The Life and Death of the Crippled Enigma

My writing persona stole my soul

I’ve been angry for as long as I can remember. It started when I was 2, and I was given up for adoption. Foster parents took me in when I was 5 and then adopted me when I was 9. I had grown to love my foster father, and then he died, just as my adoption was going through. After his death, I couldn’t remember how to smile anymore.
My foster mother told me my biological mother gave me up because “you were sick and she couldn’t take care of you.” I never understood that. Being sick just didn’t seem like a good enough reason to give up your son.
Every time my foster mother said that-whenever we had “family meetings”-I grew so angry that I would take it out on my younger (adoptive) brother by beating him up, or on my mother by yelling and cursing at her. I would also get angry at anyone who brought up the subject of my birth parents. I got in a lot of fights and broke a lot of objects.
My social worker suggested I write about whatever I felt instead of taking out my frustrations on people. So I wrote “Otis’s Notebook” on the front of an empty notebook. The first thing I wrote about was the death of my adoptive father and also about being given up by my birth mother. Basically I wrote some form of “I’m angry” over and over. It made me feel like I had a voice.
But that got repetitive. Fairy tales and other kids’ books inspired me to create, and I started making up my own stories in the summer of 1999, just before I turned 9. The stories were based on my own life and also dreams and fantasies. I would write about whatever happened in school. If I was in the mood, I would make my character the hero of a battle to win the girl’s heart. The characters were me and my friends from school, and the damsel in distress was always Carla.
I fell in love with Carla when we were both 6. She was the only one who could keep me calm. She could grab my upraised fist and pull it down and make my anger go away. We were inseparable for a few years.
Writing Quiets the Anger
Writing my stories had a similar effect. I was so caught up in what I was writing about that all my anger just faded away as though it never existed. There were no problems with anyone in the family: no fights, no screaming, no cursing-just peace and quiet.
I actually thought that the angry Otis who cursed and yelled was gone. The stories that I wrote only depicted happiness. I wanted the fictions of my stories to mix into the reality of who I was because it was an escape from being angry all the time.
In junior high, real life pissed me off again. My friends from 6th grade turned on me in 7th grade. I never understood why, but that’s when I learned that the people you call “friends” can stab you in the back.
In 7th grade English class, we read classic poems like Edgar Allen Poe’s “The Raven.” I thought, “Let me give writing my own poem a shot. It’s like telling a story.” As with my first stories, my poems weren’t angry. My first poem was inspired by what I felt the first time I saw Carla. I wrote about her sensitivity, her captivating smile, her riveting beauty, and the mesmerizing soul that you would only sense if you held her hand.
Carla moved away when I was 13. We continued to talk on the phone, but it was never the same and I’ve never felt that way about any girl since.
I Create a Monster
At the same time I lost her, I became a teenager, and my world changed. I couldn’t understand what I was doing, why I was cursing at my mother, why I was writing such dark poetry. Looking back, I think it was because I didn’t feel that there was any hope for me in terms of love.
The tone of my writing and my attitudes reverted back to the old, angry Otis. Though I had loved Carla, I doubted the love that other kids said they felt for each other. In junior high, when Valentine’s Day came around, I would sit at the back of the classroom and write poems like this one: “Roses are Red, 50 Cent can’t rap, Girls smell like perfume, YOU SMELL LIKE CRAP.” To amuse myself, I sent those poems out as “gifts” to my friends and sometimes to people who picked on me.
So I’d already started judging my classmates in my writing by the time I started high school. And once I entered 10th grade, I realized I was on my own. I didn’t want anything to do with all the fights and troublemaking I saw. Some of my classmates were already having sex at 15 and talking about wedding plans, for Christ’s sake! Others were talking about getting high and being in gangs. I didn’t want to be like them, so I retreated into writing about what I saw.
I created a writing persona, the Crippled Enigma, to describe the doom that would befall the gang members and other evildoers. The name was inspired in part by the professional wrestler Jeff Hardy, known as the Charismatic Enigma. And I walked with a limp, so the Crippled Enigma was born. I used the name as a URL for one of my MySpace pages and for a website called Gspoetry. The Crippled Enigma was a part of me that no one ever got to see before-dark, cynical, theatrical, like Heath Ledger’s Joker from Batman.
Otis’s Evil Twin
CE was like a twin brother who released all of his rage on anyone in sight, without me, Otis, to restrain him. The poems I wrote as CE channeled my anger at being bullied, losing Carla, not being listened to by my mother, and anything else that upset me.
