Who Isn’t Guilty: Lying to Our Parents

Let’s say you were supposed to be at your friend’s house playing Nintendo and your dad told you to be home at midnight. Of course you were at a party way across town having real fun. You get home late and your dad asks what took you so long. Now what are you going to do?
You’re going to lie. Why? Because you don’t want to get in trouble for being late or for being where you weren’t supposed to in the first place.
When asked when was the last time she lied to her parents, Sophia, 16, of Springfield Gardens HS responded, “You mean since dinner? When don’t I lie?”
Teens Lie For Many Reasons
Teenagers lie to their parents for a variety of reasons. But they mostly lie so they can either do something their parents wouldn’t normally let them do, or to keep parents from finding out about something they already did.
Mari Amme, 15 of Seaview Academy, for example, regularly uses the same excuse in order to be able to hang out all night. “A few years ago I told my parents that I was sleeping over at a friend’s house,” she said, “Then I went to a kegger [beer party]…[Another time] I slept over one of my boyfriend’s house.”
In order to hang out and watch the boys track team practice, Sophia admits that recently she’s been telling her mom that she’s tutoring after school.
Another kind of lies is the “lie of omission.” That’s when you purposely leave out crucial details of your whereabouts and whoabouts in order to make life a bit easier on your parents-and yourself.
Hubert, 17, of Urban Academy told his mom that he was staying the night at a friend’s house, maybe going to the movies and then to bed. At the time, that’s what they were planning to do. But they then decided to go to a party in New Jersey. Hubert didn’t say anything to let his mother know his plans had changed and when he got home the next day she asked him, “How was the movie, son?” While he admitted that he felt badly about it, Hubert never told her the truth about what happened.
Lies Protect Parents Too
While most teens lie for their own protection, some say they actually do it to protect their parents. “There are things that your parents don’t need to know about.” said Sally, 17, of Urban Academy. “There are sometimes things that I do, I have control of, that I don’t think my mom needs to know. [I don’t lie] because I think I’ll get in trouble, [it’s] so I don’t upset them and worry them.”
Some lie in order to protect their privacy, “There are some things, I feel parents shouldn’t know,” said Rudy, 16, of Springfield Gardens HS. “I lie to my parents when the situation has to do with my love life and private life.”
But there is a difference between lying because you feel something is none of your parents’ business and lying to stay out of trouble.
“There are things that you don’t tell your parents. That’s natural.” said Dina Gabriel, an Early Childhood Teacher and Parent Educator, “Lying is when you willfully distort the truth.”
When faced with the choice between distorting the truth and getting into serious trouble, many kids simply lie.
“It’s the easy way out.” said Mark, 18, Urban Academy. “I do realize that if I told the truth I’d be better off…[But at the time] you’re thinking, ‘How can I get out of this now?”
“I do it for my own safety,” explained Sophia. She said if her mother knew about half the things she did, “She’d kill me.”
Danger of Losing Trust
It’s not really fear of death so much as punishment or what Hubert calls, “Death by humiliation or even worse the horrible lecture: ‘I expect more from you’ or the ancient, ‘You should know better.'”
But lying has its own dangers like getting caught or losing your parents’ trust.
Josephine Carson, an Early Childhood Educator and a teacher in the LYFE Program, (Living for the Young Family through Education) says that she can tell when her child is lying to her. “If you have a good relationship with your child, there are certain body movements [that give it away], or the way they speak. If you have a bad relationship, you wouldn’t know each other anymore.”
Facing a parent’s squinting eye when you’re trying to lie to them can be pretty spooky. “It must be that internal link.” Mark said about his mother. “She can look at me and tell I’m lying.”
A Challenge or a Sickness?
Lying to your parents for any reason can become somewhat of a task. “You can’t just lie blindly,” said Andre, 17, of Brooklyn Tech HS. “You have to follow up the lies, make it into the truth. You have to take responsibility for it. It’s like a challenge sometimes, it’s a sickness.”
Besides being unhealthy, when kids work too hard at lying it sometimes ends up backfiring on them. “When I come up with a lie like that, [in a snap] she falls for it,” said Angela, 16, “but when I plan it for days…’Are you lying to me?’ “
As with any relationship, communication is important between parents and children. “If a parent and child can [maintain] good communication,” said Joan Davis. “then there’s less need to lie.”
Unfortunately, that doesn’t always happen. Communicating openly with your parents can be hard to do. Sometimes they’re unwilling to listen. “I wouldn’t be able to say to my parents that I needed a break and I didn’t go to school,” said Andre, 17, of Brooklyn Tech HS. “They wouldn’t even try to understand-they’re part of the problem.”
“Sometimes teenagers feel that it’s better to lie because they’ve tried to tell the truth and their parents don’t listen.” agreed Gabriel.
Parents Were Once Teenagers
“No matter what I tell them, they think I’m lying,” said Andre. “They check and double check and I see no need for that. When they think I’m lying they look in my drawers, in my notebook, sneaking behind me, so I stopped caring what they think. I can’t change them.”
“I know kids who were afraid to tell their parents that they were pregnant,” said Davis.
At one time Mari Amme thought that she was pregnant, “It would’ve made me feel better to tell somebody,” she said. When asked why she didn’t tell her parents, she exclaimed. “Why would I? The consequences…They’d kill!”
In situations where your parents are not even trying to hear what you’re saying, Davis suggests “[getting] the help of another adult…Find an aunt, a grandmother, a teacher, someone. Get someone to help you out.”
But don’t give up on your parents altogether. That relationship has to be a two way street.
Andre said that if he could say anything to his parents, “I’d tell them to ‘Close your mouth and open your ears.’ They didn’t grow up in this age. They’re not willing to listen.”
“Find out about your parents,” suggested Gabriel. “They were once adolescents, too. [Say to them] ‘Tell me what it was like when you were sixteen.’…It gets them thinking.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.