Taking the Stand

I Know My Father Did Wrong. But Should I Make Him Pay?

Soon I have to go to court. Sit in front of my father’s face and tell everything that happened. With my mother’s eyes beaming on me like two hot rays of fire. I know what she will be thinking: “That girl is a liar, my husband is a great father.” She doesn’t like to hear the truth, especially because she didn’t help out, try to stop the abuse. I know that in her heart she knows the truth and just decided not to believe it.
My father has been accused of child abuse. That is right. He has been a bad dad for eight long horrible years. It is written all over his face. If you look into his eyes they say a thousand words and you will be able to tell. You will be able to tell that he used to put notes under my pillow about what he would do to me that night. That sometimes he lent me to other men so he could get his drugs for free.
Do I Want My Dad to Go to Jail?
Sometimes I wonder how he got away with it. Eight years is a long time. Sometimes I think it’s because no one in my family would stand up to him, including my mother. Instead we would make up some excuse for his actions, like he’s kidding, or he’s the man in the house and what he says goes.
Or maybe we were just afraid. He had this smile he would share with us all like he didn’t give a damn about anything because he was the most powerful creature on the face of this earth.
But soon the day will come when he has to face me, and I’m going to tell everyone what went on in our house. Sometimes I imagine how great it will feel to get that off my chest.
Then I get confused. I think, “Do I really want him to go to jail?” He is still my dad. I still have sympathy for him. I don’t really know why. I don’t understand why I feel so much for him.
Maybe it’s because he was often nice to me. He was the one who had the answers to all my questions, like, “Why is my mother so crazy? Why doesn’t she want to be a real mother?”
During the time my father started abusing me, my mother was a complete wreck. She would hear things at night that would send her into a rampage. She rarely cleaned herself or even got off the couch. The apartment smelled like defecating bodies. Soon my brothers stopped cleaning themselves as well.
Had All the Answers
I didn’t understand it. But my father would explain. My father would say that she was two nickels short of a dime or that she was just a little lost link. After hearing that I would look at my mother as a woman who simply could not cope with life. So my father seemed like the sane one of my parents, the one with the answers, the one who could open the window into her world to help me understand why my mother acted the way she did.
The Abuse Started
I felt so bad for my mother that I would help with anything I could in the house. I also became closer with my dad because my mother could not be there for him. That’s when the abuse started, though I didn’t think of it as abuse back then. I thought I was helping my parents out.
My father would ask me to do things for him that were my mother’s place to fill, like sleeping with him. I did things with him as a favor to both of my parents, because my mother didn’t want to be open with him in that way and I felt like no one should be as lonely as he was. I felt like my father loved me when he asked me to do those things, and because we were so close, I felt like he was all I had and that I was all he had. He counted on me to be with him through all of his struggles.
My dad always had this emptiness about him and he would share this with me. I felt I had an emptiness in me, too, and that made me feel closer to my father.
It took me a long time to understand that I felt so damn empty because I had to keep my affair with my father undercover, so no one could do anything about it, no one could help stop it. It took me a long time to understand that what we did together wasn’t right or safe for a child to do. And it is why today I have this strong passion of hatred toward him.
What I hate most, though, is that I still have sympathy for him.
When I was about 12 years old my mother began to come out of her little world. She started telling my brothers that they had to wash, that they had to do their homework, and she just became in charge of things that she wasn’t before. She also began noticing what was happening between my dad and me. She noticed how often he took me places with him and bought me things and even kissed me more than he kissed her.
My mother started to pull me aside and tell me that I was stealing her husband. My mother would ask me if I liked being my dad’s toy because every time he needed me I would run to him. She said I was taking her place as the wife in the house. She said that she believed he and I were having sex.
I Felt Terrible and Guilty
When my mother said those things I felt terrible and guilty. I had wanted nothing more than to help my family out and feel loved. The last thing I had wanted was to hurt my mother or cause her pain. Now I felt that I was only pulling my father and mother away from each other. I felt like I was ruining the family. My mother made me feel like I was her new enemy, and this hurt me more than anything.
When I told my dad what my mother said, he’d say that she was just jealous that he treated me with more love and respect. But I began to feel nasty about doing things with him. I began to see my father as a slave owner who would send me away to be with other guys just so he could get his drugs. I only got pain. I had stopped trusting people, and I had begun to let men take advantage of my body just to feel love and even some hurt. I began to feel like my mother was right. I was just Dad’s little plaything.
So I tried to stop my dad from using me. That’s when things got much more difficult between us. I learned that if I didn’t agree to sex with him he would just force himself on me.
He Became the Monster Who Hurt Me
This changed the way I felt about him. I no longer looked at my dad as someone who was like me, but as the monster who hurt me.
I began to see how he had used me. I also began to see how he had manipulated me to make me feel that his need for me was my mother’s fault, not his. My anger grew and eventually I ended up in foster care because of it, because I began to hint about what was going on in my family.
And now, the day of his trial is coming. My father took my innocence to satisfy his needs and now I want to take away his life (freedom?).
He’s Still Family
Day after day, as the trial grows closer, I feel so sick of all of the things he did to me and I want my revenge. So as the days draw near and I stand before the mirror in my group home, imagining what I might say the day of the trial, I am crying inside, dying to tell it all.
But then I start to worry. I remember that I will have no family left after I do that, except for my sister, who I live with still, who is the apple of my eye. How will I wake up every morning to what I have done? Every holiday I will have to spend alone with my sister in our cold room knowing I have abolished the only family we knew. How can I do this and still wake up in the morning and look at myself in the mirror?
So as the court date draws nearer, my mind changes again and again: Should I tell? Should I not tell? If my father is gone and in jail, will I ever forgive myself for putting him there?
When I asked him why he did it, he said that I was his little wife and that he loved me. I don’t think that he wants to accept that what he did was wrong so he convinces himself that he was just being a good father. And that’s when I feel sorry for him all over again.
The truth is, I don’t know how I will answer the judge that day in court. I don’t know how I will feel sitting before my mother and father, the only parents I have, parents who I loved but parents who I know have failed me. I don’t understand all this hate and love I have for my family. I only wish I could erase the past.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.