Skinheads: Racist Monsters or Survivors in a Bleak World?

“My parents think I’m a Nazi, because that’s what the media tells them, and my parents are stupid. People see what they want to see, and hear what they want to hear; it’s about time somebody opened their eyes.”
-George Stephens, 23, a Black skinhead.
You see them as they walk down the street and you recognize them immediately.
They wear steel-toed Doc Marten boots and thin red suspenders they call braces. They have closely cropped hair or bald shaven heads. They’re known as skinheads.
But, who are they?
Are they the violent, racist monsters portrayed by the media? Or are they something else?
What, indeed, is the truth about skinheads?
Through interviews with various skinheads, we found that many of them in New York are not racist; indeed, many of them are from minority backgrounds-Black, Hispanic, and Asian as well as White.
We also found many different reasons for why they became skinheads.
Some teens are exposed to it by their friends, who may already be skinheads. Some enjoy the music, and just drifted into it.
Some agree with the skinhead ideals of patriotism and sticking up for your friends at all times. Some just like the ‘Boots & Braces’ look.
And some (both racist and non-racist) are attracted to the violence that, sadly, is ever present on the skinhead scene-and has been since the beginning.
There are many different versions of how and where they began, but the generally accepted history is that the style started in the mid ’60s in England.
Working Class Youth In England
The original skinheads were young, poor teens, both Black and White, who got their style from the Mods and the West Indian teens known as Rude Boys or Rudies.
They wore tough inexpensive clothing (like boots, braces, jeans, and pressed Ben Sherman shirts) as a symbol of their working-class roots.
They shaved their heads for two reasons-as a visible sign of unity with other skins, and also to prevent an opponent from grabbing their hair in a street fight. This tough, aggressive look gave them an edge when dealing with people on the street.
Their music in the ’60s was Ska, which is a type of Reggae with a light, fast beat and lots of horns.
Ska music sang about life on the streets, the underdog fighting back, and other things-some were simply love songs.
The skinhead style in England reached its height in ’69, died out in the early ’70s, and came back with a vengeance in 1976 with the rise of Punk.
But, by this time, it had changed.
While the first skinheads didn’t have strong political views, many of the new skin-heads were racist and fascist (though not all were!).
Their music in the ’70s was Oi, a hard, fast, and aggressive sounding music derived from both the original punk sound and some elements of Ska.
Edwin Nieves, a 17-year-old Hispanic skin, described Oi as talking “about the life a skinhead goes through… a lot of it talks about working, and a lot of songs talk about what we do when people don’t give us a chance.”
But some bands (like the English bands Skrewdriver and Brutal Attack) inserted racist propaganda into their songs, while others (like the legendary Sham 69, Cocksparrer, and the Oppressed) were actively anti-racist.
In any case, when English Punk came over the water to America, so did skinheads.
However, through our various interviews, we found that the skinhead scene in New York is very different from the scene presented by the general media.
Black, Hispanic, and Jewish Skinheads
One skin at we talked with outside CBGB’s (a small, dark, and seedy club on the Bowery in Manhattan that specializes in under ground rock music) had this to say: “The thing with us skinheads is, while up in England they’re all White supremacy, the New York skinheads are more minorities-we got our own style…”
Arman, 21, lead singer for the New York hardcore band Rest In Pieces, and drummer for the band Sick Of It All, had this observation to make: “America is a mostly White country. So, there’s a lot of hick skinheads-they don’t see Black and Hispanic people, so they have this thing in their minds, ‘Oh, White is the way,’ White pride, White-power, all that sh-t.
“But, in New York,” he continued “because everybody lives together, and there’s so many different races involved with each other-you have Black skinheads, Hispanic skinheads, White skinheads, Jewish skinheads, everything… and it all works out!”
Sam, a 20-year-old skinhead interviewed at CBGB’s, added that “in the New York area, the majority of skinheads are not racist or fascist, but in other cities they are very powerful-we don’t have strong WAR (White Aryan Resistance) chapters or things like that in New York.”
Sam added: “I’m very liberal; I don’t believe that anybody is wrong for who they want to sleep with, what color they are, what they want to listen to, or anything… I can’t understand how someone could think they’re better because of their heritage or color. I think that’s ridiculous!”
Many skins we talked to feel that the media coverage of skinheads is highly inaccurate and is a ploy to get higher ratings at their expense.
