You may have heard about the controversial story involving schoolteacher Ruth Sherman, some of the parents in her school, and a book called Nappy Hair by Carolivia Herron, a college professor. I read about it for the first time in the Dec. 14 issue of Newsweek.
If you don’t know, Ms. Sherman read the book Nappy Hair to her 3rd grade students.
When a few parents saw photocopies of some of the pages, they screamed at her and even threatened her life, and Ms. Sherman ended up leaving the school.
This is how it happened:
The Nappiest Hair in the World
Ms. Sherman was a 3rd grade teacher at P.S. 75, in Bushwick, Brooklyn.
In 1997, Ms. Sherman was a reading assistant, and her work with the principal, Felicita Santiago, boosted the reading levels of 3rd graders. So Ms. Santiago hired Ms. Sherman as a new teacher in the fall.
Ms. Sherman wanted to make reading interesting to her students, so she used books about different cultures to keep her students engaged.
She read a book about a Haitian boy who made a doll out of a broom, and a book about a Vietnamese girl who was teased about her clothes-the other kids said they looked like pajamas.
Then she read about a Black girl in a book called Nappy Hair, who had the nappiest hair in the world. And her students loved it.
They loved it so much, the 3rd graders wanted copies of the story. And Ms. Sherman gave them copies.
Celebrating Our God-Given ‘Fros
The story is about a little Black girl named Brenda who has the wildest, nappiest hair. The story is told by her uncle.
It brings up how her hair texture came about (from God), how it is connected to her African and slave roots, and how she is a cute, brown girl to be proud of because of her achievements.
Her hair is unruly and nappy, and because of it, and for a lot of other reasons, she is something special.
Parents Take Offense
But some of the parents in the school thought it was negative to read about nappy hair, probably because they only saw a few pages from the book, not the whole thing.
And they might have been offended by the fact that a White teacher was calling Black hair nappy, even though the book she was reading from was actually celebrating nappy hair.
Nappy hair is something a lot of people get teased about, and Black people in this country have often been made to feel that nappy hair is ugly.
They don’t even like the word “nappy.” But the book Nappy Hair does not do that. It reflects on the roots of that hair texture and it applauds the little girl in the story who has it.
The story does not down her, it honors her and how her hair came about.
The Book is Beautiful
These are my favorite lines in the story:
“Ain’t going to be nothing they come up with going to straighten this chile’s hair.
What you going to do?
I’m talking about straightening combs.
Can it really be?
I’m talking about relaxers and processes.
You said it.
Ain’t nothing going to straighten up the naps on this chile’s head.”
The story mentions that God intentionally gave Brenda that hair type, despite the disagreement of angels. It pleased him.
Then it goes on to mention Brenda’s connection to her ancestors, and the way her hair texture connects her to her past:
“So here she come.
Well.
Sitting back in Africa making plans.
That’s where it was.
Squinching her eyes and looking deep.
She was deep.
Getting ready to come to America with them slaves.
Didn’t we come over here?”
I think this story is beautiful. Brenda is acknowledged for being a wonderful creature and a proud Black girl, not despite her thick, curly do, but because of it.
Parents Threaten, Teacher Leaves Her School
The book goes on to call the girl “a rose among a thousand thorns.” If that is not a positive thing, then I no longer know what is negative.
I cannot comprehend what made the parents so upset, but they were.
Actually, only one parent who had a child in Ms. Sherman’s class was upset, but she organized another 50 or so parents in the school to protest. And these parents were totally heated.
The group of angry parents confronted Ms. Sherman. (Mind you, none of these parents even read the story. They only saw a picture or two from the book, and possibly read a few lines. Without trying to read the whole book, they obviously jumped to conclusions.)
Ms. Sherman’s life was threatened to her face at one point. After that, she left the school in the middle of the day, without getting to say anything to her students, and since then has been placed in another school.
Can White Teachers Teach About Race?
I think it was very uncivilized for parents to verbally threaten a teacher just because they did not like a particular book she read to her students.
Maybe the fact that the parents felt it was wrong for the teacher to teach about nappy hair really shows that they aren’t comfortable with their own culture.
After all, it’s a fact that lots of people in this city have nappy hair. You just have to look around to see it.
Or maybe they felt uncomfortable having a White teacher teach their kids about race. They might not want someone who has not experienced what they and their ancestors went through to teach them about discrimination.
Multiculturalism Opens Doors
They might not want to be reminded that they have full lips, nappy hair, broad noses and dark skin by a White person, who is more accepted by society. People get heated about race because their pride is at hand.
But people need to be aware of different cultures, and teachers should be allowed to teach about them.
It’s good to know something about another race that you never knew before, or learn something new about your own race or culture.
It broadens our understanding of history and the world, and it helps us understand our own communities better.
Besides, being multiculturally aware opens up doors for us to discuss things that we may not usually talk about because people are uncomfortable or embarrassed.
We Shouldn’t Be Afraid To Talk About It
If a multicultural curriculum is going to be taught, White teachers need to be able to teach about other cultures, too.
Teachers should keep their own stereotypes and prejudices out of the lessons, of course, and they should get information from valid sources. But the fact is, there are more White teachers than teachers of other races in this city.
So if we’re going to teach about race in our schools, often that’s the way it’s just going to be.
I think the biggest problem with the whole incident is that it may not affect only Ms. Sherman. It might cause teachers throughout the city to stop teaching about different cultures.
Some teachers who read about the drama that happened to Ms. Sherman may not feel comfortable teaching about race anymore. They’ll respond to what they read and get scared away.
Teachers need to be allowed the freedom to talk about controversial issues like race. They should not have to fear that they will get in trouble for it.
No Need to Explode
What happened to Ms. Sherman should have been avoided.
In my opinion, the book she read is great. But if parents did have concerns-and it’s good for parents to pay attention to what’s going on in their children’s schools-they should have complained to the teacher or the principal, or even moved their own children out of the classroom.
They should have sat down and had a discussion, and made their opinions known. But they should not have threatened the teacher, or assumed she was racist before they even read the whole book.
Maybe each side could have seen where they other side was coming from, and Ms. Sherman could have continued teaching a multicultural curriculum.
I think that would have been a good thing. Being able to discuss race in the classroom might deepen all of our understanding of our history and attitudes, and might actually one day make the issue of race in America less explosive.
Using the `N’ Word (Nappy)
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.