Teens to Parents: Take Our Money, Please!

One afternoon this summer, Alex Lamont and Alissa Langsam, both 17, were looking at records at a store in the Manhattan Mall.
I approached them and asked if they thought parents should have control over teens’ bank accounts. I expected them to say no.
But Alex said that if her parents didn’t control her money, she’d probably just waste it.
If she hadn’t wasted her “money on crap…I probably could have a little more money in my bank now,” she said.
Alex can’t take money out of her bank account until she is 18, but she said she didn’t mind.
Alissa agreed.
“Yeah, they should control it,” she said. “[Otherwise] I might go overboard.”
Alissa has one bank account she uses now and one that she will have control over when she is 18. Alissa explained that whenever she goes into a store, she always has to buy something. She calls her purchases “impulse buys.”
Are Teens Responsible?
Most banks seem to agree with Alex and Alissa that teens should not have final say over their money. Lots of banks like Citibank and Jamaica Savings don’t allow teens under 18 to open up an account without their parents’ permission.
A branch manager at Fleet Bank, John Sholeis, explained that they have this policy because teens cannot be held legally responsible for how they use their money, since they can’t sign a contract.
He also said that if teens were given credit cards, they might run up charges and not really understand what they were doing.
I thought teens would object to this policy and feel insulted that we are being treated like babies. I thought they would think adults are treating us like a bunch of screw ups who are not mature enough to handle our own accounts.
But surprisingly, a little more than half the teens I talked to said that if their parents didn’t control their money, they would waste it on junk.
It Depends On the Teen
Like Alissa and Alex, many of the teens I talked to said it really depends on how mature a teen is.
Ashley Williams, 17, who was visiting New York from South Carolina, has a joint savings account with her mother. She believes this situation has helped teach her a lot about saving up her money.
“A lot of people are irresponsible when taking out money,” Ashley said. Whether a teen should have economic independence “depends on the person’s maturity level,” she added.
Ashley used the money she saved to pay for her trip to New York to interview at a modeling agency. The entire trip cost around a thousand dollars.
I was shocked that most of the teens I talked to didn’t trust themselves when it came to handling money.
Hands Off My Money!
I was relieved to find a handful of teens who strongly opposed custodial accounts. Annie, 17, of James Madison High School (who doesn’t have a bank account) and Ameena Bradbury, 16, both felt that it isn’t fair for parents to have control over their children’s money.
Ameena said, “I think it’s unfair because teens are responsible…if they have a job.”
Annie said she thought it was “none of their business.”
Another teen who was against parents having control of their teens’ bank accounts was Nick Law, 19.
He believes parents shouldn’t control their kids money flow because “kids have to learn responsibility.”
Nick believes that if they have their own accounts, they will learn that they “can’t freak out if things don’t go exactly as [they] plan.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.