Spike Celebrates Malcolm

It’s here. And with Spike Lee’s Malcolm X finally on the screens, all the hype can finally die down. Hopefully there will be an end to the many controversies that started even before the movie went into production: the fear among some Blacks like poet Amiri Baraka that Lee would portray Malcolm X in a negative light; the lack of funds; the image of the burning flag during the opening credits; and all the other endless talk.
Although exaggerated, the talk was not completely without merit. Malcolm X is a very powerful film. Most of the credit for that goes not to the movie but to the subject-Malcolm himself and his extraordinary speeches.
Before we even see Malcolm, we hear his voice: “I charge the White man as the greatest murderer, the greatest rapist, the greatest enslaver, and the greatest swine-eater alive,” he proclaims.
Malcolm does violently attack “the White man,” at least verbally, but only because he is angry at 400 years of oppression-and understandably so. He would not have told us to get justice “by any means necessary” if it were something that came to us easily.
“Some people call this Hate-teaching,” he tells a crowd later in the film. “This is Love-teaching. I wouldn’t tell you this if I didn’t love you. It’s not Black supremacy, it’s Black intelligence. [The honorable Elijah Muhammad] is not teaching us to hate White people; he’s teaching us to love ourselves.”
Standing Up For His People
It makes sense. In this movie, Malcolm X comes across as a man trying to get Black people to stand up for themselves. He genuinely loves his people. In one scene, Malcolm leads a large crowd of Blacks like soldiers to a police precinct in Harlem and has them stand peacefully outside until he is allowed to see a man who has been beaten nearly to death by the cops.
At another point in the film, a reporter asks him if he promotes violence, and he clearly says, “No.” The reporter asks him why he encouraged Black people to own guns. “When you tell your people to stop killing Black people,” he replies. “I’ll tell my people to put their guns away.” He was talking about self-defense.
Not only are Malcolm’s words powerful, but Denzel Washington, who plays Malcolm, makes you believe them. Denzel makes a great transition from the young Malcolm, a street-smart hustler, drug-user, and burglar, to the eloquent spokesman for the Nation of Islam. He also looks a little like Malcolm.
Angela Bassett gives a good performance as well, as Malcolm’s wife, Betty Shabazz. She is very forceful as she shouts at him to face the truth about his friends in the Nation of Islam who are about to betray him. Yet she is also fragile as she cries at Malcolm’s side after he is brutally shot down. Betty is the first really strong female character that I’ve seen in a Spike Lee movie.
It’s Too Long
This movie is also different from the other Spike Lee movies that I’ve seen in that it is an epic. It’s big. There are breath-taking scenes of tens of thousands of Islamic pilgrims worshipping outside a giant temple in Mecca. They are taken from the sky and the people look like little ants.
But for all it’s grandeur, Malcolm X is too long. There wasn’t any need for it to go on for over three hours. Surely some lengthy bar and club scenes from Malcolm’s early days as a street hustler could have been cut down a little. As a historical film, it’s very talky to begin with and there’s not much to look at. The length takes away from the movie. You get restless, and your mind starts to wander.
After the images of burning flags and footage of the Rodney King beating at the beginning, I expected the movie to be very violent, with images of White people being slaughtered. But I was wrong. Spike Lee could have chosen to portray Malcolm as savagely anti-White or he could have shown us the different sides of Malcolm X and let us decide for ourselves what to think of him. He didn’t do either.
A True Hero
Instead, he clearly embraces Malcolm as a role model. Even the early scenes of Malcolm as a criminal are somewhat glamorous. And, if by the end of the film we had any doubts at all, they’re erased by Ossie Davis’s eulogy describing Malcolm as a “shining Black prince” and a scene with Nelson Mandela telling African schoolchildren what a great man Malcolm was. The movie comes out as a pure celebration of Malcolm X, the Black hero.
But whatever your opinion of him, Malcolm’s legacy is still very much alive today. Not just on the hats and trinkets bearing the letter X, but in the lyrics of rappers like Ice Cube and events like the uprising in L.A. last spring. So even if I said, “Don’t go see Malcolm X,” who would listen? Obviously you’re going to see it and, if you’re one of those people who wears an X hat but doesn’t know what the man was all about, you’re in for a real learning experience.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.