In the four years that I’ve been in foster care, I have had little to no contact with my mother. I’ve tried not to show surface signs of the emotions I’ve been enduring. But I can’t recall a time when I went to bed without wondering what my life would be like if I were still living with my mother.
I’ve asked myself unanswerable questions. “If I stayed home, would my mother keep taking out her anger on me?” “Would I have the same friends?” “I wonder if we would get along any better now.”
I thought the daily torment of these questions would never end. I didn’t believe I’d ever be able to discuss these feelings with my mother. We’d never held a conversation about our relationship or my feelings. And since four years had passed, and I’m now 18, I wasn’t sure I’d ever go home again.
A Text-Message Out of the Blue
But a few months ago, my mother and I began to communicate. One day soon after I started a summer job, she text-messaged me and asked where I was working. When I told her, she wrote that she worked close by and that she would like to meet me and go out to dinner. I was shocked and thrilled. Once I agreed, I grew anxious. The last time I’d seen her was at a family funeral a year before, and that was for only 10 minutes.
Immediately after work I headed uptown. We’d agreed to meet underneath a big clock facing a small park. On the way over I was thinking to myself, “I hope everything goes well. What are we going to talk about?”
I saw my mom standing under the clock before she saw me. As I approached and she noticed me, she smiled brightly, as did I, and we hugged. All my questions flew out the window. I wasn’t worried about anything. I just wanted to enjoy our evening together.
“Are you hungry?” she asked.
“Yeah, I’m ready to eat.”
“Good, because I am starving.”
Talking Like Old Friends
We walked up to Times Square, talking about cars, dogs, my job, her job, my sister, how the summer was going for us. It made me very happy to see that she was happy. She was also interested in my job and she asked a lot of questions.
At the restaurant, we stood on line waiting for a table. I jokingly criticized some of the patrons for being too loud or for not wearing matching clothing, and my mom started laughing, telling me, “Stop,” or, “Behave,” with a hint of a giggle in her voice.
I’d have bet all of my worldly possessions that when my mother and I finally did meet, there would have been an unbearable awkwardness between us. I expected to be speechless. I was relieved that it felt more like we were old friends, or that she was my older sister, not a mother who had been absent from my life for years.
Something Missing
But later I felt like something was wrong in our conversation. I started to think our discussion could have been between people who were almost strangers. “Am I like that guy from high school that she hasn’t seen in years and then runs into on the street? They hold a quick conversation about their lives and then go their separate ways?” I wondered. “Is that who we have become to each other? Am I that guy?”
I don’t know how parents usually interact with their kids, but I know I don’t want a polite relationship with my mother. I want her to be my mother and me to be her son.
When I was living at home, my mom and I fought. It was ridiculous. My mother is a professional, accomplished woman, but behind the image she presents to the world, she holds a rage. When I met her anger with my own attitude, we got into shouting matches. Our loudness would rival an arena filled to capacity with excited spectators.
We argued over the smallest things: cleaning my room, walking the dog, and my grades at school. ( I was not very fond of school.) There were times when I was a flat out pain in the ass and deserved what came to me, but mostly it seemed like my mom would just spaz unnecessarily. When that happened and I was the target, I barked back.
Shouting Matches Turned Physical
During these shouting matches, we erupted, slamming doors and throwing random objects. She’d scream hurtful things that I cannot forget: “Why don’t you go live with your father?” I fired back primitive comments: “Shut up!” “Leave me alone!”
On too many occasions our shouting turned into physical fights. My mom would go get the belt. Oh, no, I wasn’t having that. I wasn’t gonna stand still and let anyone hit me. Unwilling to strike back, I did whatever I could to keep myself from being hit. Running, ducking, dodging-not a corner of the house went untouched. This would continue until I locked myself in my room, crippled by a headache or on the verge of losing my voice.
Grandma Stepped In
I hated having conflict with my mother. I didn’t understand why she had to make it physical, but it seemed unavoidable. She had her mind made up about certain things, and so did I. There was no middle ground. That is a recipe for trouble. But I grew tired of trouble.
Fed up with all the drama, I ran to my grandmother’s house when I couldn’t take it anymore. Each time, I felt a brief sense of comfort and relaxation. But our confrontations only got worse as our frustration and rage built up. One night my grandmother called ACS, the city’s foster care agency, to make a report against my mother. The caseworker decided that I would live with my grandmother until my mother and I worked through our problems.