The poems were an outlet that allowed me to express the feelings without revealing anything too personal. Whenever I needed to blow off a little steam, the Crippled Enigma could take on the negative aspects of my life, protecting the weak and innocent version of me. He was all-powerful, without doubt or pity.
And it turned out people liked the Crippled Enigma. The audience on Gspoetry made me feel like I had a family of poets who always wanted to listen to everything I had to say. I wasn’t writing to impress anyone, but I still wanted to be accepted and I needed an audience-because what is writing when you don’t get any feedback?
Crippled Enigma in the Flesh
There was a similar tension in my real life-I wanted to fit in at school without acting like everyone else. I found myself acting like the Crippled Enigma, the writer that people online complimented and adored. In other words, the writing persona became a mask.
The mask was also protection from conflict. If I was jeered by bullies, the Crippled Enigma would taunt them: “Tell me child, do you love yourself and the mind you possess? Or were you neglected and beaten so you decide to take it out on me?” The Crippled Enigma knew how to make them feel bad for picking on me.
The Crippled Enigma also could keep girls and their nosy questions away. One time I was sitting on the bleachers in the gym. A few girls were sitting one level above me. I was listening to my headphones and I didn’t notice that one of the girls had come down to sit next to me.
Said the girl: “What are you writing?” Said I, sarcastically: “It’s called a poemâyou know where sometimes you rhyme-.” Said the girl: “You mad mean, I’m not retarded, I know what a poem is.” Said I, sarcastically: “I’m sure you do. With that kind of knowledge, you can shoot for the starsâ and then wake up.”
She walked away crying, which led me to think, “Oh crap.” I didn’t want to make anyone feel bad; I just wanted to be left alone. The next day, I saw the girl, but she ran away. Then I handed her a poem entitled “Apology (What I Meant To Say Wasâ),” which I wrote after I saw her in tears. I wrote the poem because the words “I’m sorry” just didn’t come out the way I wanted them to. I was ashamed at the grief that I had caused.
I started thinking about making that girl cry and how intimidating I was to some people and it disturbed me. “He’s one scary kid”; “He’s gonna f–k you up”; “Leave him alone”: These were phrases I kept hearing as I walked the halls and I thought, “This isn’t me. Otis doesn’t hurt anyone’s feelings, Otis doesn’t scare people.”
The Crippled Enigma and his anger had taken over too much of my life. Some mornings, I’d wake up pissed off and look in the mirror and it wouldn’t be Otis staring back. I’d be the Crippled Enigma-the storm that killed the calm as opposed to the calm that killed the storm.
The Funeral
One night not long ago I dreamed about the death of Crippled Enigma. In this dream, I stood at an open grave with an empty casket. Thunder roared and lighting rolled. Lying there was a body that looked like me, but was the Crippled Enigma. I had to hit him in the head with the shovel a few times because he kept waking up, but I stilled him with one final blow and stuffed him in the casket.
What was lying in that casket was in part the pain that had followed me since my birth. The angry, sarcastic, conniving side of me I used to hurt a person’s feelings was the role that the Crippled Enigma had been born to play.
In the dream, the casket went back down six feet under. It felt like shame was being buried. Anger out of control isn’t empowering; it’s the opposite. My anger is generally over things I couldn’t control: being given up for adoption, my dad’s death, having cerebral palsy, being bullied. It was worse in a way to have something inside me I couldn’t control. The consequences I’ve faced from letting out all my anger at family, friends, and other innocent people left me feeling ashamed and humiliated.
The dream was a wake-up call for me because it made me realize that I’ve been using anger as an excuse to upset my family, hurt the feelings of friends, and screw up in life. It made me want to change my ways and think before getting angry and doing something I’d regret for the rest of my life.
But obviously, the anger that has haunted me since childhood isn’t gone. Where will it go without the Crippled Enigma to hold it? This is neither the end of my poetry or my appearances on Gspoetry. I’d like to be able to keep my anger on the page and out of my life as much as I can.
One way to keep it out of real life is by communicating face-to-face, without personas. I’d like to get better at ignoring negative influences and at acknowledging people who show me affection.
As far as the page, writing can help me maintain the balance between my anger and my happiness if I don’t let the anger take over. A lot of what I see around me is negative, but I can write about it with a lighter and more comfortable voice and with a sense of love and truth to light the darkness.
Some of my writing aims to inspire my readers to be themselves instead of everyone else (“Your voice is your weapon, use it with caution / Be careful with the method in every precaution”), or prevent someone from causing harm to himself or others, (“don’t fight the enemy, she/he isn’t worth your time / Think about the result before you cross that line”). That’s Otis from the heart and from his whole soul.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.