two and eight taken away. Social workers transported the kids to the hospital, where they were stripped and questioned and put immediately into foster care.
This family could have benefited from help instead of having the children taken. The problem in this family was a new stepfather who had never been a parent before and who used excessive corporal punishment (hitting the children), and a mother who had a history of having suffered from domestic violence in the past, and who therefore did not know how to control the situation.
During the year that the four children were in foster care, separated from one another in a total of eight foster homes, the problems in the family were not resolved. The mother told me that family therapy was not given to them until just before the children were returned home.
The mother wanted therapy to understand her issues. In fact, she asked the agency what problems she should work on. No one-not the social workers, the law guardian, the child’s therapist, or the mental health evaluator-would tell her. She was expected to figure out her problems on her own.
But of course, if she could have done that, the family would not have come to the attention of the authorities in the first place.
Losing the children to foster care cost the stepfather his job of 20 years because of the time he had to take off from work for court appearances and other meetings. Since the older child was kept in care a few months after the younger children returned home, this child became afraid that his family was trying to get rid of him. The younger children wondered what their big brother had done so that he could not come home.
Normal Conflict
And, of course, these four children have a fear that they will never lose, no matter how much their parents reassure them-that someday they will be taken away again.
Another example: A single mother’s 13-year-old son told people at his community center that his mother hit him with a baseball bat and that he was afraid to go home. The child was removed and put into foster care. A 72-hour case conference before removal would have figured out that the mother, for the first time in her only child’s life, had a boyfriend, which caused the child to be jealous.
A conference would have also determined that the night the child was afraid to come home was also the night he was supposed to show his mother his report card. He had not done as well on his report card as he had told everyone. The child had recently written a letter to God, looking for his father. It also turned out that the mother didn’t have a baseball bat.
In other words, normal family conflict. The 72-hour case conference before removal would have helped this family start working on the real issue-the mother and son communicating with one another. The mother was perfectly willing to go for family counseling and had done so in the past.
Family-oriented services that help rather than punish families make the best fiscal and emotional sense. They should be services that help a family before stress escalates.
The services presently in use are available only after a family has been labeled (and stigmatized) as “abusive,” and these services are hard to find.
One of my relatives could have used some parenting skills classes and other advice when she first had children. But none of us knew about them.
Even if we had heard of them, we still would not have been able to locate them because there is no directory of preventive services available to the general public. And even if there was, people are reluctant to use these services because the word on the street is that if you try to get help, your children could be taken away.
Respect is what everyone in the foster care system wants. It is especially what the families that come to the attention of the ACS should get.
Help the Whole Family
A social worker told one mother that her agency’s goal was not to help the family, but the children. But aren’t children part of the word “family?”
One of the members of the National Association of Former Foster Children said he always thought foster care meant “forced-to-care.” Foster care means the loss of family heritage and identity. It can never substitute for family and therefore it can never be improved. The only way to “reform” foster care is to keep families from going into it.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.