In my culture it’s disrespectful to talk back to people older than you, even if you disagree with what they say. You just have to listen as they go on and on; otherwise, they’ll say you’re not raised well.
I admit I have a problem controlling my speech in this way. To me, it makes a difference whether you choose your language and tone or just shoot words out of your mouth. I always try my best to speak calmly and raise different sides of an issue without sounding like I’m arguing. Unfortunately, to many people in my culture, your tone and words aren’t important-they will only remember that you talked back.
Recently my mom, my sisters and I went to dinner at our neighbor’s house. The older group of women started talking about Yemeni girls who listen to their iPods in the streets. They said these are not good girls, that they want to show off and drag attention to themselves.
“Maybe they’re bored and want to keep themselves company on the train instead of just staring at people,” I said.
They all looked at me, and my sister and mom gave me a weird look that said, “Is it your business? Did they say your name?”
I shrugged my shoulders. One woman replied, “Oh, you do it too?” I told her yes.
“You see what America does to the girls? They’re going to become flirty girls,” another lady said.
“Why? Because we listen to music? Nobody even knows because it’s under the scarf,” I said, referring to the scarves we wear over our heads.
I continued to defend myself, and the conversation moved on to different things. On the way home, my mom complained. She said that if I’d stayed quiet the topic would have closed as easily as it opened, but I started a discussion. She was worried the women would think that I was disrespectful and proud.
On the outside, I stayed confident in my opinion that it wasn’t wrong to listen to an iPod or talk back to them. But inside my heart, pieces of guilt were eating me up. I didn’t want my mom to be embarrassed or mad because of me. Even if what I did seemed right to me, her being upset confused my thinking.
I’d like to tell adults who want to say something in front of me without me talking back that they can keep dreaming. I don’t want to change. But on the other hand, guilt about upsetting my parents gives me second thoughts. I don’t want people to say to my parents that they didn’t raise me well just because I speak my mind. I know at times it really bothers them that I’m like this. That’s why, when my brain signals me to start an interesting discussion, the question always lies in front of me: “Should I say something or keep quiet? What if Mom and Dad get upset?”
-Orubba Almansouri
Should the writer have talked back?
Ayana: I would’ve just turned on my iPod during this conversation. I pick and choose when I’m going to say something. I’ve heard adults say, “Oh, girls are dressing really skanky” because we wear leggings, but I’m not going to debate with them because I know it’s not true. The idea that, if she made her point right, the women were going to be like, “Yeah, you’re right!”-that’s really far-fetched.
If you really feel bad when you talk back, I think you should focus more on keeping your opinions to yourself.
Do you ever find it hard to keep quiet when you disagree with someone?
Torres: As you get more mature, you know what to avoid. Trying to prove your point is not going to change anything. Ignore them; keep on doing what you like.
Perry: You can’t change every single ignorant person in the world. If it’s directed at you then it’s best to voice your opinion, but if it’s not about you, it’s best to ignore it.
Ben: Most people say “Ignore them,” but in this kind of family, they would never ask you your opinion. It’s the same thing in my country. As long as you’re a teenager they don’t want to ask you anything. If she felt like they were saying the whole generation is bad, she probably felt like she had to say something about it.
At a certain time, I couldn’t say something to older people because they would say, “Yeah, nobody asked you.” But I kept on talking and they got used to it.
Have you ever done something that you didn’t think was wrong, but that embarrassed your parents?
Torres: Once, my family went to a wedding. My brothers and I were dressed up: we had shirts on, scarves. After the wedding we went to my dad’s friend’s house to visit. We took off the shirts and were just walking around in our t-shirts.
When we got into the car later, my dad was mad. He was like: “This is the first and last time you do something like that. When you go somewhere, if you went with a shirt, you come back with a shirt.”
In the end, I felt bad. Not because of what I did-I didn’t think it was a big deal-but because of the way he expressed his anger. He didn’t beat me; he just looked embarrassed and ashamed.
Lea: If you think you did the right thing, then I don’t think you should feel bad, even if your parents don’t like it.
What Would You Do? Teens Debate What it Means to Do the Right Thing
Should I Speak My Mind?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.