Recently, a law was passed called the Adoption and Safe Families Act [ASFA]. The law states that when any child has been in foster care for 15 out of 22 months, the agency that she’s in must go to court to begin proceedings to terminate parental rights. That way, the child can be placed up for adoption.
Now I know there are those of you out there who are probably saying to yourselves that this law won’t and can’t affect you. You’re thinking, “So what’s the big deal? It’s just another law.”
But actually this law is a shocker. It’s about to bring a whole new meaning to the term “family” for some kids in foster care.
Because of ASFA, many families will be torn apart, while at the same time, new ones will be formed. Some kids will lose contact with their biological parents while getting a chance to start over with new parents. Other kids will lose their biological parents but have no one to turn to but the system.
Too Long in Care
ASFA was originally passed because there are too many kids spending too much time in foster care. The president and the people in Congress who make the laws believe that every child should have a permanent place to live and grow up. Because foster care does not give us permanent homes, they thought it would be better for kids to get adopted than to wait for years and years in care.
Therefore, they gave biological parents the option to get their lives together-quickly-so they can take their kids in care back home, or lose their kids permanently.
“Foster care is not supposed to be a permanent way of life. It’s the way the government is supposed to take care of kids temporarily,” said Maris Blechner, one of the founders of an adoption agency for hard-to-place children (like many of us teens in foster care) called Family Focus.
“The federal law ASFA says children shouldn’t spend their lives in foster care. We should either get the family fixed up, or the child should get adopted,” she added.
The idea is that kids need stable homes. They shouldn’t be bouncing around the system, and they shouldn’t be bouncing in and out of the system, either, going home to their families only to return to care. Last year, 11% of kids who entered foster care in New York City had been in the system before, but due to unfortunate circumstances at home, they had to return.
But Will the Law Help?
When kids don’t have a stable home and family, it makes it harder for us in all sorts of ways. It’s harder to concentrate and do well in school. It’s harder to form close relationships with peers and adults. It’s harder just to feel good about ourselves. When we grow up, it can make it more difficult to find and keep a good job, create a close family of our own and just be happy.
So getting a permanent home faster sounds good. But many people are not sure that’s what this law is going to do for kids.
Nobody’s Children
For one thing, critics say that just because you terminate biological parents’ rights doesn’t mean you’ll find a kid a stable home. Only a small percentage of kids in care get adopted, and those are usually the younger children.
Last year, according to the New York State Children and Family Services, there were 38,440 kids in foster care in New York City. About a third of those kids had adoption as their goal. But only about one-fourth of those were adopted (that is 3,086 kids).
Sure, that’s a lot of kids who were adopted. But it’s a heck of a lot of kids who were not. So even if many more kids do get adopted, it still may hardly make a dent on all the kids in care.
Instead, what might happen is that ASFA could create a lot of legal orphans-kids whose parents’ rights have been terminated, but who aren’t being adopted, and who are just floating around, with no legal guardians but the state.
Broken Families
Critics of the bill are also angry because they say that parents are being given up on too quickly, and are not being given a chance to show that they can be responsible parents. They say that in the past, child welfare agencies had to ask, “Why terminate parents’ rights?” but now with ASFA in place, the question has become, “Why should we not terminate parents’ rights?”
They say ASFA’s fatal flaw is that it hurries up the breaking up of families but does nothing to ensure that parents get equally speedy access to the services they need-like drug rehab programs and family counseling-to get their lives together so that they get their kids back. They say that if more energy was put into helping families in crisis, those families could become stable homes.
“We need to put the emphasis on supporting families that can be saved,” said Sharone Salaam of People United For Children, located in Harlem, which represents biological parents whose kids have been taken away from them.
Whichever way you look at it, this law is bound to have a big impact on kids and their families. Maybe it will give parents a kick in the pants to hurry up and get their acts and their families back together. Other parents, though, will fail.
Only Time Will Tell
Maybe some of those are parents who constantly return to rehab programs, but constantly relapse; who always miss their court appointments and always seem to have some kind of an excuse; who seem to have just given up on everything and want no help at all. Maybe having their rights terminated would be the best thing for their kids. But some are probably parents who could change but aren’t getting the help they need.
We’ll just have to wait and see if this new law actually helps us get the stable homes we’ve been denied, or only makes things harder when life is already hard enough.
SIDEBAR: Last Chance for Parents
Now that you’ve heard a little about this law, it probably sounds very drastic-and it is. But before I go any further, let me clarify a few points, because with ASFA, agencies aren’t supposed to just go and start taking people’s children away from them and putting them up for adoption. There are some points in the law that are designed to protect parents’ rights and give parents a break.
o First, if the agency documents a plan to reunify the child with the parent, then they don’t have to go to court to terminate the parent’s rights. For instance, if the parent hasn’t done everything she needs to do to get her children back within the 22-month time frame, but the agency can show that she’s pretty far along in being able to provide a safe home for her children, then the agency doesn’t have to go to court.
o Second, If a child is being cared for by a relative, then the agency doesn’t have to worry about ASFA.
o Third, when a judge rules that an agency has not done all it could do to possibly allow a parent to get herself together, such as not providing sufficient drug programs, help in finding housing, and personal and family therapy, her parental rights won’t be terminated. Critics say that agencies are going to court to terminate parents’ rights without providing all these services. But according to the law, at least, if an agency does not do it’s job, then parents aren’t supposed to be punished. And when an agency does go to court, that doesn’t mean that the parents’ rights are automatically terminated. A judge will look at each case and decide. But even with all those exemptions, filings to terminate parental rights have gone up by 1/3 in the state of New York-to 4,201-since 1999 when the law was passed. And 90% of the cases that go to court end up in termination-which means a lot more parents are losing their rights than before, and a lot more children might end up in care indefinitely.
