As a foster child and then as an adopted child, I feel like I never had enough information about my past. It hurt me not knowing what led to my being placed in foster care. I think the system should make sure that information is available to kids if they want to receive it. Without it, some kids will feel just as lost as I have felt.
I wanted to know what information adopted kids and kids in care should have, so I interviewed Sheba Rana, a child protective worker. She goes out to kids’ homes to determine whether things are going the way they should or if kids need to be placed into foster homes. I also spoke to Cari Pea, a lawyer at Lawyers for Children in New York, who represents children in foster care and writes FCYU’s legal column, to find out about our right to information.
Caseworkers Should Speak the Truth
Sheba agreed with me that from the very beginning, kids should have information about what is happening to them and their families. She said that when she goes to a home, she tries “to give the children as much information as possible, depending on their age and maturity level.”
She added that when kids are being removed from their homes, there’s often so much chaos, it’s hard for them to take in what she tells them. That’s why she sometimes gives them her phone number, in case they have questions later on. “I have some kids call me. They’ll say, ‘Can you just explain that again?'” she said.
Sheba said she has never lied to a child. She said that lying to a child could leave that child “devastated.” So instead, when children ask her, “How long will I be here?” her response is, “I don’t know myself, so I can’t give that information to you.” She doesn’t want to lead them to thinking one thing when she doesn’t really know what’s going to happen to them.
Sheba also said she doesn’t know any other workers who have lied to children. That response made me a little curious because when I was taken away, they did lie to me and made me believe that I would be going home to my parents that very night.
I believe many children now are being lied to when they are put into a new foster home. I say this because I have seen it happen about three or four times when new kids were placed in my home. The caseworker told them they’d be going home soon, when they weren’t going home. Later on, the caseworkers would get all upset because the children didn’t want to believe or listen to what they had to say. But I think they’d already ruined those kids’ trust in them, and made them more likely to close out people who want to help. I believe more workers should behave like Sheba when kids are first put into foster homes and be as up front as they can be.
Our Files Don’t Belong to Us
Unfortunately, even after we settle into a new home and that initial shock of separation is over, some of us still don’t know why we’re living a whole new life. If we go into care as teenagers, we usually understand, but if we go into care as little kids, often we don’t, and too often the adults in the system think it’s better to keep that information from us in order to protect us, when really it hurts us more not to know. I interviewed Cari to find out what rights we have to know about our past as we get old enough to ask.
Some of what I found out was upsetting. For instance, I’ve always wanted to read my files so that I could know as much as the agency does about what happened to me, but Cari told me that the law does not give me the right to read those files.
She said that all foster children’s records and files belong to the agency, and the court usually only orders your files open for specific reasons, like if you want to sue your agency for mishandling your case. She said that’s because, “although your records concern you, they also concern your family, and the agency has to balance your family’s right to privacy with your right to know.”
Foster Youth Still Have The Right to Info
While I can see that parents have rights too, sometimes I think the agencies just use that as an excuse not to let us see all the things they’ve written down about us. I think we should have the right to see our files.
Cari said that even though we don’t have the right to our files, all kids should have some basic information about their case-even if they don’t have all the details-and that most of the kids she represents do know why they’re in care. She said that if you don’t, “You should ask your caseworker directly. Then the caseworker can look into the files to help you to understand what happened to you years ago,” she said.
Cari said that “it’s usually left up to the counselor or caseworker to decide the level of information that’s appropriate to give you.” She said social workers often believe that learning about our past that way can help us deal better than just reading the cold facts of our case in our file.
I agree with that to a certain point, but I also think it depends on the type of relationship that kids have been able to build with their caseworkers. I never built a good relationship with any of my caseworkers, which made it harder for me to have that kind of conversation with them. I believe caseworkers need to be better trained in helping us have those conversations about our pasts.
Adoption Makes It Tougher
At least, though, when you’re in foster care, you have a caseworker you can ask. Once kids are adopted, getting information gets much tougher. After most adoptions, except in special kinds of adoptions called open adoptions, a lot of information about your past basically gets cut off.
Once you turn 18, if you want information about your biological family and your family has indicated through the adoption registry that they want to be in contact with you, then your agency will hook you up and you may be able to be in touch. There’s also the sibling registry. If you’ve been separated from your siblings, you can register, and if your biological siblings register too, then they’ll put you in contact.
But lots of people don’t know about these registries, or your biological family may not want to be in contact with you.
Understanding Our Own Lives
When that’s the case, you can still get some basic information from the state-that is if your records have that information in them-like your parents’ religion, general appearance, ethnicity, occupation and some facts surrounding your adoption, but that’s about all.
If you want more information than that, your best bet may be to see if your adoptive family has any information that they’re willing to share with you, or to try to find your biological family yourself.
Cari said that adopted children are often challenging the privacy laws and trying to get access to their records. But, she said, there are still old laws in place that keep those records private. I agree with those adopted kids who are challenging the laws. I agree that our right to know is not being taken seriously enough. I feel that adopted kids should be entitled to a lot of the information if not all of the information that the agency has. After all, maybe parents have a right to privacy, but we also have the right to understand our own lives.
The Right to Know
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.