The Day the City Called

I can still remember the phone call at 2 a.m. The voice on the other line said, “Hello, may I speak to Caroline Marrero?”
I said, “Speaking.”
The voice said, “Hi, I’m a worker from ACS. Allegations were made that you verbally abuse your son and mentally degrade him.”
As I’m listening, in the background I hear another phone ring, and the worker tells me to hold on a minute, but doesn’t put me on hold. I know he’s speaking to my sister because I hear him say, “I understand, Ms. R. I can’t talk to you now, I have Mrs. Marrero on the phone. I’ll talk to you later.”
Then he comes back on the phone and I say, “It was my sister, wasn’t it? I heard you talking to her.” He tells me he isn’t at liberty to tell me, but I know the truth. I heard it with my own ears.
Betrayed by My Sister
Then he tells me, “I want to set up an appointment for someone to go to your house. Are you going to be there tomorrow?” I said I would and he said fine, someone would be there between 5 and 8 p.m.
As I hung up the phone, so many angry thoughts passed through my head. I felt disgust toward my sister for being so vindictive, and disappointed with my son for being a part of her game. My sister and I have had bad blood in the past, but this was taking it too far, messing with my family, my happiness, my whole reason for living. There’s nothing that occurred between us that should have made her act so evil. Mainly I felt scared that what my sister did could disrupt the unity of my family.
The conflict with my son started one day when my son, my husband and I were out shopping for clothes for the beginning of school and my son began to be very loud, disrespecting my husband and attracting attention to us in the street.
A lot of the time my son and I get along well, we go out together, we laugh a lot together, and I enjoy spending time with him. But my son and I also have some problems because my husband is not his father and he doesn’t want to accept him into our lives. He misses his own father, who does not do a good job of staying in touch with him, and that, I believe, increases my son’s anger.
Sometimes my son gets into one of those disrespectful moods and starts making statements to my husband like, “You’re not my father, I don’t have to listen to you. You don’t own me, only my mother can tell me what to do.”
At 2 A.M. I Got the Call
It happened to be one of those days and my son’s behavior got out of hand. He started saying to my husband, “You’re always getting into my business. Who do you think you are, my father? Well, you’re not.” That got me very upset. My husband was furious and everybody was looking at us making a spectacle of ourselves in the street. So I told my son, “Don’t come home until you calm down.” Later I found out that he thought I said, “Don’t come home,” and he ran to my sister’s house in Brooklyn and gave his version and that led her to call ACS.
When my son didn’t come home that night and didn’t bother to call me, I started thinking the worst: Is he OK? Did something happen to him? But then it dawned on me that he was probably at my sister’s house, because he’s gone there before when we’ve had a fight. So I went to sleep, and at 2 a.m. I received the call.
The next day, a perfect stranger came into my house, interrogating me and putting into question my ability to be a good parent. Questioning everyone in my household, like my husband, my stepson, my son, my neighbors. Looking through my apartment, checking my cabinets.
But even though I felt violated by the interrogation, I appreciated that the caseworker was very polite. He seemed like one of those workers who is interested in helping, and that made me feel better.
He asked me many questions, like was my son on medication, were his shots up to date, did he attend school regularly, did he have a therapist, how was his behavior, did he have problems with his peers or were his problems mostly at home, how do I discipline him, did I hit or punish him, how did I feel about sending my son to live with his father if the conflicts were too bad.
After he had talked to all of us, the worker wanted to check out my apartment. Once he saw one of my cabinets and that it was full, he said, “That’s all I need to see.”
A Thorough Inspection
But I told him, “No, I want you to see all of my cabinets.” I had my pride, and if he was there to grade me, I wanted to show him I was more than qualified to pass inspection. I may not be a perfect mother, because who is, but I feel I’m a damned good one. I love my son, I love my family and I love my responsibility and I wanted him to see that. If first impressions count, I thought he should be able to tell what kind of parent I am.
Once I showed him my kitchen he said, “You have a lot of food. You go shopping a lot.”
I told him, “Every time there’s a special, I’m there.”
Then I walked him step by step through my son’s closet, his dresser drawers. I showed him the window guards, the smoke detector. I told him where I take Jonathan to the doctor, that his vaccinations were all up to date, that he was a healthy child.
Fortunately, the caseworker decided the case was unfounded and that there was no reason to remove my son. In fact, the worker told my son he should be proud to have a mother who cares about him and loves him so much, and that other children are not as fortunate. It’s funny that when a perfect stranger said that to my son, somehow it made it easier for him to accept that he’s with me and not his father, and it’s been a little easier with him since then.
But though everything turned out OK, the whole event will be everlasting in my memory, because how do you forget the day when it seemed possible that the city was about to become your worst enemy and remove your child from you? The memories of it still terrorize me. I think about how the city had the power to judge me and take my child from me, and I only had my own words and the proof of my apartment to defend myself with.
Luckily, I was able to make a good first impression by being as honest as possible and remaining in control, and the investigator who came to my house did his job well too. But not all parents know how to deal with child care officials, and not all caseworkers are as polite and reassuring as mine. I believe this becomes a big problem with those cases that are not clear cut, where parents are harming their children, but where it might do more harm than good to take the children out of their home. We’ve all heard of cases where caseworkers made decisions quickly and removed children when they could have given families help instead. When this happens, it may be weeks, months or even years that children are separated from their parents unnecessarily, and that hurts children too.
Despite this, I still believe that the foster care system should exist and that every complaint it receives should be investigated, because there are children in danger. But I also think parents should have more rights and more protection than they do. I think parents should have the right to know who accused them, because too many people use the foster care system as a way to get revenge. I also believe that the foster care system should investigate if there’s something ugly motivating the accuser to call.
Parents Need Protection
I also think parents should have better legal representation, with someone there to fight for them from the very beginning, especially for parents who aren’t good at fighting for themselves. Right now, lawyers who represent parents are overworked and underpaid and sometimes only have a few minutes to meet with their clients. Sometimes it can be days or even weeks before a parent gets to meet with a lawyer at all. Parents shouldn’t be treated like criminals until they’re proven guilty, and they should have at least as much protection as defendants in the criminal courts.
People might argue that if caseworkers had to jump through hoops to protect parents’ rights, their children would be at greater risk of not getting removed when they needed to be, but I don’t think parents’ rights and children’s rights have to be in conflict. After all, if the only way for the system to make sure children are safe is by violating the parents’ rights, how likely is it that the system will protect the children’s rights too? And what does it say about how well the system is working in general if parents receive inadequate protection?
I believe these changes may only happen if parents themselves begin to speak up. That’s why I’m now a parent leader at the Child Welfare Organizing Project, an organization of birth parents working to reform the foster care system. My main objective is to be able to help a fellow parent in need and to change the child welfare system to be more sensitive to the needs of parents and families.
For information about the Child Welfare Organizing Project, call Mike Arsham at 212-348-3000.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.