Tug of War

My dad asked my two younger sisters and me to come sit around the dining room table. It was Christmas vacation, 1997, and I had just turned 14. My dad looked worn. He sighed the heaviest sigh I had ever heard.
“Girls,” he said, “your mother and I, weâit’s just not working, so we are going to get a divorce.”
The words hit me like an aluminum bat swung at full speed. What should I say? What should I do? Divorce was such a foreign-sounding word. I couldn’t believe it would ever become a part of my vocabulary, even though I knew that my parents’ marriage was disintegrating.
The only knowledge I had of divorce came from The Baby Sitter’s Club books and ABC after-school specials. They always presented a positive image shrouding the pain of divorce, as if it were a benefit to have two of everything.
But when I thought of divorce that day around the dining room table, I could feel each of my parents pulling me to their side, as if I was the thick rope in a vicious game of tug of war.
The traumas of divorce are bad enough for parents, but it is even worse on kids. I’ve been through so many emotions, few of them positive, that I never experienced until the divorce. I could not have imagined how long my parents’ divorce would continue to plague my life.
The Signs Were There
I was in shock when my dad made his announcement, but it was bound to happen. Ever since I was 10, there had been what felt like an invisible wall between my mom and dad. My dad’s face was always drawn tight. My mom was downhearted almost every day. If they did have any tender feelings for each other, they never showed it. Our home was devoid of those Brady Bunch feelings: no love, no togetherness, no family.
Whenever I came into the house, I could feel the tension mash down on my chest. My parents were always arguing, especially about expenses. When one of my sisters or I came in the room, the arguing would stop abruptly, but as soon as we left it started again.
To make things worse, my dad was always staying “late” at his job. I think it was his way of avoiding confrontations with my mother. As this excuse became more frequent, even I grew suspicious about his stories.
It wasn’t fair to us because we didn’t get to spend as much time with him as we used to. I began to wonder if maybe I was the problem, maybe he didn’t want to see me anymore.
When my parents did see each other, my dad would always look at my mom as if she were a specimen under a microscope, not his wife of 14 years. She would look at him as if she had left her soul on the doorstep.
‘Happy New Year!’
It didn’t seem as if things could get any worse, but they did. On New Year’s Eve, just a few days after my dad told us about the divorce, he did not come home. I didn’t know where he was.
I guess I didn’t think anything of it until I saw my mom holding back tears. “We have to be strong because I don’t think your daddy is coming back to us,” she said. That was right before the countdown to the new year.
I looked at my two sisters and they looked as if they were going to cry. None of us said anything. My mother pulled us all into a huddled embrace.
My dad came back a few days later and my parents started to argue again. It was so bad I took my sisters into the basement to get away from all the yelling, cursing and fighting going on upstairs. I tried to cheer up my sisters by talking about our Christmas presents, but they just sat there, their faces blotted with tears.
Mama Leaves the Nest
My dad came crashing downstairs and told us to go upstairs. His face was twisted in anger.
When we came upstairs my mom was standing in the staircase with her jacket wrapped around her and a suitcase beside her on the step. Her face was expressionless, but her chin was thrust forward and she was trying not to look at us.
“Your mom has to go,” my dad said, glaring at her.
I didn’t know what to say. My younger sister, who was 7, cried quietly. I felt like I was about to pass out.
“Remember this, girls,” my dad said. “Never bite the hand that feeds you.”
My dad was facing my sisters and me but I knew he was talking to my mom. I heard the horn of a taxi blare and, with that, my mom was gone.
It was as if someone reached in and pulled my heart right through my rib cage. My dad looked as if he had let a burden go. He assured us that everything would be normal once we got used to living with only him.
The rest of the day was filled with fake smiles and forced laughter. My dad tried to have us come together and make spaghetti as a “family,” but it was impossible to pretend that nothing had happened.
A Week with Daddy
That week with my dad was a little blurred. How would you feel if your mom was there one day and gone the next? I was devastated. I was confused. I missed my mother. Why would one parent do this to the other?
I think my dad threw my mom out because he wanted to rebuild his family without my mom’s input. He believed he was the more concerned parent. “Now I can raise you like I always wanted to,” he said with a satisfied smile.
