The United States is the crime and violence capital of the world. More lives are lost each year to violence in the US than the number of Americans killed during the Vietnam war. The recent increase in the number of murders in New York is only one part of the larger picture. In many ways, violence in New York is an extension of the violence that is increasing nationwide.
Like many of us, Eddie Mebane, 19, of West Side HS in Manhattan, doesn’t feel safe in New York: “Now everybody’s running in a posse. If you’re not running in a group, you’re going to get jumped. People around my block don’t like me. They think I’m a goody two-shoes.”
“I’m afraid for my life because a lot of my friends are dying for no reason and I don’t want to be one of them, ” said Barry Foster, 19, also of West Side HS.
Talib Abdul Assim, 19, agreed: “Youth are unsafe anywhere. There is no such thing as a safe place anywhere.”
Teens Don’t Feel Safe
Eddie, Barry, and Talib have a good reason to be scared. For teenagers 15-19 in New York City, the leading cause of death is homicide and the majority of the homicides are committed by other teenagers.
Although crime in New York City has reached massive proportions, it is very bad in other cities and states too. Black men have the highest murder rates. The National Center for Health Statistics said that in 1987, the homicide rate in New York for Black men was 137 per 100,000 while Michigan had a homicide rate of 232 per 100,000 with many of them occurring in Detroit. The rate for Washington, D.C. was slightly higher than New York, 139 per 100,000. As you can see, New York is not the only place suffering from a wave of violence. The United States as a whole is plagued by crime.
What about the rest of the world? Are things worse in other countries? Not at all. The Journal of the American Medical Association reported that in 1987 in the United States, among men 15-24, 22 per 100,000 were killed. We ranked number one in the industrialized world. Scotland ranked number two, but our rates are over four times as high as theirs. And men in this age group in the United States are killed forty times as often as in Japan. Why is homicide so common in the United States?
Drugs and Homicide
Mebane said that selling drugs was the number one reason why so many get killed.
“They think that’s the easiest way out. It’s hard to get a decentpaying job, especially without education…get the girls, get the money and be known,” said Mebane.
Wayne Winborne, research coordinator at the Center for Law and Social Justice in Brooklyn said it’s important to put the killing in context. “The shootouts…those are dealers who are not drug addicts, they’re businessmen. They’re business people, part of an economy,” said Winborne.
Another factor is that guns are easier to get here than in almost any other country. Even though New York State has strong gun control laws compared to other states, Winborne feels that a New York policy is not enough: “There has to be a national policy…we have to deal with the gun manufacturers and we have to make it difficult to do business in the United States…[but] The National Rifle Association is a powerful lobby and they are against any form of gun control.”
It’s Too Easy To Get Guns
One 19 year-old student who attends West Side HS remembered the time he owned a gun and said it was a matter of following the trend. “I owned a .32 automatic. At that time I thought: everybody has a gun, why not me. I used it for show and prove, not show and tell.”
“There are deep seated attitudes involved about violence and weapons that I think are woven into the fabric of this country and the whole notion of the right to bear arms, even for people who don’t know where it comes from, still have that deep sense of ‘I have the right…I should have the right,’ ” stated Winborne. Guns have become a part of American culture and gun control is one of our biggest problems.
Winborne also felt that there was a link between American culture and violence. He said that movies and film play a big role in the attitude of American society toward violence:
“If a filmmaker has a scene where the man is caressing a woman’s breast, that will get an ‘X’ rating, but if that same filmmaker has a scene where that man is shooting that woman’s breast off with a double barrel shotgun, that’ll get an ‘R.’
“That sends a clear message to our young people as to how we perceive violence, how much we glorify violence, how much we think it is acceptable…and I think it’s that context that has given rise to very casualattitudes on the part of our young people to violent behavior.”
Violence and the Media
Winborne also stated that the role of the hero in movies has changed and that at one time it was enough for the hero to win, but now it’s necessary for the hero to kill the villain for a movie viewer to be satisfied.
Although the media influence social attitudes, there are other factors involved. The diversity of the United States may also play a role.
Linda Lantieri, coordinator of the Resolving Conflict Creatively Program (RCCP is a program that promotes education in conflict resolution in New York City public high schools), explained that America is extremely diverse. “If you look at other places in the world, the diversity is not as profound and not as distinct as we have here in the US.”
Because we have people living here from so many different racial and ethnic groups, it is automatically going to be harder for us to get along.
Diversity a Factor
Winborne felt that diversity was wonderful, but said: “If one group is placed above another group or valued more than another group…If one group is constantly competing with another group for resources and there isn’t an even flow of those resources back and forth, that’s when you’re going to get problems.”
Lantieri also cited education as a major factor in the way our society perceives violence. “Lots [of students] around us do not get the message that it is wonderful to be non-violent, [to be] a creative problem solver, [to] think of a way to solve a problem without fighting or without walking away. I think education plays a significant role there.”
Lantieri continued: “We need to begin to see the action of non-violently resolving conflict as the hero’s choice. That it is really a choice that is showinga deeper character, a better self-esteem and that there are skills that can begin to help people to respond in that way.”
SIDEBAR: Will 7,000 More Cops Solve The Problem?
In an effort to reduce the crime rate, Mayor Dinkins has proposed a plan that would increase the number of New York City policemen by 7,000. Will more cops help reducethe violence? Wayne Winborne at the Center for Law and Social Justice in Brooklyn, is not sure that more cops will mean less crime because adding cops doesn’t deal with the causes of crime. Winborne also feels that New York City police officers should be required to live in the city. He thinks many officers who live outside of the five boroughs have stereotyped perceptions about certain neighborhoods which make it harder for the officers to get along with the people they are supposed to protect. Evelyn Ryan, 16, of West Side HS thinks cops can be part of the problem:”I feel that cops should respect teenagers and then they’d be respected and not be racial, ’cause they’re making teenagers turn against them and other teenagers.”
