Torn Between Mom and Dad

My best memories of my father are from when I was 5 years old. He used to take me to the university where he had classes, and let me run around and draw. He used to drive me to church in his purple Volkswagon bug with the black leather seats.
And then he was gone.
Until I was 12, I didn’t think too much about why he had moved out or why he never came to visit. That’s when I started overhearing my mother’s phone conversations with him. They would argue about why he didn’t send any child support, and why my mother should not be blamed for my not writing to him frequently.
Overhearing those conversations shattered my dream that we would one day be a family again. So began the most confusing, painful and taxing period of my life, when I experienced what I now realize was a terrible depression.
Torn Between Mom and Dad
I had always had this perfect image of my invisible father. It seemed like he was this mysterious Superman character-the way he appeared and disappeared from my life. There was an occasional letter and phone calls on my birthday and Christmas. The conversations were usually brief because it cost him a lot of money to call from Brazil or Guyana.
At 12, I started to speculate about why my dad didn’t live with us and I started to ask my mother uninhibited questions. She would give me a description of how malevolent he was. “He never let me have my own money. I had to ask him for an allowance just to buy groceries or something for myself,” she told me. “He was so manipulative that he would make me feel like I deserved him beating me up for defying him.”
Maybe He Wasn’t So Great
I would visualize the torment and emotional shredding my mother went through and question myself about how great my dad really was. I mean, if he was so wonderful, why didn’t Mom ever say anything positive about him, and why did I never hear her mention his coming back to the U.S. to live with us?
I was halfway between hating what my father did to me and my mother, and wanting him to come back into my life. Even though I started to see his faults, my young mind still thought my dad could be the solver of all my problems, and the lifter of all the burdens in my life.
But Why Was My Mom So Harsh?
Everything felt wrong. Little things like my grades, or my mother reprimanding me about fighting with my younger sister started to irritate me. It seemed that my mother was always treating her more softly than me. I was constantly being yelled at: “Don’t yell at your sister! Be more kind!” Life was not being kind to me, so why did I have to show kindness to anyone else?
I would cry every day, more than once a day, lamenting to my soaked pillow the woes of being an older sister, and how mean my mom was, and how everything would be better if we were all one big happy family again.
I started to dread coming home after school to be around my annoying sister-she didn’t know what I was going through because her father still visited her sometimes.
I would brood over the fact that we had different fathers, and hers seemed to care more, and that Mom was going to marry him and leave me as the only one in our house with my dad’s last name-my legacy.
My grades started to slip because I had no motivation to continue. All I heard was my mother telling me that I could do better, and asking why this was marked wrong, or when I was going to do this or that.
Once in a while, my dad called and gave me the same old speech on how he knew that I would succeed because I was his daughter. Then he’d say, “Isn’t your mother helping you?” and, “Just keep up your studies.”
Was It All My Fault?
My friends would ask me, “What’s wrong? Why do you always look so sad?” I would say that it was nothing, of course. I complained about my mother and sister sometimes, but I don’t think I told even my closest friends what was really wrong.
I felt that I could not put such a heavy burden on them, with their sheltered, two-parent households. They would not be able to handle the instability of my family life. All they knew was that I used to live in England, and I had a cute baby sister-details were not an issue.
It even got to the point where I felt that everything that went wrong was my fault. I thought that if I hadn’t been born, my mother would have had the strength and courage to leave my father sooner. I was some extra baggage.
I started being more aware of the inconsistencies and shortcomings of all my relatives. I saw broken marriages, delinquent cousins and deeper damage, too. It made me think that there was some genetic defect in my mother’s family, and every time I heard some new tragedy I felt more ashamed.
Suicidal Fantasies
I caught myself staring into space a lot more. When I was 13, I kept thinking about walking up to the roof of my 15-floor apartment building and jumping off.
In school, I would sit in class and stare out the window, visualizing myself slowly tumbling down to the welcoming grass or sidewalk. That image would help me find some peace amid the din of frustrating math or boring science.
