The writers of New Youth Connections wanted to learn more about New York City’s foster care system and what it’s like to be in care, so we decided to interview some of our fellow writers at Represent, the magazine written by and for teens in foster care. Both magazines are published by Youth Communication.
NYC: What do you think about the foster care system in New York City?
Manny: Baaad. The whole process is really slow, to the point where it’s like nothing is moving. I’ve been in care for seven years now and I’m supposed to be getting adopted soon. But that’s not even final [yet].
Samantha: The way the system works is out of hand. I’ve been in foster care for over 10 years and seen everything. [The system] helps people in some ways but it also affects other people’s lives in bad ways. The way they take kids in and out of homes is a huge problem. It seems like the system thinks they [always] know what’s best for the kids. But they’re not the ones walking in that kid’s shoes every day, going from home to home, having to go through conflicts with the homes they’re in.
NYC: What would you recommend changing about the foster care system?
Charlene: [I think the system should] be more observant about where they put kids and investigate every detail about the family that they’re placing someone in. [Not deciding that because] I’m 19 I deserve to be in a group home or I need to get kicked out. In foster care it’s just like, “OK, we need to put her somewhere. Put her anywhere.” [And you might end up with foster parents] who can’t understand you because you don’t speak Spanish [or vice versa].
Samantha: Also, [some of] the staff in foster care agencies don’t seem to have the patience needed to work with the kids. Out of all people, these are the people who are supposed to help the kids and improve their lives, not make them worse. Another issue is that [some agency] staff don’t have an idea of what they’re supposed to do. we’re the kids; we’re not supposed to be telling you how to do your job. You’re supposed to know how to do your job.
NYC: What are some misconceptions about foster care?
Manny: Let me get the list. There’s a stereotype that, “You’re not going to amount to anything, you’re going to drop out of high school, you’re going to end up in jail, you do bad in school, you do bad in life!” But I think it’s actually the opposite. Hearing all these negative things gives you the incentive to do better, and instead of underachieving, you overachieve.
Samantha: [In some ways], kids in foster care have more opportunities and more doors open to them than kids who aren’t in foster care. Outsiders see foster care kids as the ones who are going to be the next drug dealers on the block, the next ones going to jail, who aren’t going to finish their education. It might be true for some, but it’s not true for everybody.
NYC: How do those stereotypes make you feel?
Samantha: Sometimes it makes you feel like you’re from another planet, because people look at you like you’re different. In some [ways] we are different. But I don’t let stereotypes bother me. I’m an open-minded person-I take it and go. I don’t get angry.
Manny: I just use the stereotypes as a driving force to do better and succeed. I want to flip the stereotypes and do the opposite. I’m going to do well; I’m going to graduate. I’m going to be somebody.
NYC: What do you wish people knew about foster care?
Samantha: It opens a lot of doors for [some] kids. You get financial aid for college and they help you get housing-things that people who aren’t in foster care might have a hard time with. It helps you prepare for being on your own, and I know a lot of people who aren’t in foster care and have problems with that.
People see the foster care system as something that needs to be improved, which is true. But I know from my time in the system that you find some people who actually care about you and want you to prove those stereotypes wrong.
NYC: How are teens treated in foster care?
Samantha: we’re treated as if we’re unworthy, in a way. When you go into a new foster home, a lot of the foster moms look at you as if you could overthrow them or something. They don’t trust you. they’vealready stereotyped you as “a teenager who’s coming to my home and is going to be very mischievous and promiscuous or dealing drugs.”
Some social workers work to get you the support you need, but others have already put it in their heads that a child might be trouble, and they don’t give that teen a chance. That’s pathetic, because as a social worker you’re not supposed to judge the kid before you meet them. You’re supposed to want to work with that kid no matter what they’re like.
Charlene: [Some foster parents] don’t treat everyone the same. They’ll give their kids something special and take their kids out to eat, and [to their foster kids,] they’ll be like, “There’s food in the refrigerator.” Maybe their kids can bring their friends over and you can’t bring your friends over.
NYC: Are teens safe in foster care?
Manny: I think generally in foster homes teens are safe, but sometimes crazy things happen. Like my brother doesn’t believe in God. So in this one home that he went to when he was younger, the lady woke him up at 3 in the morning and she was throwing holy water on him, and he was scared.
Samantha: When it comes to [feeling] safe, the word is trust. Because when you live in [some religious] homes they make you feel like you don’t belong on this earth just because you don’t believe in a higher being or don’t have a commitment to a certain religion.
It’s hard because when you’re a teenager, that’s the time when you’re trying to find yourself. You go into a home where they’re so religious or claim they’re religious, and they won’t accept you for who you are.
For me, it’s been mostly safe in a lot of the homes I’ve been in. In a few homes, with certain people around and the environment, it wasn’t safe.
Charlene: In group homes, everyone always steals from you. And when you try to go back and get your stuff, there’s always a fight. Staff just sit back sometimes and watch.
