The Black Woman’s Guide to Groveling

The Blackman’s Guide to Understanding the Blackwoman, Civilized Publications, $10.00.
Shahrazad Ali’s book, “The Blackman’s Guide to Understanding the Blackwoman” is supposedly about Black women and how they act. Ali says she wrote it to “create a revolution of positive change in Black relationships.” I don’t see how anything positive can come out of a book that makes it seem like all of the Black race’s problems were caused by women.
Ali says that Black men shouldn’t trust Black women because they are jealous, money grubbing, vindictive, dirty and hostile. It seems like she has a personal vendetta.
Black women can’t please Ali, no matter what they do. According to her, professional women are too ambitious and don’t devote enough time to their families; women who stay home are lazy and don’t take proper care of their homes. Women who care about their appearance are selfish and vain; women who don’t are dirty and slovenly.
For example, Ali puts down Black women who get an education and have a successful career. She says they get too aggressive in the workplace and shouldn’t work so hard or put in overtime because it keeps them from taking proper care of their men. Well I think a woman needs to fulfill herself instead of just being at the beck and call of her man.
Black women, along with women of all races, have fought hard for our place in the work force. Who is Ali to downgrade us for doing a good job? If a Black man can’t handle it, then that’s his problem.
Even the women who stay home don’t know how to keep a clean house, according to Ali. She says that a Black woman’s house has crud in the sink and spoiled food in the fridge. Maybe her house looks that way, but not mine.
Ali also criticizes us for being slaves to fashion. She says a Black woman will “run up charge accounts, borrow from the rent and make any sacrifice she deems necessary to obtain a certain outfit.” I think Ali should take a closer look at Black men. I’ve noticed plenty of them wearing expensive suits and designer clothes like Polo, Gucci, and Fendi. They are more conscious of their look than Black women, in my opinion.
The most outrageous thing Ali says is that it’s okay for a Black man to cheat on his woman because it’s not in his nature to be tied down. If his woman gets upset over this, then she has the problem. Gimme a break! If you put your trust in a man and then find out he’s having an affair, I think you have every right in the world to blow your top.
And Ali thinks men have every right to be upset when the shoe is on the other foot. She even tells Black men not to let their women go out with the girls because they’re not to be trusted. Let them out of the house and they’ll find another man, she says. Her book is full of this kind of double standard.
Ali says that this book “is not an intentional negative portrayal of the Blackwoman.” If you ask me, it’s a completely negative portrayal and an unfair one. She not only put Black women down in the mud, she buried us six feet under.
The only people who might be interested in reading this book are men who think like Ali. Chauvinistic men who think women should carry out their every whim and grovel at their feet will love it. As for me, I think Ali is full of it. The paper this book is printed on could have been put to a lot better use than spreading this nonsense.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.