What Would You Do? Teens Debate What it Means to Do the Right Thing

A Big Brother's Dilemma

Since childhood, I’ve dreamt of working in law and politics. I want to be one who stands up for others, who leads them to their greater good. I sometimes fast forward and imagine myself in a court of law, defending innocents, or standing at a podium somewhere in Africa, leading a rally before millions of people. I want to reform my country’s social and judicial systems in favor of the poor. Or perhaps I could be an ambassador between my home country, Ivory Coast, and the world.
Some might see this as too much ambition for a 17-year-old, but I always felt sure I would be able to realize this dream-until recently.
As the first born in an African family, I have to look out for my brother and sister and help pay for their college. In fact, it is more than a simple responsibility; it is a tradition, an obligation. Last year, my dad started pressuring me to be more “realistic” and drop my “foolish” dreams. My siblings are 13 and 10, he reminded me. Soon enough, the family will have to face their college bills. And if my parents aren’t there in 10 years, how will I support them?
I have been raised to keep in mind that my parents won’t always be around and I may soon have to take care of myself and my younger siblings, too. As a teen, my dad had to pay for his siblings’ education after they lost both parents. He suffered for a while, hustling and doing everything he could to keep control of his family and get a proper education at the same time.
Now, my dad is anxious for me to become financially secure as soon as possible so that, if anything happens to him, I’ll avoid the hardships he experienced. He has proposed a practical plan for my future: He wants me to attend a two-year nursing program. (He is a nurse and says nursing is one of the most secure jobs nowadays.) According to his plan, 10 years from now I will be working, finished paying back my college loans, and able to put my siblings through school. Once my siblings graduate college, I could even go back to school and become a doctor. I haven’t really imagined what it would be like to be a nurse or doctor-I just don’t want to think about it.
This puts me in a dilemma. I want to stick to my plan, but my father’s experience as a teenager is a reminder of how uncertain the future can be. Now, I feel like I have to make the choice between my dreams and my family responsibilities, a choice that leaves me completely torn. My father’s plan will bring me financial independence quickly and allow me to help my family, but isn’t independence about doing what we want to do?
-Boubacar Diallo
Is it more important to take care of your family or follow your own dreams?
Lana: It’s more important to follow your dreams because you’ll be miserable in life if you don’t.
Lea: I think that you should put yourself before your family. If you abandon what you want, you’ll end up feeling insecure.
Torres: I don’t know. I have a cousin who wanted to be a professional soccer player. He started making money doing it, but he got injured and now he can’t play. He had to go back to college. Sometimes, your dream is not right for you.
Cinorow: I see it as family first, before your dreams. But I guess it depends on how you feel about your family.
Ayana: It depends on who in the family needs you. If it’s one of my aunts, I’m not rushing, ’cause I already know how they are. My cousins, I’m there. Brothers, I’m there. Most people think because you’re my family I owe you something. But I don’t owe you just because I was born into the same gene pool as you.
According to the utilitarian philosophy of “the greatest good for the greatest number of people,” it makes more moral sense to leave behind the few to help the many. In this story, that would mean the writer should leave behind his two siblings in his effort to become a lawyer and help a whole nation. What do you think about that?
Ayana: Helping lots of people is a possibility in the future, but family is now. That’s your blood. You’re a part of them, they’re a part of you.
Chris: Family is still more important because they are real for you in the past, present, and future, and a dream might not come out as you planned.
What would you do if you were the writer?
Chris: I would help my brother and sister until they can handle themselves-then I would stick to my own plan.
Perry: I would follow my dream.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.