For a while this spring, we were constantly hearing in the media about a young African immigrant named Amadou Diallo who was shot 41 times by four White cops on a dark Bronx street. He was not armed with any weapon, and of those 41 shots, 19 hit him, causing his untimely death.
These were the facts that the media reported on a day to day basis. However within that tragic story a new story arose-the story of a Black community filled with legitimate anger, and a city which galvanized support.
After the shooting, demonstrations outside City Hall began, attended by African-Americans, Asians, Hispanics, Whites and Native Americans. Plus, organizations that have not always seen eye to eye-such as the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, the Nation of Islam and the Anti-Defamation League-joined together in the protests.
The Mayor’s Got an Attitude
In the past, when there were similar incidents, most often you would see mainly Black people protesting police brutality and racial insensitivity by the mayor, who in turn would accuse Black politicians like Al Sharpton and Charles Rangel of playing the race card, and simply seeking attention from the press. He’d display a nonchalant attitude when confronted with anger from the Black community.
This time he couldn’t do that, though. Not only did people like David Dinkins and Jesse Jackson come out. So did people like Susan Sarandon, Ed Koch and Governor Pataki.
President Clinton responded in his weekly radio address, offering ideas for racial sensitivity training and calling for more funding for the hiring of minority police officers.
Reforming Under Fire
The governor, who’s almost always silent on matters of race, said, “You don’t succeed as a state with a huge divide, where some people think things are getting better and others worse.” And he added, with an obvious jab at the mayor: “Part of governing is being tolerant and listening to criticism and responding appropriately to criticism.”
The mayor was forced to open up a little bit under the pressure. He discussed the need for new police tactics, called for more respectful attitudes from officers, and invited Manhattan Borough President C. Virginia Fields, a Black woman, over for a discussion of the controversy.
I don’t think that would have happened if it had just been Blacks and Hispanics protesting. First Lady Hillary Clinton said in 1996 that it “takes a village to raise a child.” I would say, “It takes a village to get something done-especially concerning race.”
Even before Amadou Diallo was shot, in reaction to such situations as Abner Louima and Rodney King, I had formed an opinion of what it is to be a young Black male in an American metropolis.
I live in Williamsbridge, in the northern section of the Bronx. Not much police action takes place, but that does not mean we don’t have crime, because trust me, we do. Car thefts, robberies, all of those kinds of things.
Before Diallo, people had their opinions of police already set. This situation just fanned the flames. After February 5, people displayed their hostility toward the NYPD more frequently and more openly.
‘Criminals With Badges’
A few things I’ve heard have been: “They’re a bunch of Klansmen with blue suits,” and “They’re just criminals with badges.” Some of these feelings I have quoted are the nice versions. To be honest, in many ways, their feelings are mine as well.
Now, I know that not all cops are racist. It would be foolish and unfair for me to say that. They have hard jobs and they risk their lives for people they don’t know.
If a police officer approaches a suspect and the person is moving about in a manner which may be threatening to that cop’s life, he may think, “My son is expecting me home tomorrow morning.” So a jittery feeling may come over him, and he may have to make a decision quickly. Is it going to be my life or his?
But in this instance, those officers should have known way before 41 shots that Amadou was not a threat, but a corpse. Too often, it seems like cops feel there is no check on their authority, and they can do as they please.
Imagining the Worst
Before Amadou Diallo was shot, I know most people in the minority community and myself would think that police could shoot anyone at will and only be put on desk duty or get a fine or have nothing happen to them at all. I know every now and then I would think, “If it were night and I was in a predominantly White section of the city, what would happen if some cops saw me?”
Or I would think things like, “Black life is cheap, people don’t care.” I had this vision of God forbid should something happen to me, the people in my neighborhood saying, “Oh! Jesus lord have mercy, he was such a gifted young man,” or, “He ain’t never done nothing wrong to nobody. He was gonna go to Howard University and all that stuff.”
Then would come Mayor Giuliani on television with the usual smug attitude saying, “I’m not going to judge the police ’til I see the facts,” when the facts would already be there.
Black, and Different
These kinds of thoughts make a person feel powerless. And these thoughts have been with me for a long time.
When I was 10, for instance, my parents and I went to visit my grandmother, who lived in a Black neighborhood. My father stopped for a moment on the deserted street leading to our destination, when a police vehicle pulled up behind us with its sirens on.
The officer got out of the car and approached my father asking him for his license and registration. My father asked why, and he responded, “You stopped in the middle of traffic.” My father looked at him as if he were stupid and said, “What traffic? The street is deserted.”
I guess the cop did not like my father’s response, so he asked him to step out of the car. But my father surprised him. “I don’t want any trouble, I am an MP [military police] in the service,” he said. He produced his identification, and the cop looked shocked. Suddenly he had nothing to say. He gave my father back his license, then walked away.
Images of Rodney King
As a 10 year old, probably I was immature, but the truth is, I was scared. I had always been a news hound, and images of Yusef Hawkins being beat up in Bensonhurst, and Rodney King being beaten in L.A. flashed through my mind.
What struck me at that moment was that I was Black, and I was different.
After Diallo’s death, when public opinion turned against the police, I felt vindicated. I had thought people outside the ‘hood could not see what I had been seeing and feeling all along. But this time it seemed like they did see.
When I passed cops in the street, I felt a certain sense of power. Now everyone was watching them, and it was their turn to feel ill at ease.
I felt somewhat optimistic that this time something positive would emerge.
An Important Issue Fades
It was educational for me to see so many different types of people concerned with the death of an African immigrant. It showed that he didn’t have to be White, or any other race, just a human. I felt pleased that my initial assumption that no one cared was not completely true.
But now, with other stories at the top of the news, I feel that slowly a very important issue is fading away. And the mayor is going back to his old ways, refusing to cooperate with investigators. As coverage comes to a close, so do the eyes of those who were keeping a watch on the conduct of the police department and on the mayor.
Unless everyone continues to cry out loudly, “No! This can’t continue, it’s got to stop!” the mayor will resume his stone cold manner. Then will any of this have made a difference? The answer will be no; if we let this issue be forgotten, the result will be business as usual.
The Diallo Shooting
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.