It’s Hard Visiting Parents in Jail-Sometimes It’s Worse Not to
Fourteen years ago, when Elizabeth Gaynes’ daughter was 6 and her son was 2, their father was arrested and sent to prison.
A few years later, she began Family Works, a program that helps fathers in prison stay connected to their kids and become better dads. This is some of what she had to say about what it’s like for kids to have a father behind bars.
NYC: Why did you start Family Works?
Gaynes: When we developed Family Works, we looked at many factors.
One question was: Is it good for the children? One fact is that 50% of juveniles in prison have a close relative, usually a father, in prison. It’s a big risk factor for a young person.
It’s not because their parents are telling kids to go commit crimes. It’s something to do with how all children idealize their parents and want to be like them. Or it’s because it makes kids angry and alienates them to have a parent taken away, and that’s why they get in trouble.
Or the kids are raised around factors that are some of the same reasons that the parent goes into prison-like being around drugs, or living in poverty.
Helping Inmates Be Better Parents
We realized that having a parent in prison would have an affect on a kid whether the child saw his parent or not. And keeping them together would probably be better, because 95% of all people in prison are going to come home. And all parents can use help. So we’re trying to help inmates become better parents.
Some people have said that if we make it pleasant [to visit], maybe kids won’t be deterred from becoming criminals. But in talking to young people, we see that they still know it means you can’t come home. Even the best of circumstances does not encourage kids to come to prison.
NYC: How do kids feel when their fathers are in prison?
Gaynes: There’s a lot of stigma about parents who are arrested. Children worry that other people will think there’s something wrong with you, that you’re the bad seed. Crime is in no way genetic. Kids are not more likely to be born criminals.
Kids Learn to Lie
My children’s father was arrested when they were young. My daughter told some of her friends, and their mothers wouldn’t let them play with her anymore. She was 7 years old.
She quickly learned not to tell anyone. She said he was down south, or in the military. A lot of kids are afraid their friends will think less of them.
NYC: How do kids react to visiting their parents in jail?
Gaynes: They’re relieved to see that their parent is safe. From the media, they worry that their parents will be on bread and water, or that they’re mistreated.
There’s also a lot of sadness when they have to leave. It feels bad to be told by someone to leave your father.
My Daughter Felt Betrayed
They’re also angry at the parent. My daughter, for a year she wouldn’t go visit her dad. She felt he betrayed her. Kids also get angry at the corrections department and the police and other authorities, because they believe they’re responsible for putting their dad in the situation.
Kids usually believe their parents are innocent or are being punished much more harshly than necessary. That’s especially true now with so many people going to prison for years basically because they’re drug addicts. Many people believe that’s a stupid response.
Mostly it’s both sad and angry.
Prisoners Are Treated
Like Babies
But also, there’s something more complicated. While prisoners aren’t treated badly in front of their kids, they’re treated like children, or like they’re stupid and dangerous.
Like in the visiting room, there are vending machines. But inmates are not allowed to go near them or use them. There’s a line they’re not allowed to cross. As if they can’t be trusted with 50 cents.
We like to think of our parents as strong and capable. Prisoners are treated like they’re 2. They’re constantly belittled. It has an affect on kids. It’s a combination of angry and upset-it’s difficult for kids to see that.
Visiting a parent is less difficult than being cut off, though, when all the negative feelings are still there but there’s not the relief and comfort of knowing that your parent thinks of you, loves and cares for you.
Not knowing your father who is in prison, I think the impact can be worse. I feel like whether you know your father or not, he has a big impact on you. Even friends whose fathers died before they were born, it has a big influence. And what info kids don’t have, they make up. Either that he’s a bad guy or a good guy.
Staying Connected
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.