What’s it like to be on your own after foster care? “Like that commercial where the lady gets into the cockpit and they just give her the plane to fly,” said Leonard, 24, a former New York City foster teen. And it’s true. Foster care fails when it comes to preparing teens for a future of success.
This summer at Youth Advocacy Center, we interviewed young people in care, former foster youth, parents, agency administrators, lawyers and judges. They all said the same thing-foster care does not prepare kids to succeed after care.
Independent living (IL) workshops, the main work that agencies do with teens, are supposed to prepare kids for their futures. Recently the government set aside a lot more money for teens in IL classes. But if you’ve attended a typical IL workshop, you know that only a small percentage of eligible kids show up and those that do usually don’t find the class helpful.
IL Workshops Are a Mess
“If the workshop was supposed to start at 2:30, people wander in at 2:45, 3, even 3:30,” one teen said. “Staff walk in to pull kids out for meetings. The IL coordinator might start off by playing some icebreaker games. With soda and snacks, the atmosphere is like a party. There are kids from ages 14 to 21 in the class, all with different issues.”
“At the workshop, it’s not uncommon to hear the same information one year after another,” another teen reported. “Many of the workshops are about sexually transmitted diseases, which gets a lot of the 14- and 15-year-olds giggling. When they tell you how to balance a checkbook, it’s hard to pay attention because you don’t even have a bank account.”
“You’re not tested on anything you’re taught,” another teen added, “and you’re not asked to produce anything. You get a stipend if you go, or, at many agencies, even if you don’t go. No one seems to take any of it very seriously.”
And even when the kids do attend these classes, the system has disgracefully low expectations for young people. One teen told us that when his IL class has guest speakers, it’s usually someone to talk about what it’s like in jail. These kinds of low expectations for foster teens have an impact on how programs are run and what is defined as a “success story” in foster care.
IL workers tell me, “Olivia is doing so well! She’s renting a room and has a job at Bradlees!” But young people we know have greater ambitions: They want to be designers or writers or nurses or lawyers. They have the potential to make major contributions to society-not just to scrape by.
Foster Youth Need Concrete Plans
At the Youth Advocacy Center (YAC), we think the place to start planning for teens’ futures is with their goals. We take teens’ goals seriously (even if we don’t think someone’s chances of becoming a brain surgeon or top rapper are great). YAC uses “cases,” real stories of young people in care working to reach their goals, to teach teens to start taking control of their futures.
We also give them real-life experience. Part of YAC’s program is focused on introducing teens to successful professionals in fields of their interest. For example, last semester Melissa met with a defense lawyer, Janel with a pediatric nurse, Sashine with a graphic designer and Shermeane with a pastry chef. They learned more about the education and training they needed.
What You Can Do
Teens can help themselves by finding outside programs-whether it’s Youth Advocacy Center, their high school, a college, a vocational program, internship or even national service-and by talking to people about what they’re interested in doing with their futures. But IL programs need to take responsibility, too, by developing better methods which help teens reach their goals.
Currently YAC is writing a report to educate child welfare policy makers and practitioners about how important it is for foster care teens to be able to plan for their futures. We are also producing a video featuring young people in care taking control of their lives. Former foster care youth and older youth in care meet once every six weeks to provide guidance and advice to YAC as we work on these projects. If you’re interested in working on any of these projects, call Youth Advocacy Center at 212-675-6181.
Betsy Krebs is the executive director of Youth Advocacy Center and an Individual Project Fellow of the Open Society Institute.
Coming Up:
Self-Advocacy and Goal Planning Seminar
Only for New York City teens 17 and up who are serious about becoming successful. Learn to advocate for yourself and take control of your life with other teens in care. The required final project is going on an informational interview with a professional in the field that you’re interested in. Classes meet one afternoon a week. Next session starts early November. Call 212-675-6181 for more information.
The Problem With Independent Living
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.