What Makes the Perfect Parent?

Teens Speak Out:
What Makes the Perfect Parent?
By Joi M. Kafka
“Mom, Dad, I really want to talk to you, but I can’t because . . .”
The list of reasons why teens can’t communicate with their parents is as long as the list of conflicts teens and parents experience every day.
But what would a parent who is easy to talk to, understanding, and helpful in every way be like? What qualities does the ideal parent have?
These questions were posed to Vera Winitch’s journalism classes at Benjamin Cardozo HS. Listen up, parents-they had a lot of informative and surprising things to say.
Almost every student interviewed spoke of the importance of good communication in a parent-child relationship.
Two-Way Communication
“The ideal parent for me would be someone who is not afraid of two-way communication,” said 15-year-old Melanie Smith. “He or she would really listen and consider what I’m saying and not just try to pacify me.
“If we can have a frank conversation and see the pros and cons of any situation or subject, maybe we can both bend a little and compromise,” Melanie continued.
Most teens felt that parents needed to work on listening.
“A lousy parent is one that doesn’t listen to what you have to say and won’t let you express yourself,” said Michael Landers, 15.
Kimberly Seals, 16, agrees. “A lousy parent does not communicate with his or her child and takes things out on their kids.”
Listening requires openness. “A bad parent is one who’s not willing to listen and jumps to conclusions,” added Karen Carrillo, 16.
Problems, pressures, and frustrations go hand-in-hand with the teen years. We are not always sure who we are or where we are going in our lives. Peer pressure, SAT’s, college, and work decisions can overwhelm any teenager.
When things are falling apart, most teens look to their parents for support. Unfortunately, not all of them receive it. Having a parent who is supportive and sympathetic to problems seemed to be almost everyone’s ideal.
“I feel a good parent is one who listens and is always there for you,” said 16-year-old Jilda Toma. “She will stand by you and support you when you’re at your lowest point or if you make a mistake.
“But a bad parent is someone who ignores his child and has no concern
for his life, fears, insecurities, and problems,” Jilda continued.
Karen Carrillo says her mother is close to the ideal. “My mom is very understanding. I can always go to her when I have a problem. She’s always there for me, even through the bad times, and she supports my decisions.”
Friend or Parent?
“A perfect parent is a good friend as well as a good parent. He or she should be understanding and be there when you need them,” said Kimberly Seals.
But can a good parent also be a good friend? Most teens wanted friendship from their parents, but not without discipline.
“A perfect parent is one that can balance being an authoritarian and a friend at the same time,” said Leilani McClellan, 16.
“A parent should be a friend but not too soft or the child could get out of hand,” said 14-year-old Kristen Kleppel.
According to Scott Joachim, discipline is part of protecting your children. “If my parents let me stay out all night, they wouldn’t be good parents-you have to protect your kids,” he explained.
Kristen thinks spending time with your kids is also part of being a parent. “My dad is a friend, he’ll kid around with you. We go to Mets games, out to eat, and lots of other places. I can tell him about my problems,” she said.
We’ve all heard of the infamous “generation gap.” Every generation of kids complains that their parents are too out of touch with modern-day teen problems and can’t understand what teens of today are going through. Teens of the ’80s are no exception.
“When parents were young, they had their own trends and rules to obey. Now that they have kids of their own, they are trying to make us be what they were, since that was all they knew while growing up,” said Melanie Smith.
Similarly, Suzanne Mengharas wants “a parent who is understanding and relates to the `teenage situation.'”
Need to be’Up to Date’
Michael Landers thinks that “a perfect parent is an up-to-date parent, someone who knows what it’s like to live in the’80s and treats you according to today and not when they grew up.”
The feelings of these Benjamin Cardozo students show that many teens do want to be close to their parents and receive guidance and discipline from them, despite what many parents believe.
Communication, a shoulder to lean on, being a friend, showing love, and relating to their kids and their world-is that too much to ask of a parent? These students don’t think so, and hopefully, neither will the parents who are reading this.
[Special thanks to Ms. Vera Winitch, journalism teacher at Benjamin Cardozo HS, for her assistance in setting up these interviews.]

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.