If you’re planning on going to college, you’ve most likely been feeling stressed about obtaining a “good” score on the commonly dreaded, and in my case, hated, SAT.
After all, family, friends and schools are constantly warning us that getting into the right college depends on getting a high SAT score. So who can blame you for succumbing to the pressure? I certainly can’t. I’ve been worrying about the test since the 10th grade.
SAT Expectations
Although my parents are definitely not SAT-crazed, they do expect me to get at least a 1300. I got a 1380 on the PSAT (practice SAT) that I took in October, and if my test score falls in June, I will be mortified.
After all, some colleges hold your SAT score in equal standing to your grade point average-if I want to get into a good college, I’ll feel more confident about my prospects if I perform well on the SAT.
Recently however, I’ve been trying to put the test’s importance in perspective, which is sometimes hard to do at my high school. The students all sport the latest North Face jackets, Nike sneakers and Abercrombie and Fitch apparel. Preppy doesn’t even begin to describe the school’s atmosphere.
Still, I love it because the education is great and much more challenging than most city high schools.
Because of that, the atmosphere is competitive. There are about 60 kids in my grade and I know everyone’s name, the clique they hang out with and, more specifically, whether or not they get better grades than me. No, there’s not some literal listing of grades within the school, but perceived intelligence is out in the open.
Also out in the open is that SAT scores matter too. One of my teachers confessed that “SAT day” (the day each student discovers his or her test results) is the worst day of the year.
She described that day as so full of emotions-some students crying, others boasting in triumph-that it hurt her as a teacher to witness such an event. As one student attending the school explained, “If I get below a 1250, I’d cry and my parents would kill me.”
Parental Pressure
Many parents apply a great deal of pressure on their children to “succeed” on the SAT. They feel that their children must get above a certain score to increase their chances of attending a school like Harvard or Yale.
As one parent who wished to remain anonymous said, “SATs are very important and I would be very disappointed [if my daughter got under a 1300]. I expect her to get higher than the 1340 she got on the PSAT.”
Some parents stress that SATs are heavily weighed in the eyes of the supposed “best” colleges. According to New York Times writer Joseph Berger, the SATs help colleges “gauge the worth of more subjective factors like grades and teacher recommendations.” In other words, colleges use the test to help prove that a student deserves the grades and recommendations she receives.
A Score’s Impact
But feeling pressured to do well on the SAT has a major psychological impact on many students. According to 12th grader Paris Wells, who currently attends Manhattan’s City-As-School, getting a combined score ranging in the 900s made him feel “dumb.”
Patrick Caleb, another City-As-School student, felt “stupid” when he got in the 1000s. NYC Lab School student Deborah Slavin, on the other hand, felt “elated” and “proud” with her score of a 1350.
According to Deborah, the SATs create an inferiority complex amongst students who perform unsuccessfully on the test and a superiority complex amongst students who do well. She believes these feelings will “last far beyond high school.”
Embarrassing Moments
I’ve seen the effects myself.
Last year, a boy in my physics class felt embarrassed to ask me a question. A friend later told me he said he was embarrassed because I had gotten a 1380 PSAT score while he had gotten a 1240.
A 1240 is an amazing score, but the boy felt that I was smarter simply because I had gotten a slightly higher score. Similarly, I feel completely less knowledgeable than someone I know who has gotten a score in the 1500s. In my mind, that person must automatically be smarter than me.
Robert Schaeffer, the Public Education Director for the Fair Test organization, a non-profit organization that says the SATs are unfair, said this can be really dangerous.
“Students believe that they are their test score. If you get a high score you must be smart, and vice versa for a low score,” he said.
There’s More to Life
Yet while this SAT-hierarchy may be real for some parents and students, some high school juniors and seniors focus on other things. As Paris explained, “I’m not even prepping [for the SAT].” According to Paris, the combination of his stressful internship, busy school life and hands-on musical aspirations simply don’t leave time for the test.
Amy Waters, a junior at the Lab School, said, “For me, personally, the SATs rate about a four on the scale of one to ten.”
She went on to say that “hobbies like basketball or softball are much more interesting and, I think, important for me than some SAT. I love those things and so of course I put them in front of SAT studying.
“The SATs put you into this box that doesn’t mention whether or not you’re a great basketball player, brilliant artist, or an amazing chemistry student,” Amy added. “The SAT just shows you how good you are at taking the SATs.”