My mother came into my room after school many times when I got too quiet, and either found me sitting on the bed like a zombie, or with my face buried in my pillow, stifling my cries. She would say, “Get up. You are way too young to be making your face like that. I’m sorry that you think you have to cry every time something goes wrong, but you have to be stronger. God is your guide.”
Sometimes when I heard a version of this lecture I would say, “But it never seems like He’s there, and I have to live with knowing what I know.”
I told Mom that I felt that nobody loved me, and I was being treated like Cinderella with all the chores I had to do. All I got was a hug, an “everything will be all right,” and a speech that started out as an esteem booster and ended off being a “not good enough” scolding.
Mom Didn’t Understand
My mother would start out with, “Don’t preoccupy yourself with what happened in the past. You know I love you and will always be there for you.”
Then, all of a sudden, she would switch to, “That’s why you have to apply yourself. Why do I have to keep on telling you that when you have a test or a project coming up to tell me about itâ” Blah, blah, blah!
I know now that Mom was probably feeling pretty helpless and annoyed at my bawling for my father. It was not a picnic raising two girls as different as night and day, and seven years apart. But back then, she just seemed insensitive.
She did not seem to understand how important it was for me to stay connected to both her and my father and how hard she was making that.
My dad seemed more benevolent and “nicer” since he was far away and not directly involved in my life.
Expressing My Emotions In Writing
I needed to find some way to deal with all these conflicting emotions. I heard about a writing workshop for junior high and high school girls. It was all about outspokenness and freedom to express your feelings. I decided to join.
We met on Mondays, and there were about 12 of us. I was surprised to find out some of the problems that other girls in the group had. One girl had to deal with an abusive stepdad, another was adopted, another was sexually active. Almost every girl had something that pulled her down now and then, but I still felt alone. The others seemed to be able to get over their problems easier, and were strong in their opinions and character. I felt invisible and wrote a poem about it:
the flittering insect
trying to survive
among the flock of others.
So am I, the butterfly
at any moment it could drop dead,
but no one would notice.
So am I, the butterfly
Talking to Counselors
One day the head of the workshop called me aside, after she read my poems and reaction pieces on depression. I could tell that she was worried about what she read, because soon I was talking to some counselors at the organization that ran the workshop.
They asked me the same questions over and over in a concerned, patronizing manner. “How did what your mother said make you feel?” “Do you think you could ask your dad what happened?” “Are you and your sister getting along any better?”
I got so annoyed that I just told them straight out about my thoughts of jumping off my roof. But, at the same time, I was finally getting the attention I longed for, and these people really seemed to care.
They had a session where all of us and our parents individually talked to counselors, I guess to try to bridge the communication gap between parents and their teen daughters.
When my turn came, my mother and I ended up talking to the same women I had spoken to before. They asked my mom questions about her background and raising me, while I was a cold stone in my seat. I showed no emotion whatsoever; I was determined not to crack.
Giving Mom a Chance
But when my mom started talking about taking care of me and my sister without either father in the house, I felt very broken inside. Mom started crying, and so did I, because I hated seeing my mother in such a state of helplessness. All my tears of anger, sadness and frustration at her, at myself and at my fragmented family came rushing out in that meeting, and I finally hugged my mother with feeling.
It was only one session, but it changed a lot in my life for the better. After that, I was able to talk about my feelings in the workshop with ease and I got a lot of support from the others.
It was also the beginning of a much better relationship with my mother. Mom and I still have our clashes of opinion, especially when I complain about my sister, but we can understand each other’s feelings more when it comes to delicate subjects of the past. I have a more sympathetic view of her and a less idealized image of my dad than when I was younger.
I am glad to say that I do not have suicidal thoughts anymore, but rather more positive plans for the future, like going away to college, and learning how to be independent. And even though more things I didn’t know about my family are still being revealed to me, I can accept them as imperfections of the human heart, and not the end of my world.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.