Teen Pregnancy: An Election Issue?

In September, Republican presidential candidate John McCain announced that his vice-presidential running mate would be Sarah Palin, the governor of Alaska and a mother of five. Not long after that, Governor Palin and her husband confirmed that their unmarried 17-year-old daughter, Bristol, was pregnant and would marry her boyfriend.
Much media coverage followed. Some commentators criticized Governor Palin for supporting abstinence-only education in the past. Others argued Bristol’s situation shouldn’t be treated as a political issue. Many questioned Bristol’s decision to marry the baby’s father, who described himself on his MySpace page as a “redneck.” On Good Morning America, Senator McCain’s wife, Cindy, described the pregnancy as “wonderful.”
This story has brought a lot of attention to one teen’s pregnancy-but what does it mean to other teens not in the national spotlight? Here at NYC, we had a group discussion about some of the questions it raises. Below, some of our writers share their reactions.
Pregnant Teens Need Support
I think people have been making too big a deal about Bristol Palin’s pregnancy. The more teens who see that others are doing it, the more we’ll see teen pregnancy in our nation. Already, I think many of the teens who have kids don’t do so accidentally, but plan on it because the media make it seem like something that should be welcomed.
I’m not saying the media should say rude things about pregnant teens, but it seems that they promote teen pregnancy with stories about teens like Bristol Palin and Jamie Lynn Spears. Other teens who want attention see these headlines and figure out the easiest way to get it. If there were more TV programs like The Baby Borrowers-which shows teens how hard it is to take care of a baby in reality-there might be fewer teen pregnancies than there are now.
Also, many teens may be kicked out of their homes when their mothers find out that they’re pregnant. This leads to financial and emotional instability. Bristol Palin, Jamie Lynn Spears and the pregnant girl in the movie Juno each had what many teens lack: a family backing them up. In Bristol Palin’s case, she has the whole Republican party backing her up. Teens do make the mistake of not thinking through what might happen when they take chances, but I feel parents, aunts and uncles or even a cousin should be behind every pregnant teen.
-Courtney Smith
Parents Unprepared
Bristol Palin’s pregnancy sets a bad example for teens all over America. Although I support her choice of keeping the baby, I think that rushing to get married to make it “OK” was a stupid idea. I don’t think she really thought about all her options.
If I was in her position I would think it’s best to give the baby up for adoption. I don’t believe in abortion unless it is necessary and I don’t think getting married would better the situation, since both parents are teens unprepared to raise a child (especially when the boyfriend seems immature and calls himself a redneck!).
Although Bristol’s pregnancy was irresponsible and rash, I think it’s brought the issue of teen pregnancy to the public eye. I think it will open the eyes of people who buy into stereotypes about teen mothers and help them realize it can happen to anybody, regardless of race or background.
-Amanda Fernandez
I Feel Bad for Bristol
I just wonder how Bristol feels. This girl may have just made the biggest mistake of her life and here we are, wondering how it affects her mother’s campaign and what it says about her mother. Sometimes you have to look beyond the politics and think about the actual people. I feel bad for Bristol, having to live through this in the public eye. For all we know, maybe it was her first time. Maybe her boyfriend was pressuring her and she just gave in.
Whether or not McCain wins the election, I don’t think this baby will make other people compassionate toward teen mothers, or make people think about sex education. All I think this has done is caused a media circus like other scandals before it. People watch the news, read the newspaper, and say, “This is what America has become,” then move on with their lives, with their views unchanged.
-Marci Bayer
Not a Bad Mother
When I think about Bristol Palin’s pregnancy, I wonder how the Republican vice-presidential candidate’s child could get herself into this position. How could her mother let the situation slip through her fingers? But then I think of teenagers in general, and how sneaky and rebellious we can be. We do what we want, no matter what the consequences.
Just because Bristol got pregnant before marriage, it doesn’t make Sarah Palin a bad mother. She has been saying in her speeches that she’s just like us (the average American), and that she relates to us. So why can’t we let her relate to us with this as well? This situation has shown that, like many people, Sarah Palin doesn’t have everything together. This makes her more human.
-Marsha Dupiton
Palins Shouldn’t Say They’re Happy
If the daughter of a Democrat was the one to become pregnant, would the reaction of the Republicans be the same? From what I see, that’s a big “No!” The Republicans are always talking about the things Democrats do wrong, so if it was the other way around, they would have used the situation as a weapon to show that Democrats aren’t responsible enough to take care of one family, let alone the whole country.
The Palin family might be happy for real that their 17-year-old daughter is pregnant, or they may not be, but want to pretend they are. Either way, they shouldn’t be going around saying they’re happy that their daughter is pregnant, making it seem like it’s a one-day or one-year thing when it’s a lifelong issue. The candidates are running to represent the country and some people look up to them. We don’t want all girls thinking that teen pregnancy is OK, just because one famous family thinks so.
-Orubba Almansouri
A Sad Ordeal
Sitting at home watching on TV as Sarah Palin’s candidacy was announced, I saw her children walk in a single file across the stage with her. Bristol caught my eye. I instantly thought there was something strange about her-the way she carried her newborn baby brother on her stomach, along with a long baby blanket. Not long after that, I found out that Bristol Palin was pregnant-I knew there was something about her!
I immediately thought about how disappointed Sarah Palin must have been. I don’t support Bristol having the baby (though it’s not my choice to make), but with a mother who is a public figure and a Republican, it went without saying that Bristol would have to keep it.
But getting married to the baby’s father? Whoa. That’s a whole other issue. Bristol Palin will really have no life after the baby. And the baby’s father sounds like a dud. What kind of role models is this baby going to have? It’s truly a sad ordeal-for everyone.
-Tashiana Garrido

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.