Even though I am Jewish, my family was never very religious as I was growing up. We always chose what appealed to us from the Torah (the laws, teachings and divine knowledge of Judaism). I never observed the sabbath (the Jewish day of rest and prayer celebrated on Saturday). I wear pants (which some religious Jews consider inappropriate attire for a woman) and sometimes the food I eat may not be kosher (conform to Jewish dietary laws).
I never saw anything wrong with this until I was sent to an Orthodox Jewish school. (Orthodox Jews follow religious law and tradition much more closely than Conservative or Reformed Jews.) Suddenly, my eyes were opened up.
I was sent to an Orthodox school (yeshiva) in seventh grade because my family thought it would be safer than public school. They also thought it was a way for me to learn more about my identity and what it means to be Jewish. I quickly realized how different my lifestyle was from my new classmates.
No More Mini Skirts
I found out that Orthodox Jews cannot wear clothing like minis and tank tops. Their clothes are more modest: skirts that cover the knees and a shirt or blouse with sleeves up to or covering the elbow.
I started dressing like they did for school, but afterwards I would change into a pair of jeans. As a Conservative Jew, I had always worn whatever I wanted. Suddenly, I found out that the clothes I had been wearing were not right.
Keeping kosher was another big topic. Jewish dietary laws prohibit you from mixing meat and dairy products together. (You can’t eat cheeseburgers, for example.) You have to wait six hours after eating meat before you can eat dairy. You can’t eat any seafood that doesn’t have scales or fins, so shrimp and other shellfish are a no-no. You also can’t eat pork or ham.
Conservative Jews don’t follow these rules as closely as Orthodox Jews do, so I was used to eating whatever I wanted. Suddenly, someone was telling me that the food I was putting into my body was not right.
A Day of Rest and Prayer
I was also exposed to a real celebration of the sabbath for the first time. It was like nothing I had experienced. On sabbath, you’re not allowed to physically create anything which means you can’t work. You can’t turn on electricity (no watching TV or listening to the stereo) or drive in a car either. Religious Jews celebrate the sabbath by lighting candles, having special meals with their families, and praying. To me, the sabbath had always been just like any other day of the week.
I was confused by all the new things I was learning. There were sharp contradictions between my home life and life at school. I had always considered myself Jewish and now I was being told that I wasn’t, really. It’s like going through life thinking you’re an orange and then being told that you’re an apple.
I was frustrated at how one teacher in particular was always trying to get me to become more religious, even though I wasn’t sure I wanted to. I enjoyed my life so much that I was afraid to give it up. At the same time, I was starting to feel guilty that I didn’t celebrate holidays like Passover (which marks the time the Jews escaped slavery in Egypt) or Yom Kippur (the Day of Atonement) correctly.
I had also grown to love the traditional shabat (sabbath) celebration. Teachers would invite me and other students to their houses to sleep over and experience the sabbath. We’d talk, sing songs, go for walks in the evening, and eat a lot at meals. The teachers would try to stay up the whole night learning Torah, but the rest of us would be out by midnight. I began to see the sabbath as a time of tranquility, purity, and holiness.
Putting Others First
In many ways, going to an Orthodox school has made me a better person. At school, we contribute to charity, take food and old clothes to the poor, visit nursing homes, and help women who can’t afford babysitters take care of their children. We contribute money to buy presents for orphans during the holidays. These activities have taught me to think of others, especially those who are not as well off as me.
I often feel torn between Orthodoxy and Conservatism. These days, I consider myself Conservative but with Orthodox influences. I sometimes doubt that Orthodoxy is right for me, since the laws regarding the holidays, keeping kosher, and observing the sabbath are so hard to follow. I’m still trying to find my way. But my experiences at school have made me realize more than ever what a beautiful religion Judaism is.
There’s More Than One Way to Be Jewish
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.