Bad News Sells
When we asked Edwin about this, he had this to say: “What TV does, the good stuff doesn’t sell-they have to take stuff… so they make us all bad. And, people, like, they just want to hate something, and skinhead’s a perfect to hate…”
Andrew Szarzinski, a 20-year-old skinhead, asked, “Why do people listen to TV? They trust it. TV’s their friend. They’ll believe the TV more than they’ll believe you…”
In a way, though, skinheads are kind of used to being outcasts.
The image of the luckless, troubled skinhead-kicked around by the press and TV, violently attacked by both the police and the general public, forced to take ‘sh-t jobs’ because no one else will employ them, and coming from screwed-up backgrounds in general-a group of survivors in a bleak, bitter world-is a common one in skinhead mythology.
And, like most myths, it has more than a grain of truth.
Scott Banks, a Black 18-year-old skin, had this to say: “Most of us come from messed up backgrounds… Y’know, I was born and raised in Brooklyn, N.Y.-in East New York… so, skinheads, man, we’re a rare breed-we’re hard, man. I’ve always been that way.”
Being hard, keeping your pride, being able and willing to fight for what you have-however little it may be-that’s a large part of the skinhead philosophy.
And how do they defend their friends and beliefs? Often through brute force.
Edwin says: “Of course, we do get violent, but that’s because people make us that way-it’s not because we choose to be. Like, people put us down just because we look different. We’ll give other people a chance, but no one gives us a chance.”
The violent behavior that many skins (both racist and non-racist) exhibit is inexcusable.
But so is the perception that all skinheads are racist jerks and deserve all the troubles and pain they receive. Too many people are making that generalization-and the non-racist skins feel they are being persecuted (‘crucified’ in their slang) by people who are ignorant of the facts, who think that they are all Nazis.
Skinheads Against Racism
And to judge someone’s worth as a human being by their appearance is a terrible wrong-it puts you in the same league as the fascist skins you think you’re helping to defeat.
Many people are unaware of the existence of organizations like SHARP (SkinHeads Against Racial Prejudice).
Marcus, 21, founder of SHARP, said, “SHARP was started about nine months ago because of all the negative media press, and it was just to show people that we [non-racist skins] exist, and to try to educate people.”
As Edwin says, “What I believe in is freedom for everybody who has a say… everybody’s equal, color doesn’t matter to nobody.”
George Stephens, a Black skinhead, notes that the roots of the Skinhead style are partially Black, “so you can’t be a White-power skinhead, because how can you listen to Black music and be White-power?”
As for the racists, Marcus reasons that, “The ‘boneheads’ who later became the White-power skins probably didn’t have jobs. So, when people are poor, and they don’t have jobs, and somebody comes in and says, ‘These are the people to blame, this is why you’re like that,’ they’re gonna follow that. Same way Hitler did it in Germany, the same way some people are trying to do here. You get people that are in desperate need for an answer… and, somebody gives them an answer-no matter how crazy it is, if they’re desperate enough, they’ll listen to it.”
A Return To the Past
Dick Hebidge, who co-wrote the book “Skinhead” with Nick Knight, maintains that skinheads are trying to make sense of a world that doesn’t seem to make much sense, to return to a time when the country was “Number One,” when the friends you made (‘Your mates’) stuck with you through thick and thin, to a romanticized time of clarity and stability not like the rapidly changing and uncertain world of today.
The original skinhead movement in England arose when “the sun was setting” on the English empire-she had lost her grip on the world economy, her might was on the wane… and isn’t the same thing happening, to a certain extent, here in the U.S.?
Could our forefathers have even conceived that Crack, AIDS, and the hydrogen bomb (among other things) would be problems that we would face?
Who wouldn’t want to go back to a time when the problems you had were up front and in your face? When you could touch and see them?
When people who worked with their hands (the “working-class”) weren’t kicked off their jobs and replaced by machines and computers?
When you defended your pride and honor with your fists and your wits-not with a Micro-Uzi submachine pistol?
Some people contend, however, that this is nothing more than a wistful illusion.
“They don’t know our feelings-only desperate cries/They see reflections through distorted eyes/We don’t care because it breaks their views/Got to learn to fight t to live/before they grind us under heel… “
-“Crucified” by Iron Cross
“We are a violent reaction to a violent society.”
-George Stephens, 23.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.