When I was in 6th grade, my mother bought me a pair of Skechers sneakers. I hated wearing them. Every day, I’d make up a reason why I needed a new pair. They were too small, I told her. They didn’t match my school uniform. They squeaked when I walked. After weeks of hearing me complain, my mom finally gave in and bought me a pair of white and navy blue New Balance shoes that I picked out from Foot Locker.
The real reason I didn’t want to wear the Skechers? For starters, they were ugly, covered with shiny material and indigo stripes, and they reminded me of girls’ sneakers. But more importantly, they were cheap-a measly $40. To my classmates, wearing an inexpensive sneaker was a fatal flaw: I would have been teased if I’d ever worn them to school. So I never did. I wore my old sneakers until my mom bought the new pair.
So imagine my surprise last fall when I heard that people were lining up by the hundreds to buy $15 sneakers.
Cheap Sneakers Reduce Crime?
Starbury is a new line of athletic apparel endorsed by New York Knicks basketball player Stephon Marbury and sold exclusively by the Steve & Barry’s sportswear chain. The main selling point is the price: the flagship product is the Starbury One basketball sneakers, which sell for $14.98 a pair. Every other item in the Starbury line costs less than $10, compared to the newest basketball sneakers from Nike and Adidas, which cost as much as $199.
High-priced basketball sneakers are so coveted by youth that Marbury actually predicted that his new Starbury line would help keep kids safer by decreasing their chances of being mugged over expensive clothing, according to a December 2006 article on citymayors.com, a website that monitors the conditions of the world’s major cities.
Atlanta police have reported an average of 12 violent muggings per month since 1990, just for sportswear, according to the article. And over the same period, Chicago police have reported 12 muggings and violent acts per month involving athletic shoes alone, and more than 50 incidents involving expensive sports-team logo jackets.
Price vs. Quality
Most teens don’t go to these extremes, but the sentiment is still there-some clothing items, especially sneakers, are worth blowing your (or your parents’) money for. The fact that others know you paid that much is the appeal.
So the popularity of Starbury was news to me. Usually sneakers under $20 were the butt of jokes. Yet the Starbury shoes seemed to be selling faster than they could make them. It made no sense to me, the average materialistic teenager.
I knew almost nothing about the new sneakers, so I decided to approach the subject as a potential customer. Would I take Starbury over the higher-priced shoes I usually buy? First I wanted to find out if the low price meant lower quality.
There have always been cheap alternatives to high-end products, such as a line of sneakers endorsed by Shaquille O’Neale and sold exclusively at Payless Shoes stores. What’s different this time is that Marbury claims that the Starbury sneakers are just as well-made as the more expensive Nike or Reebok sneakers. To prove it, Marbury wore them in all of the games he played last season.
Ripped Off by Nike
But I have to admit, I was skeptical. Could a $15 sneaker really be as good as a $125 pair? It turns out that a better question would be: Can a $15 sneaker really be as good as a sneaker that stores sell for $125?
The wording makes a huge difference, because in reality, no mass-produced sneaker is worth over $100. In fact, the actual cost of making a sneaker-whether it’s an Air Force 1 or Starbury One-is nowhere close. I’d always assumed that the expensive sneakers must have better material and more highly skilled labor, that the exorbitant prices meant better quality.
Then I did some online research about sneaker manufacturing. According to a 2005 article in BusinessWeek, Nike sells its Air Force 1 sneakers to retailers for about $48 a pair, after manufacturing them in Asia at a cost of only $12. The retailers then jack up the price to $85 and up. In other words, almost all of what you’re paying is profit for Nike and the shoe stores. As I sit here, wearing my all black Air Force 1 shoes, I feel like I’ve been ripped off.
Status Symbols on Our Feet
Maybe the quality of the Starbury is as good as that of Nikes or Adidas. But I’m still not convinced that Starbury will ever be as popular as Nike or Adidas, for the simple reason that they cost less. Many people see the price itself as a status symbol. Sneakers are more than footwear now-they’re like collector’s items, big billboards telling everyone that the wearer has tons of money to burn.
Those Skechers my mother bought me in 6th grade were just as well-made as the expensive Nikes my classmates wore. And my shoes looked better than some of the pairs they were wearing, too. But that wasn’t the issue. The problem was that a cheaper shoe would’ve given my classmates the impression that I couldn’t afford a “better” shoe and had to settle for less.
Things haven’t changed much since 6th grade. Since Steve & Barry’s released them last August, the company has sold about a million pairs of Starbury Ones, according to Neil Weilheimer, executive editor of the trade magazine Footwear News, in a recent interview with The New York Times. At $15 a pair, that’s about $15 million in sales.
‘How Would I Look?’
That may seem like a lot, but compared to the billions of dollars earned annually by Nike and Adidas, which recently bought Reebok, the Starbury line still isn’t major competition. To get an idea of how insignificant $15 million is to Nike, consider this: NBA player Lebron James is signed to a $90 million eight-year contract with Nike to endorse its sneakers.
I asked my friends if they’d be buying the Starbury shoes, and every single one said no. Why not? It couldn’t be because they didn’t have the $15 for a pair. Some of my friends spend almost that amount for lunch every day. Was it the appearance? That wasn’t it either-over half of my friends hadn’t even seen a pair before.
The explanations I got all went something like this: “How would I look wearing a pair of Starburys?” In other words, how would they look to other people if they bought a $15 pair of shoes?
When my friends realized their responses seemed materialistic, they got defensive, asking me, “Would you ever wear a pair?”
In all honesty, I probably wouldn’t. I don’t think they look as good as Nikes or Adidas. I like how the swoosh and Jumpman logo look on my Nikes. The Starbury logo, which is, unsurprisingly, a stylized five-pointed star, seems too plain, too generic. It doesn’t have any history behind it or a sense of exclusivity that took Nike and Reebok decades to create.
Style Over Value
So, after a couple of weeks of gathering information, I came to the following conclusions: Starbury sneakers are equal in quality to the much more expensive competition and lots of people are buying them (though not as many as are buying Nikes and Adidas) and giving them good reviews. And despite all of this, I still wouldn’t buy them.
I admit that it’s easy for me to pick style over value. I still rely on my parents for money. I’ve never had to work for a living or worry about being broke. Starburys were made for people who don’t want to spend all of their money on a pair of sneakers.
If I did have to worry about money on a regular basis, I’d make the sensible choice: choosing a good price over looks, and getting Starburys. Because in an age where shoe companies reap huge profits from their products, the idea that more expensive equals better just isn’t true. But for now, I’ll keep my Nikes.
Starbury: The New Status Symbol?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.