Picture this: an average low-income family eating dinner. In the dimly lit room, the small kids are yelling like brats, haggling over a cheap, swollen pizza pie.
Five minutes into the dinner, the parents are also howling like brats, hassling over how to deal with this batch of naughty children (who resume eating dinner as if nothing has happened).
Yes, it’s an average low-income family dinner scene, except that it’s taking place at a foster care agency in Brooklyn, being observed by social workers, and is scheduled to end in approximately one hour.
No Easy Choices
This is a scene from Vanessa Roth’s new documentary, Taken In: The Lives of America’s Foster Children (to air on PBS, Channel 13 in New York, at 9 p.m. on May 22-check your local TV listings for the time in your area).
It’s also a vivid memory for any foster child who never had the chance to see his/her biological parents outside of an incredibly sterile office building.
The film revolves primarily around the moving tale of Jeffrey and Joanna Smith (15 and 5 years old), two White foster children who were taken from their drug-addicted parents (Russell and Anna) on charges of neglect and placed with a Hispanic foster family.
Jeffrey and Joanna want to go back to their parents but their parents are too crack-addicted to care for them. And throughout the documentary, this contradiction is masterfully highlighted. There are those who argue for terminating parents’ rights so foster children can be adopted, and then there are those who lobby for family reunification. Watching Taken In, one soon realizes that while both arguments are valid, the choice between the two is not easy.
There are also frequent pauses within the documentary where we get to hear other true life stories from former foster children themselves (one of whom is former FCYU writer Tieysha McVay).
A “Normal” Dinner
Aside from all the other memorable moments within the film, what really caught my eye was, as previously mentioned, that dinner scene during the family visit to the foster care agency.
The children (including the brothers of Jeffrey and Joanna, who had been living in a separate foster home at the time) ate and drank as if they were back home and nothing had ever happened to disrupt their lives.
It is open for debate whether this was some form of resilience, emotional suppression, adjustment to the circumstances, or if these children were just plain indifferent to the whole situation.
A Question of Identity
But, from my own experience, I will simply say that very young children are perhaps the most culturally adaptable creatures on the planet. I, personally, have never known any other family situation in my life other than foster care, and, up until my teenage years, it was perfectly normal to me.
However, if you’re a newcomer to the business of foster care and want an unbiased look at the daily life of foster children, this is the documentary to see.
The chronicle of Jeffrey’s and Joanna’s daily lives is very moving-from their daily diabetes shots (which they inject themselves), to their striking uneasiness at the church service they attend with their foster mother, to their struggle to understand the strange language (Spanish) of their new family.
In addition, the former foster children (Tieysha McVay, Michael Williams, Mary Cavanaugh, Bill and Paul Korff) shed light, with their stories, on the meaning of foster care.
They bring up such issues as unity, destiny, inheritance, and identity. The last of which is described by Mary Cavanaugh (the illegitimate child of a very religious Catholic woman who, in the 1940s, gave her up for adoption to avoid embarrassment): “In school, my sister introduced me as her ‘foster sister’ and I said, ‘So that’s what I am.'”
Indeed, it has come to the point where foster care is no longer the condition of not having a family but, in fact, the identity of being a child without a family. And, since we only realize our identities later on in life, most foster kids (like Jeffrey, the oldest in the film) are often ill-prepared to deal with the strange realization that they are “different.”
Tune In
But don’t take my word for it. Tune in to PBS (Channel 13) on May 22 at 9 p.m., and watch Taken In: The Lives of America’s Foster Children.
Forget the politics of foster care and observe the children closely. Look at what they have to go through on a daily basis and you be the judge.
Taken In: The Lives of America’s Foster Children
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.