When I wasn’t a Twin Anymore

Will my twin and I ever be close again?

(Names and places have been changed.)
One afternoon last December, my identical twin sister Melissa and I were sitting on opposite ends of the couch in the living room. She was worrying about something and I offered her a suggestion like I usually did.
“Why are you talking to me like I care about you? I don’t care about you,” Melissa said. She looked at me with a baffled expression on her face, as if we’d previously discussed our feelings and settled on this fact. I was stunned and I went completely silent.
They say there’s a certain closeness between twins, especially identical twins. There’s this person who, through no fault of your own, looks and dresses exactly like you. You share a bond that no outsider can break. But what happens when you and your twin start to grow up? Is the bond still unbreakable?
Sharing Snacks and Genes
When Melissa and I were 5 years old, we were best friends and constant playmates. We played board games meant for four, but we had fun playing with just the two of us.
When we were put in different kindergarten classes, we’d spend the walk home from school telling each other about our day. I even saved snacks from my teacher in my Beach Barbie lunchbox for Melissa, so we could share them when we got home.
But while we shared not only snacks, but the same looks, clothes and genes, Melissa and I didn’t share the same personality. She was always ready to complain about what she felt wasn’t right. I was more prone to go with the flow and listen to other people.
She was also braver than me, which is probably why I depended on her so much. Melissa was born first, and she did everything else before me, too-said her first words, took her first steps, and just about everything else there is to do in the world before you turn 5. She was big sis and I admired her.
I Needed Her
The summer after 2nd grade, we went to day camp. As usual, we were inseparable and spent all day playing together. But one day, Melissa and I were put in separate groups. As her group left to start an activity in another room, I started to bawl my eyes out. I felt like she was starting a new life with new people and leaving me behind. A counselor came over and asked me, “What’s wrong?”
“My stomach hurts,” I lied. I could tell she didn’t believe me, but I didn’t want her to know the real reason I was crying. She called Melissa back into the room, and my sister asked me what had happened.
“My stomach hurts,” I said again between sobs. Melissa looked worried as she sat there with her hand on my shoulder, trying to figure out what was wrong.
I couldn’t tell her that being separated from her in a new environment was just too much for me. I was embarrassed that I needed her to stay when she didn’t seem to need me.
Our personalities grew even more defined by the time we reached junior high. Melissa was developing into the “don’t mess with me” type, and I was the “I’ll just stand here in the corner and watch” type. Although our bond still felt as solid as a rock, that didn’t stay true for much longer.
I had a hard time when we started high school at different schools. On the first day of 9th grade, she had to leave before me to get to her new school. She came to the bathroom door and we said our good-byes and good-lucks. Right after she left, I started crying, just like when we were at summer camp. She was leaving me again.
We still told each other about our day after school when we could find the time. But high school was demanding and we got stressed out a lot. We began spending less time chilling and more time arguing. By the beginning of junior year, things started to get out of control.
Looking back on it now, our arguments seem really senseless. They were about silly things, like time in the bathroom, who got the last bit of ice cream, who got to wear what shirt on what day.
Still, things would get really heated. Our parents started to complain about our behavior. “Sisters are supposed to live loving,” my father would say. My mother would chime in, “They don’t live loving at all.”
Each time we fought, we grew inches apart from each other. We acted like we weren’t split from the same egg, like we’d never carried love in our hearts for each other. I felt like Melissa was shutting me out and leaving me by myself once again.
‘I don’t Care About You’
She seemed to make it her duty to verbally abuse me with the most hurtful phrases. She called me stupid and made me feel bad about things I’d confided to her in secret. Whenever I asked her why she was being so mean, she’d ask me the same question, and we’d go back and forth about how nasty the other person was being. The arguments would always end with my surprised silence at what she had just said to me.
Finally, a few months into junior year, we had the blowout where she said she didn’t care about me. I was used to her rude remarks. But this felt different-this was how she felt about me as a person. My mind immediately transformed “I don’t care about you” into “I don’t care what happens to you.” It was the worst thing she’d ever said to me.
It meant that if I were dying of thirst in the desert, she wouldn’t spare a drop of agua, because she absolutely despised and loathed me. At that moment, it felt like I wasn’t a twin anymore. “Only regular siblings don’t care about each other, right?” I thought to myself. “Only regular siblings argue about trivial matters, right?” I didn’t shed a tear. Instead, I decided not to care about her either.
A Sudden Truce?
After that I tried to stay out of her way (no easy task since we share a bedroom). When I did speak to her, all I got was a “Mind your own business.” I left her alone and focused on my schoolwork.
But about six months later, a sudden truce was formed. One day when I was going to apply for a job at Target, my mother made Melissa go apply, too. As we walked back to the train station, Melissa and I started complaining about our mom, who’s always making us late. It was one of the few things we still bonded over.
“I would have been here before you, but I had to wait for Mommy,” she said.
After that, the conversation continued, and when we got home, for the first time in ages, there seemed to be no tension. We chilled out in front of the TV like two homies who’d had a falling out, but were now “cool.” I think this happened because when we’re in public, we tend to put on the “loving sisters” act. I guess when we got home, we forgot we were acting.
Unfortunately, it didn’t last. A few weeks later, I tried to intervene in a dispute between Melissa and my mom. She blew up at me for supposedly taking our mother’s side and didn’t speak to me for days. Now I feel like it’s just always going to be like this.
Keeping my Distance
I remember when I wanted to name my future daughter after Melissa. I remember talking about how we had to be next-door neighbors when we got older. I’d love for us to be sitting in our living room now, talking about our college plans and how scared we’re both going to be when we leave home next year.
But the way she’s been acting has turned me off wanting to form a close relationship with her. I’ve started to wonder if all twins go through this-a period of total loyalty to each other, and then a drifting apart. With our different personalities, maybe it was bound to happen.
But I’m not willing to do anything else to try to salvage our relationship. Maybe one day something crazy like an earthquake or a death in the family will bring us close again. But for now, I’ve decided to keep my emotions at a distance so that I don’t get my hopes up only to be let down again.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.