Who Is RuPaul?: A Woman’s Nightmare

A man transforming himself into a woman is strange enough. But one who does this and then becomes a mainstream pop idol? That’s the story of RuPaul Andre Charles, a 6’7″ Black man in a platinum wig and platform heels. What is the world coming to?
RuPaul is the first drag queen (a man who dresses up as a woman) to have a record at the top of the charts. His hit “Supermodel (You Better Work!)” made its debut last November and is holding a respectable spot on Billboard’s dance chart, and the accompanying video is getting lots of play.
In the “Supermodel” video, RuPaul wears a number of sexy red outfits including a flowing dress, a pair of short-shorts, and a G-string swim suit. These outfits and his feminine gestures and sexy facial expressions must be what’s attracting all the attention because the vocals are no good. RuPaul is not a singer. He just wants attention and to get it, he prances around mimicking women.
He’s Mocking Us
I think RuPaul is just exploiting the female sex for his own financial gain. Believe me, had he sung the same song as a man, he would never have gotten all this attention.
When I look at RuPaul, I see a mockery of the true female. How dare he make a career out of carrying himself like a woman. He is not a woman. He’s a man and he should accept that. And as if his video weren’t doing enough damage, stealing attention away from female musicians with real talent, he’s also getting jobs modeling women’s clothing. RuPaul knows what he’s doing, and he’s making it hard for real women out there who are struggling to make it.
In a way, RuPaul has an advantage over female models because people find him exotic and unique. They think it’s impressive for a man to turn himself into an incredibly attractive woman. Personally, I prefer to see women’s clothes modeled by real women. Besides, there are already plenty of jobs out there for men to do. They shouldn’t intrude on what little we have. RuPaul has no right to ride the woman’s bandwagon to a decent good paying job. It’s just like stealing someone’s cake on their birthday.
Better Than the Real Thing?
I remember seeing RuPaul being interviewed on the music television station, VH1. He had a crowd of girls around him and he spoke about his career so far. At the end of the interview, he had the gall to criticize the way professional models walk down the runway. He stood and demonstrated how clothing should be carried. He sashayed up and down the platform, flicking his head, and flipping his blonde wig. It’s like he wants to show that he can do a better job of being a woman than the real thing. I find this offensive and I’d be even more offended if I were a model and he took a job away from me.
Women have come a long way since the cave days but we still don’t have equality with men. For centuries men have been telling us that they are better than we are at a variety of professions. So now, just when we’re starting to make inroads, showing that we can do just as good a job as men in a variety of professions, along comes a man who wants to prove that he’s better at being a woman than we are.
I think RuPaul’s popularity could have a dramatic impact on women in this day and age. Soon, a lot of women will fall into the trap of thinking that what RuPaul is doing is cool. They’ll think, “Oh, it’s alright, it’s all about fun, he’s cute.” They won’t stop to think, “Hey, what if this whole thing is another male-chauvinist attempt to rule the entertainment industry?”
It’ll be just like in the movie Tootsie, when an out-of-work actor can’t get cast in any male roles so he dresses up as a woman and becomes a soap opera star. The message seemed to be, if you can’t succeed as a man, don’t worry. Just slip on a dress and you’ll do fine.
RuPaul is proof that truth can be just as outrageous as fiction. Real females who aspire to be models, singers, or actresses, be warned! I fear that a couple of years from now there will be many more RuPauls out there. God help us.

SIDEBAR: Beauty or Beast?
I asked some people at my school, Jamaica HS, what they thought about RuPaul and the reactions were mixed. T.T., a freshman girl, said, “RuPaul, I think, is not helping the African-American man’s image. He’s creating a taboo image. When I see Rupaul, a big ol’ Black man cross-dressed transvestite, I see a negative stereotype of a Black man. We need to project a positive persona of the Black man. Educated, dressed according to his sex, and not a freak.” Sabrina, who’s a senior, disagreed. “He’s cool, I like him…her,” she said. “He’s better looking than most women I know, except for his height. He has the guts to wear clothing I wouldn’t dare to wear.” Katrina Livingston, a junior, said that while she likes RuPaul’s music, she doesn’t approve of the image he projects. She told me about the time she and her boyfriend were watching TV when RuPaul came on. “I said, ‘Look at that girl. Don’t she look fly? All trimmed down.’ He got excited and said, ‘YEAH!’ Then I told him that she was a man. He said, ‘Oh sh-t,’ and threw up.” That experience convinced Katrina that it was cruel of RuPaul to fool people like that. But Lazaros, a senior, said that RuPaul isn’t trying to fool anyone. “It’s great that he’s being accepted,” Lazaros said. “His drag is great. He makes it seem real but you know it’s fake. His act is fun…He’s doing what he wants. People can either like it or hate it.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.