Therapy didn’t Help Us
At first, the agency mandated that my mother, sister and I go to family therapy once a week. After school my mother would pick us up and take us to the therapist’s office. On the way there we usually got along fine, but in the office my mother, my sister and I would either sit in silence or take turns snapping about what we thought was wrong with each other and why our family had these issues. Coming home we were silent, each of us visibly angry.
Even though the therapist was supposed to help, no good ever came out of those discussions. Disagreeing and yelling at each other only seemed to make things worse. Once the therapy stopped, we mostly stopped talking or seeing each other.
I Missed My Mom . . .
With my mother gone from my life, I felt incomplete. Despite all our conflicts, I admire my mother in many ways, and her values and care have made me who I am today.
My mother always held education in high regard. She wanted my sister and me to be intelligent and well-rounded. She made sure we read on a daily basis and practiced our penmanship and mathematics, in and out of school, year round. She made sure we traveled and did activities, like martial arts, to strengthen our minds.
She taught me the value of always looking presentable, and made sure I was well-mannered and capable of holding a conversation with people much older than me. Her insistence led my sister to Exeter, one of the toughest boarding schools in the country, and I also went to boarding school in Pennsylvania last year.
It Takes Two to Argue
My mother also taught me to assert my authority and never let anyone use me or talk to me like I was inferior. I saw her stand up to whomever raised their voice at her-my father, my grandmother, anyone. Often she took that too far. She was stubborn and refused to lose any arguments. (I did not see it then, but now I see all of these things in myself.)
As much as my mother has hurt me, I admire her, and while we were not speaking, I was sad, lonely, confused and angry. I felt I’d been left with a gaping hole in the fabric of my life.
I do not blame only my mother for my being in foster care. It takes two people to argue. So I can only hope that we can start over. I’d like us to make up for lost time, if that is possible. I believe my mother has a lot to offer me.
Since that first night when we had dinner, my mom and I have been trying to start a new relationship. We have spoken on the phone, written emails back and forth, gone out to dinner and seen movies.
We have a good time and we enjoy each other’s company, but I can’t shake the feeling that something is gone between us. Maybe our relationship feels different because I am older and more mature now, or maybe it takes time to make up for so much time apart.
My grandmother has tried to fill a parent’s shoes, and now my mom is trying to be a mother again. But I still feel like I have no parents. My father left long ago, and my mother is not really part of me, either. I think that’s because I still don’t understand how she feels about everything that went on between us, and she doesn’t know how I feel, either.
I Need an Explanation
As long as we are getting along great, I don’t want to mess things up by talking about the past. But I hope to someday talk with my mother about what went on between us. I need that to help put our past behind me.
Perhaps one day we will be out to dinner somewhere and one of those “remember the time?” conversations will come up. A conversation that begins with a pleasant, humorous tone will end serious and apologetic, as we pour out everything we have felt.
I’ll say, “Remember the time you were in a rush to get to Manhattan and Erika and I were moving really slow? Ha! The train station was right across the street but you were so flustered you walked all the way around the block.” We’ll laugh, but then the tone will suddenly change as we remember what came next.
âWhy Were You So Angry?’
My sister and I were standing in front of the house wondering what the hell she was doing walking around the block, and whether she expected us to follow. She arrived back shortly, and shot a glance towards us that said, “Upstairs! Now!”
Once upstairs she began yelling.
“Why are you people holding me up? I have somewhere to be! You think the world revolves around you?” she said.
“You were moving too fast. We weren’t ready yet. It’s not our fault!” I yelled back.
Putting the Past Behind
Our flashback moment will end and, after a few seconds of uncomfortable silence, I’ll ask her, “Why would you get so angry at us?”
I can’t even imagine what she might say, but I hope that she’ll explain her reasons and apologize, and that I’ll accept her apology and apologize, too. Over time, with our explanations and apologies we might put the past behind us and enjoy a newfound positive relationship.
Sound like a storybook ending to you, too? It does to me. But if I could receive an explanation and give one, I think I might be ready to move on. I have been waiting for her explanation for four years, and I have mine prepared.
Starting Over
Do My Mom and I Need to Talk About the Past to Move Forward?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.