Some colleges agree with this philosophy and place more of an emphasis on finding well-rounded students. Take Bard College, a small liberal arts school located in Annandale-on-Hudson, New York. The college doesn’t even require the test.
According to Jane Brien, the assistant director of admissions, “The philosophy of Bard is that the SATs are not a great indicator of a student’s potential-they aren’t the whole story.”
Bard is not alone in this belief. In a recent New York Times article, Columbia University’s president, George E. Rupp, said that admission officers there “turn down lots of students with very high SATs, and admit some students with very low SATs.”
Forced to Conform
Still, the SAT is just one of many exams that society equates with intelligence. The regents, the ACT, and those ridiculous City-wide English and math tests taken in elementary school force our intelligence to conform to the mold of what certain individuals have labeled as valuable knowledge.
Knowing an analogy like whether a basket is to fruit as a cup is to liquid is not applicable to everyone’s “real” world. And I really don’t care to read some boring passage about whether or not plants thrive in desert environments.
But you can bet that I’m going to be studying like hell for that test regardless of my opinion of it. As my English teacher once advised, some tests are worth putting all your effort into, and others aren’t. It’s a reality that most colleges are more likely to accept you if you have a high score, so if I want to go to a good school, then I’d better give the SAT my all.
SIDEBAR: Is the SAT Biased?
According to the College Board (the makers of the test), the SATs are not meant to sum up who you are as a student, but rather, to help admissions officers get a glimpse of the grades you’ll get in your first year of college. Other experts disagree. Robert Schaeffer, the Public Education Director for the Fair Test organization, asked, “How is it then that on the SAT, young women get lower scores than men but get higher grades in their first year of college? The answer is that the test is biased.” Schaeffer and other SAT critics believe that the SAT doesn’t determine how well you’ll do, but rather, how successful you are at taking tests under pressure. For example, Bill Bradley, who later became a senator, star basketball player, honor student at Princeton, Rhodes scholar and just recently, a potential Democratic nominee for the presidency, scored only a 485 on the SAT verbal section in his teen years. Often, the hardest workers don’t get the highest SAT scores.
Minorities and Women Are at a Disadvantage
Many of the test’s critics also feel that SATs work against minorities, women and students of lower financial status. These groups, on average, get lower scores than privileged White males. As many students who’ve taken the test already know, the SAT is fast-paced and intuitive-you’ve got to be able to trust your instincts and just go for an answer regardless of whether or not you’re 100% sure you’re right. If you take time to second guess yourself, chances are that you’re not going to finish the entire exam, which leaves you with a lower score. Unfortunately, many studies have found that girls, students coming from poorer backgrounds, and minorities often are less likely to trust their instincts. As a result, they tend to second guess themselves. Since our society favors rich White men-they’ve usually gotten better jobs, earned more money, etc.,-non-Whites and women often have less self-confidence. So they aren’t particularly prone to trusting their initial ideas and answers on a test like the SAT. GPA = Test Score According to the Fall 1991 edition of The Examiner, a pamphlet from The National Center for Fair & Open Testing, while girls’ grade point averages are generally higher than boys, they tend to get lower SAT scores. The average math score for girls is about 20-40 points below the average score for boys. The average verbal score for girls is 502; for math, it’s 495. Males score an average of 509 on the verbal and 531 on the math. Despite their lower GPAs, boys have an advantage over girls when their college applications are being viewed because of their higher SAT scores. As The Examiner explains, “Schools that rely on SAT scores to determine admissions or scholarship aid are denying females equal educational opportunity.” Because certain colleges use SATs as a significant factor in determining who can attend their school and who can’t, critics believe that such schools are making the same mistakes that the SAT has made-assessing students based on how they take a test.
Unfair to Immigrants
Students who speak English as a second language are also expected to take the same test as students for whom English is their first language. As Schaeffer explained, “The SAT encourages snap judgments based on three digit scores. For an immigrant who’s never spoken English before moving to America to get a 500 as an English verbal score is great, but for someone who has grown up speaking English all of their life, a 500 is completely average.” The idea that a non-English-speaking student should be forced to take the same test as students who have spoken English all their lives is completely unfair. Not all students come from the same background, and to ignore those differences is a great disservice. Students from poor backgrounds who don’t have access to the best schools, tutors or $800 SAT prep courses like those offered by Kaplan or Princeton Review may also find themselves struggling with the SAT. When test time comes, a student who didn’t hire an SAT tutor will be treated the same as someone who did.
