The Christmas Santa Didn’t Come

When I was a little boy growing up in Jamaica, I believed in all sorts of magical things. My family told me that ghosts walk at night and that angels fall from the sky after being rejected from heaven and then land in the water, transforming into mermaids. They said that mermaids sit on stones by the water and comb their hair.
My grandfather told me that one day as he was coming home from fishing, he saw a mermaid’s comb on a stone and stole it. He told me that made the mermaid very mad and she cast a spell on my mother. The spell made my mother very sick, so she went to a psychic healer for help.
That man told my mother that she should cut a pumpkin in half at midnight and stick the knife in the middle of the pumpkin. Then she should call the mermaid and ask for forgiveness, and give back the comb. That’s what she did. The next day, my mother was well, so my grandpa said.
A Christmas Without Magic?
No wonder I strongly believed that Santa Claus really does travel around the world distributing gifts on Christmas. I thought that whatever you ask for, you get! When Christmas came around I felt overwhelmed with happiness. But one Christmas when I was little, I did not receive the bike I requested and I was crushed.
That Christmas morning my mother and I were walking to the street fair a few blocks from my house, next to Poppa D’s store. I was very upset about the bike, huffing and puffing, pushing my lips out and acting as if I were about to cry.
I asked my mother why I did not get what I wanted. With a secretive look on her face and a mild voice, my mother bent her head forward and told me, “Santa was killed in a plane crash going to another country.”
No One to Bring My Dreams
I was shocked and disappointed. I thought, “Who will give the bike to me now that Santa is dead?” I felt very much like the world was over.
I asked my mother, “Mummy, is Santa the only one who gives out presents on Christmas?” With the same discreet look she said, “That’s right.”
I was in a rage that Santa had died and no one could give me my bike. My breath became even heavier, my lips extended as far as they could go and I started dragging myself slowly along behind my mother. It felt so bad to know that I couldn’t count on anyone to bring me my dreams.
For a long time I continued to believe that Santa was real, but that he had died. (Now that I think of it, why’d I believe he died in a plane crash when Santa’s got a sleigh?)
A Lie to Protect Me
When I was 14, I found out that Santa was just a myth. Then I realized that my mom didn’t have the money to buy me a bike that year. My mother owned her own business and things sometimes got tight. That Christmas, sales didn’t pick up.
I think my mother lied to me because she wanted life to seem simple, uncomplicated. She wanted me to believe that if I was good, Santa would not let me down. The idea that goodness leads to rewards makes the world seem very fair. She didn’t want me to learn too early that that’s not the way the world works.
Looking Life in the Eye
I wish she hadn’t lied. Kids need to grow up. She couldn’t protect me forever. When my mother and I came to New York, she was working and going to school at the same time. Those years, I saw my mother bending over backward for minimum wage.
One day I told her, “I am not going to school no more because I don’t have name brand clothes and they are making fun of me.” I was older then, so my mother sat me down with a poker face and a somber voice and told me, “The times we’re in are very difficult and money is hard to come by.”
It felt sad but good to know that I was growing up, and my mother could be straight with me about life.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.