NYC: What’s the difference between a foster home and a group home? Which do teens prefer?
Samantha: In a group home, you have a lot of kids living under the same roof, and everyone can relate because they’re all in the same system. But you’re open to so many other people and anything can happen. People can steal from you and you don’t know when someone’s going to come out of nowhere and pick a fight with you. I remember when I was in a group home, the staff didn’t give a heck. You could live today and die tomorrow; they didn’t care.
In a foster home, you have fewer kids living under one roof and you live with a family. You’re a bit safer, and sometimes you have people who actually care about you and want to work with you. I also think you have more opportunities when it comes to [adults] wanting what’s best for you. When you’re in a group home, you have a lot of other people that need to be taken care of too, so that attention is divided.
Charlene: When it comes down to it, all people want family around them, someone who’ll comfort them. So whether it’s a foster family or your own family, the point is that you want a family.
Samantha: Sometimes in foster homes if you’re very lucky, you’ll actually find a family who cares about you and wants to help you, and that you’ll want to live with until you come out of care. You don’t find too many families in this system who really care about you, who aren’t just there for the money they make off you. In a group home, you don’t have a family. Your family is the kids who live with you, and half of those kids don’t like you.
NYC: Does the foster care system support teens in their education?
Samantha: Since I’ve been in the foster care system, it’s been all about motivating kids to go to college or helping prepare them to live on their own. And I’ve had social workers who didn’t just motivate me but supported me, in whatever decisions I’ve made about school.
NYC: When do New York City teens “age out” of the foster care system?
Charlene: After you turn 18, they put two different papers in front of you-one to get out of the system and one to say you’re still in it and we’re still looking out for you and providing for you. Some people I know just sign themselves out. I guess some kids feel that when they’re 18, they have the authority, that it’s going to be easy to look for their own place. But it’s not as easy as being in care and having help. I advise whoever’s in care to never sign out. Get everything you can get from the system. You don’t want to sign that paper [to leave the system] until you’re 21.
NYC: What do teens get if they stay in care until they’re 21?
Charlene: Your ACS worker has to help you with things like housing and financial aid to go to college. And if you feel like you’re not being helped, there’s always someone higher [up in the system who you can go to].
NYC: Would you ever become a foster parent or adopt?
Samantha: Since I was young I’ve had this plan where I would help kids who were like me and ended up in the foster care system, and beyond that, families who don’t have a home. Yes, I would adopt, because I understand what it’s like and what the challenges are.
Manny: A lot of kids in the system, when you ask them what they want to be, they say a social worker or something that has to do with the system, including adopting or being a foster parent. They know that it’s hard and they want to help the kids. We know what we went through as children. We know we can help by not only providing a home, but being a parent. It makes you feel good when you know you can help somebody, and when you do.
NYC: Is that something you’re thinking about doing?
Manny: Of course!
NYC: What person in your life helps you the most?
Manny: That would be my foster parent. She’s the best. She’s like-she is my mom. That’s just it. She is my mother.
Charlene: This woman I call my aunt. I was in a group home setting with her and we went through so much. She knows the way I feel, that the only thing I wanted was a family. But certain people you get close to in care, they can’t take you because they have to follow certain rules and regulations. I’m in another group home now, but I still consider her a close family member.
Samantha: I had this foster mom who wasn’t like the other foster moms. She wasn’t just being a foster mom as a job. She actually cared about kids and wanted to make a difference as a role model.
I went through a lot of things in my past and never had hope that anything good would happen. But she showed me that things could be reversed and you could find someone who replaces what you lost. And for me, she replaced what I’ve lost-my family. She treated me like I was one of hers. That was really good for me, and I always appreciated her for that. I’ve experienced a lot of foster homes where they didn’t really care about the kids, just “I’m doing you a favor by putting you in my home.” But that foster mom was an inspiration.
NYC: Is there anything else you’d like to say?
Samantha: I think it’s odd how you can end up in the foster system. Anybody could just pick up a phone and call the cops and say this has happened to a child, or a child could call the cops and say, “My mom just beat me with a belt.” And the next thing you know, ACS (Administration for Children’s Services) is there.
And ACS has the power to say that the kid doesn’t belong to the parent anymore, [that] he or she belongs to the city. That’s how I’ve always looked at it. If the city thinks you’re too harsh on your kid, then the kid’s out of your home and into the system.
I don’t think it should work like that, because people come from different backgrounds and cultures and have their own way of doing things. I think it’s something that needs to be improved.
If you’re in foster care and have a problem with your placement, call the Administration for Children’s Services’ Office of Advocacy at 212-676-9421.
Questions about foster care? Visit FYI3.com, a website providing resources and information for foster teens.
Interview conducted by NYC writers Ilya Arbit; Angel Muñoz; Jerrica Neal; Viveca Shearin; Natalia Tavarez and Jordan Temple.
What’s Life Like in Foster Care?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.