I always knew that my dad was a more demanding parent. He wanted us to have the highest grades possible, to dream and to learn about life. He was always talking about the future and how he was looking forward to sending us away to college. I’ve always admired my dad’s ability to dream and have others dream with him. But what bothered me was that he expected us to forget about my mom.
Whoop! Whoop! That’s The Sound of the Police
A few days after my mom left, I was coming home with some friends from the pizza parlor. I had hardly spoken to her since she left, and when I did it felt awkward. As we approached the end of my block, I saw flashing lights in front of my house. Why were the police at my door?
I didn’t know what was going on and I didn’t want to find out. Did something happen to my sisters?! I hesitated at first, but then I ran to my house. My mom was standing in the living room.
She had brought the police to allow her to come back into the house because she was afraid of my dad. She had been staying at my uncle’s house.
The police were in my living room asking my dad questions, my younger sisters were on the couch crying and my friends were outside peering in. I was overwhelmed. I cried for the first time since she had left.
I Will Survive
When my mom moved back in, the atmosphere in the house got even worse. My parents had vicious arguments. I would leave the room so I wouldn’t have to hear them bad-mouthing each other.
I was depressed. I stopped eating, I stopped doing my homework and my sisters and I were always fighting.
I always felt like I was going to cry or pass out. My head was always aching. I would tune out my teachers during class. I stopped going to a lot of my after-school activities.
When my 13-year-old sister asked me, “Do you think we would be able to go live with Grandma?” I realized that my sisters were just as miserable as I was.
One night, a couple of months after my mom returned, my parents were arguing again. It stopped suddenly. I heard my dad zipping a suitcase and slamming a door. He came into my room. “Baby, you up? Come downstairs.”
My sisters and I came slowly down the stairs, not knowing what to expect.
It was the first time I had ever seen my dad cry. He tried to play it off but I could tell he was crying. It brought tears to my eyes because I knew his were tears of frustration and sadness.
“Well, girls, I didn’t think it would have to come to this.”
He stood with his duffel bag in our little kitchen shaking his head. He just repeated, “I can’t, I can’tâ” I knew he was talking about all the fighting with my mom. The whole scene was so surreal.
I was frozen on the staircase, my two younger sisters crouched behind me. The only noise was our sniffles. It was the first time in a long time that I heard my dad tell us that he loved us, deeply and sincerely.
Separated and It Feels So ‘Good’
My mom and dad were separated for about a year after my dad left that day. They were a little happier because they didn’t have to be around each other.
My mom’s smiles lasted a little longer, which made me smile a little longer too. She was more relaxed. The guard that she had kept up around my dad was let down. It was nice seeing her enjoy her life. What saddened me was that my dad had to be out of the picture for her to be happy.
My dad also seemed more relaxed when my mom wasn’t around. He would take my sisters and me to Prospect Park to play baseball or to King’s Plaza Mall.
When we played baseball, he would say, “Try to hit it out of the park, baby!” Even though I couldn’t bat to save my life, it made me feel good that my dad was egging me on. It made me see that my dad really did care, that he was just as happy to see me as I was to see him.
Even though there was a lot less tension after my parents’ separation, there was still a lot of pressure with my dad gone. There was never enough money to go around, even when my dad gave us money. It was still not enough for the mortgage, domestic bills and three children. I had to use my summer job paycheck to help feed my sisters and me.
Slowly my mother fell into a depression. She would call her sister more, she would cook less and she spent more time alone in her bedroom. My dad was not there physically and my mom was not really there either, so as the eldest, I stepped in and took over. I wanted to make sure my sisters were taken care of. I became the parent even though I was only 14.
I made sure my sisters had dinner, did their homework and went to school on time. My middle sister and I kept the house clean. I told my sisters, “Things will get better one day.” That was what I was hoping but that wasn’t what happened.
My sisters dubbed me “Mama” because I was the mother at the time. It was helpful to know that someone appreciated what I was doing.
My mom didn’t seem to notice, though. “Why is it that every time I walk in the house it’s dirty?” was all she would say before she went upstairs and shut her bedroom door. I guess she was still dealing with my dad leaving and all the pressures from work and home.
It’s My Life
My dad called every day to talk to us. But my sisters didn’t want to talk to the man they held responsible for their sadness.
As usual, I was torn. I knew that my father wanted to talk to me and I didn’t want to disappoint him, but I felt as if I was betraying my mom by talking to my dad.
