Some foster kids hope that staying in a group home or foster home in the neighborhood where they came from will end most of the problems usually associated with foster care (such as having to travel a long way to visit relatives, or having to go to a new school and make new friends all over again). And these are good reasons for being placed in your own neighborhood.
But let’s talk reality.
Most of the neighborhoods in New York City where foster kids come from tend to be crumbling ghettos, like the Morrisania section in the South Bronx (where child abuse rates are among the highest in the city).
Sure, you’ll be closer to your parents and you won’t have to change schools, but what kind of foster parents do you expect to get in a neighborhood where so many children are already being abused?
Is It a Choice?
And where exactly do you think you’ll be eating, sleeping, and living every day? What kind of foster home do you think they’re going to find you in a wasteland like Morrisania, where, in 1993, more than 50% of families made less than $10,000 a year and between 45%-60% of all housing units are in fair to poor condition? Would you want to live in a foster home in this neighborhood?
Furthermore, is the neighborhood-based plan even going to be a choice? As I hear, it’s going to be the same policy for everyone (“one-size-fits-all”).
It’s being called “decentralization,” which means individual communities developing foster care programs (or having these programs developed for them) according to the community’s needs.
Sounds good. But how about your needs? Are they always going to be the same as everyone else’s in the neighborhood?
What if your biological parents really have abused or neglected you, so that neither you nor your foster parents want to be close to them any time soon? According to the new policy, you may have to stay in the same neighborhood as your biological parents-whether you like it or not.
It Could Be Harder
And what if your biological parents aren’t dangerous, but refuse to cooperate with the agency or otherwise can’t get their kids back? What if their parental rights are terminated because they continue taking drugs?
What is the system going to do with you then? Put you in a new neighborhood after all this time? Or leave you with your foster parents in your old neighborhood? If you are adopted by your foster parents, they probably won’t agree to an “open adoption” (letting your biological parents visit after you are adopted).
So…your adoptive parents don’t want visitation and it’s illegal for the biological parents to make contact with you after adoption. BUT YOUR BIOLOGICAL PARENTS LIVE RIGHT DOWN THE BLOCK or maybe even NEXT DOOR! How in the hell can you avoid them? Has the ACS thought about this??
And, while we’re at it, let’s talk about school life. What if they place you in one of your classmate’s homes? What if you have to bring in your foster parents for report-card night? Sure, you live in the same neighborhood and you don’t have to make new friends, but you do have to explain your “new” parents to all of your old friends!
And when it comes to academics, I can tell you that my brother and sister stayed in the same school after we were placed in foster care, and they both failed the first grade miserably. Staying in the same school doesn’t make foster care any easier. It may even be harder.
Realistic Worries
You might say that I’m dreaming up these possible disasters just for the hell of it, but every child in foster care knows these are realistic “what if” questions. These may be the consequences that will affect all of you in care if this policy goes into effect. So far, I haven’t heard anybody introduce a “Plan B” in case something goes wrong.
In fact, “experts” believe that having the biological parents and child live closer will naturally lead to successful reunification.
This belief, as I mentioned before, is not based on real life. Parents’ rights can and have been terminated no matter how close to the child the parents have lived.
Plan B?
I also believe there are more important issues that deserve consideration (like better foster parents and dealing with the social problems that make foster care necessary), but that’s another article.
So, for now, I won’t support this neighbor- hood-based policy until I see a “Plan B” introduced for each of the possible disasters that I mentioned above. Connecting youth to their parents and old neighborhoods is good, but preparing alternative plans to deal with worst-case scenarios is better.
(Statistics on Morrisania from the Citizen’s Committee for Children of New York.)
Where Do You Want to be Placed?: Move Me!
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.