Twins, But Not the Same

Can my brother help me understand why we're so different?

When my brother moved back to New York last spring, all pandemonium was let loose in my heart. It was like Christmas, our birthday and the 4th of July all in one. What I wanted most for years was finally a reality! You see, my brother, John, is more than my brother. He’s my best friend and role model, and he’s my twin.
Growing up, John and I loved to play video games. Super Mario and Mortal Kombat were our favorites, and we would argue over the littlest things, like, “Oh, I wanted to pick this character,” just stupid stuff. We played Nok hockey at the local P.A.L. and drenched ourselves at the water pump on hot summer days.
‘Normal’ vs.’Different’
My brother and I both went through the horrors and wrath of our adoptive mom, getting hit with brooms, mops and belts. We reacted to her the same way when we were young-by being submissive-but when we got older John stayed out of her sights and never caused problems while Mom and I fought. After our fights, I left, going out for a few hours to calm down.
In school I was always bullied, and I had anger issues. John handled his anger and was never bullied. Somehow he seemed to come out “normal” despite all we’d been through, while I came out “different.”
Separated at 16
When I was 16 Mommy Dearest and I got into a fight. All of a sudden she came at me with a golf club and pretended she was Tiger Woods and I was a golf ball. I snapped and threatened to kill her. She got scared and called the cops, and I was sent to the hospital.
When I was cleared at 5 in the morning, all I wanted to do was make up with Mom and hit that pillow hard. But the doctor said to me, “Your mother said you can’t live there anymore. I’m going to contact ACS and someone will pick you up.”
About an hour later a man from ACS came and took me to Laight Street and I got put in a group home. What hurt me most was being separated from my twin and not knowing if I would ever be reunited with him.
After that, John and I talked, but we never talked about what happened. No matter what we feel, my twin and I have an unwritten rule forbidding any talk about the past.
‘My Brother Is Leaving’
I never really adjusted to being separated from my brother. In my first group home, I always felt lonely. Nothing felt in place. I had no one to give me advice or the courage to face obstacles in my path, which he always did and does even to this day. It felt so weird to speak on the phone or just to see him occasionally.
Just when I was starting to feel more comfortable being apart from my brother, he told me he was going to Job Corps upstate so he could get his GED and learn a trade in computers. His words felt like a punch in the gut. I was speechless. I couldn’t compute a complete thought except, “My brother’s leaving.”
But I couldn’t blame him. You see, he wanted to get away from our family’s bull-the alcoholics, the fights, the gossip and the drama.
Out of Touch
When John went to Job Corps he often asked me to write to him and I promised to. He even gave me his address every time he came to New York. But for some reason I just couldn’t. I wanted to talk to him, not write a letter like he was a pen pal.
Plus, I was a little jealous of John ’cause he “made it.” He was going to school and learning a trade. What was I doing? In foster care I was diagnosed with a mental illness, Borderline Personality Disorder, which means, point blank, that I have a bad impulse control problem. I was in and out of the hospital and dropped out of school.
Then, when we were 17, John joined the Army. I didn’t want him to join because I was afraid for him. My admiration for my brother was mixed with sad feelings about myself. You see, when I was little my foster mom used to tell stories about my biological dad being in the Army. I wanted to be a cop or an army general. But since I have a mental illness, the Army and NYPD won’t let me join.
Months Went By
With my brother in the Army, I knew that our relationship was going to change again. “When will we see each other? How will we keep in contact?” I asked myself.
While he was in the Army I would speak to John during infrequent phone calls from his post in Ft. Drum. When he was shipped to Iraq, we rarely kept in contact. Months would go by between phone calls, but he always made me feel good when I talked to him.
While John was away, my life was hard. I was homeless, depressed and getting through a nasty relationship. I didn’t know what to do, and I was suicidal. I didn’t tell my brother much until he came back home.
Together Again
For about six months after he came home from Iraq, my brother was living upstate. Then, after almost six years’ separation, he moved back to the city. He still looked the same: slim, handsome and funny, but he was noticeably built and had a muzzle burn on his arm from fighting.
My brother had changed in other ways since the last time I saw him: he’d come out as gay, he was more responsible and he didn’t hold his tongue anymore. he’d snap if you pushed him to the limit. But John is good company. He can make anyone smile, especially me.
My brother likes to spin glow sticks, shoot pool, dye his hair, go to movies and go to parties. He has an inviting personality. When we go out together, heads turn and all eyes are on John. People stop him to compliment him on his clothes or hair.
Since he came back home, my whole life has been a little better. We shop, play pool, sometimes walk around the Bronx and smoke a J., or just chill at Grandma’s house and listen to a lot of dance music. We shoot the breeze for hours on end.
Showing Who I Am
Since my brother’s been here, he’s seen me struggle with my mental illness. I don’t know if he understands what I’m dealing with, because I don’t like to talk about my illness in specifics, but he’s seen the results.
One time I was at my cousin Myra’s house and Myra told John, “I want Mike to leave. He’s acting weird.” John told me I had to leave.
I said, “Why the f-ck Myra can’t tell me to leave? Why you doing it?”
I got into a yelling match with my whole family. When I left I popped a lot of pills and drank a lot and ended up in the hospital. It was scary. I hadn’t spazzed like that in front of John before and I thought he wouldn’t talk to me again.
John was angry. He told me that if I end up in the hospital again, he won’t visit me, which hurts. But I’m trying not to spazz because I don’t want to lose my brother and I don’t want him to worry.
Memories of Our Past
My brother is trying to help me stay calm. Once John and I were at our mom’s house and she was ranking on me. John noticed I was getting mad so he pulled me to the back room and told me, “Take what Mom says with a grain of salt.” He’s right, but it’s hard not to let her get under my skin.
If John has any scars from our messed up childhood he hides them well. When I compare myself to my brother I get a little down. We are the same age but he’s calmer and has accomplished so much more. Sometimes I feel like I haven’t accomplished anything. I see that I have not fully healed from my past.
I wish we could talk about the past so we both can understand what happened to us. As close as we are, I wish I could tell him how I still struggle and how thinking about our past sometimes makes me so sad. It truly hurts that I still don’t understand why, if we both went through the same violence, we turned out so different.
Could He Help Me Heal?
Maybe we don’t speak about the abuse because John has not been able to let go of the past. Or maybe he’s let go and doesn’t want to bring up old memories. Sometimes I think it’s better this way because if we did talk about the abuse, where would the conversation go? Would we both get mad? I wonder if I could handle it if I brought up painful memories with my brother and then was at home by myself.
But still, I wish I could understand how he’s so normal and I’m soâdifferent. I hope I can get the courage to ask John to help me understand why, even though we are twins, we’re not the same.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.