Lennie Payne, a senior at Chelsea Vocational HS, is one of many students who feels that he has been harassed by transit cops: “They always seem to ask to see [passes] for some unapparent reason. Even if the train is right there and you run through and flash your pass, they will call you back.”
Lennie continued: “Meanwhile if your friend is holding the door for you, the police will make him let go of the door.”
End Up Missing the Train
“As soon as you walk into the train station, you just put your pass to the glass where the lady [in the token booth] is, and walk through. But if the police didn’t see you, they will always stop you, and then the train goes ding-ding and you have to wait for another one,” said Matthew, 14, of Mahalia Jackson JHS.
Matthew recalled a recent experience: “I paid my fare at this station but the turnstile wasn’t working and my token got stuck. I told the lady that my token was stuck and she told me to go under. Then [after] I went under the cop stopped me.”
Many young people feel that police officers treat them unfairly and discriminate against them simply because they are young. They argue that this is especially true for Blacks and Latinos.
“Some policemen are very ‘racial,’ especially those White ones,” stated Matthew.
“I think they’re unfair. A lot of times policemen have quotas and in the past, they have arrested people on false charges just so they could get in their quotas. I believe that a lot of times the White cops harass certain Black people on the train,” explained Cleveland, a student at City College in Manhattan. He continued: “For the most part, cops are racist. There are very few Black cops. And you have to understand that White people really don’t understand much about Black culture.”
Cleveland believes that a White cop from Long Island, Elmhurst, Queens, or Bensonhurst, Brooklyn, doesn’t know how to deal with young minorities from Bushwick or Bed-Stuy.
Positive & Negative Stereotyping
David agreed: “I think definitely that [transit cops] are partial…If I was a ‘mighty whitey’ I don’t think that they ever would have stopped me in the first place. I think that if I was some little spastic White kid wearing a Michigan college T-shirt, some sweatpants, and a little billed cap looking very, very, very pristine, then he wouldn’t have said anything.”
“It’s usually the nerd-looking kid who they let go through with no problem. Yet when you get these hard-looking brothers with baseball caps, the jeans, and the hats, those are the guys they usually check,” pointed out Cleveland. “What I have seen is that transit cops have a tendency to be more helpful to White people, especially young White women. You see these young White and Black cops talking to girls on the platform when their main job is not getting a rap or phone numbers.”
Many teens agreed that the police are guilty of negative stereotyping: “You have to understand that the image of a young Black teenager and a criminal is almost synonymous nowadays. Walking around with their jeans pulled halfway down their behinds, crumpled all at their feet, wearing real expensive sneakers, a billed cap, and a really expensive jacket. That’s the look, and that look almost means criminal [to cops], explained David.
Unnecessary Force
Not only do young subway riders feel that transit cops harass them, they also feel these cops needlessly use force against them.
“If you talk back to a police officer when they arrest you, then they will beat you up,” believes Matthew.
On one occasion, after trying to explain to a transit officer that he paid his fare, David claimed that “The cop said, ‘No you didn’t,’ after which he roped me up, pulled out that billy club and almost started beating me like I was a fool.”
Cleveland agreed: “Even though we haven’t heard of any major incidents of it in the subway system since Michael Stewart, police brutality does exist but just isn’t reported.”
But many teens acknowledge that not all cops are unfair and disrespectful, and even admit that cops in New York City have a difficult job.
Transit Cops Should Protect Teens
“[Some cops] are fair but, they all have a fear of kids because of all these policemen getting shot,” explained Lennie.
“At most stations, people don’t pay unless there is a transit cop there,” said Cleveland. He added that at the train station near A. Philip Randolph HS, “When authorities aren’t there, you can see crackheads just sucking out the tokens.”
Lennie agreed. “[Transit cops] should be in the train station to protect [you]…because when you get on the trains, kids be rolling in packs of 15. And it helps if a cop is there because they aren’t going to cause any trouble and they won’t mess with you.”
“Even though I don’t agree with the police all the time, and even though they do have a tendency to harass certain people, they should at least be in school locations,” claimed Cleveland.
And David argued that even when really bad hoods get on the subway, they don’t do anything when they see a cop in the car. “They always wait until they get outside, or upstairs out of the subway.”
Still, many teens felt that all transit cops should be trained to treat all young people fairly while providing the protection necessary while riding the subway. “Young punks these days just want to rob you, get the money, house your Timberlands, your Columbia jacket, and just jet,” said Matthew.
SIDEBAR
A Cop Responds Interview with Sgt. Robert Valentino, spokesman for the Transit Police Public Information Dept.
Many young people say they are not treated fairly by transit cops. How would you respond to that?
“We treat all passengers the same. All people, no matter what their race, age, or color, when they pay their fare have the right to be treated the same. We have a problem with those breaking the rules. So regardless of age or race, if you’re breaking the rules you’ll have to suffer the measures taken, whether it be verbal, or through a summons. It seems that teens are committing the felonies more than any of the other age groups who are passengers on the trains.”
Why do teens complain that they are often stopped by transit cops?
“As far as teen complaints about passes being checked, that’s a requirement. There are so many people not paying for tokens and evading their fare. The city loses $70 million a year due to fare evasion. So it’s a requirement that we check all IDs and passes. We look at police IDs and transit worker IDs…as well as student passes.”
What can you tell our readers about Project Safe?
“Project Safe Passage was instituted in May of 1990 in Brooklyn. What it did was offer students the opportunity to ride the train in a designated car with a cop. We now have 71 assignments in operation throughout the subway system. There have been no reported felonies while officers have been riding in the trains with the students.”
What other school outreach programs do you have?
“Usually the same cops used in Project Safe Passage are used in the social outreach program. What happens is cops are placed in different schools, [it’s in about 150 high schools and junior high schools] and they go over problems that principals are having, [with students]. For instance, if a principal knows that there is a kid with a gun in the school, they would tell our officers and they, [the officers]…handle the situation.”
Do you have any advice for teens?
“The criminal element-not just in the subway-but in the city, warrants caution. They should be careful, stay in a group and not alone when outside or inside the subway. When riding on the trains they should ride in the car with the Project Safe Passage officer or ride with the motorman.”