So to please them both, I talked to my dad when my mom wasn’t there and I didn’t mention my dad when she could hear.
I tried to keep my sisters from the drama. I kept on smiling, but it was emotionally draining. In reality, my grades, my social life and my conscience were on the fry. I was tired of the pressure. My hair even started falling out.
I would complain daily to my dad that I was unhappy. He said, “If you stayed with me then you’d probably have less stress.” I was starting to believe it, since my home life was eating at my nerves like rats at garbage. I started to hint that I might go with him.
Looking back on it now, I don’t think it was fair that my dad tried to convince me to live with him. I think he was insensitive to my pain over the separation.
One day in September, when the house was empty, I started crying loudly. No one was there, no one cared, except Daddy. He was the one who called daily and asked how I was.
I made an impulsive decision, though it was one I had been contemplating for some time. I flew upstairs to my room and packed my duffel bag, put on my coat and called my dad. At the time, I thought it was the right decision to move in with him.
A Therapist to Decide My Fate?
Well, with my impulsive decision came a barrage of proceedings. My mom and dad’s divorce had been going on for about a year at this point. The custody battle would have happened regardless. But I think my decision pushed it into effect quicker.
My dad hired a lawyer and a forensic therapist. The therapist would determine if we went with our mom or our dad. I was afraid what I said would affect where we ended up. My dad said I should just tell the truth.
The therapist was nice but was he there to help me or just collect his check? Was he siding more with my dad because he was paying him or was he being fair in his judgments? Even though I worried about his fairness, it made me feel good that someone was concerned about how the kids felt in the middle of all this confusion.
In the end, my dad won custody of me and my sisters.
My mom made me feel like a traitor since I had chosen Daddy over Mommy. She made me feel I was the one tearing the family apart. It made me angry that she would even think that I was choosing one parent over the other.
It’s not that I loved my father more than I did her. It was just such a relief not having to take care of my sisters or clean up the house anymore. I was just doing what I felt was best for myself.
If I had one wish it would be that my mom and dad loved one another again. I would like my family back together. The reality is that will never happen, and that has to be the harshest realization of all.

SIDEBAR: After the Divorce: Don’t Ask Me to Choose
You know the saying, “The grass is always greener on the other side of the fence?” It’s funny how cliches are so true. I chose to live with my dad, but I miss my mom so much. I know I sound spoiled but I don’t care. There are people who don’t even like their parents, but I do. I love them both very much. It breaks my heart to see my family torn. After my parents split up, I chose to live with my dad. But, now that I live with him, I want to live with my mom. I thought living with my dad would be a good thing. But he’s not as easygoing as my mom. I know my dad has always had my sisters’ and my best interests at heart and that he really cares about us. But, there are times when I can’t stand him. He assumes things without taking everything into perspective, he feels that everything he says is law and he gets angry over mistakes that I didn’t mean to make. What really gets me is when he expects me to act like a Marine. He always says, “Be a man.” I’m not a man, I’m a girl! Or he’ll tell me, “You shouldn’t cry, it’s not going to help you.” Well, sometimes you just need to cry. He always assumes I have a boyfriend or that I’m skipping school to hang out with my friends, which is not true. But there are other times when I love living with my dad, like when he makes sure I have everything I need, does anything to get it and is always behind me 110%. I know that if I had stayed with my mom, I would still be wanting to live with my dad. My mom seems happier now. She has moved on in her life. So maybe I did the right thing. Maybe the divorce wasn’t a catastrophe after all.
Why Can’t There Be Clones?
I still have to choose between my parents on a weekly basis. Do you ever wish there were two of you? That’s exactly how I feel when the weekend rolls around. My dad is so sweet (when he wants to be) but he is just not as fun as my mom. She makes me laugh a lot, she always buys me stuff even when she really shouldn’t and she always wants to do something. I guess those are the things I love about her. When my sisters and I choose which parent to spend the weekend with, we don’t want to seem ungrateful. My heart aches when I have to turn down one parent and go with the other. Even though they try to sound as if they’re all right about it, there is always that hint of disappointment in their voices. It’s like they’ve lost a chess match and are half-hearted in congratulating the winner. It’s bad enough that they make us choose who to go with, but they always try to outdo each other. I think it’s immature.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.