Sibling Relationships: Rivalry, Jealousy, Hostility…and Loyalty

For many teens it’s a familiar story: along with brothers and sisters come fights. Some teens fight every day with their siblings. The arguments can be about something as basic as who gets to use the bathroom first in the morning or who gets which seat in the car.
This is how Elizabeth Ren, 15, of Stuyvesant HS, sums up her relationship with her 12-year-old brother George: “My brother and I are always fighting for control, whether it’s the remote control or using the TV,” she says.
Because relationships between siblings often center on control, the cause for an argument can be just about anything. Isaac Esterman, 17, of Hunter College HS, remembers the time he bought a new magazine with fill-in blanks and told his 12-year-old brother Sam not to write in it. Sam wrote in it anyway and they had a fight.
For Manjula Nair, 15, of Stuyvesant HS, disagreements with her older brother Manoj, 16, center on junk food, the TV, and especially the phone. The fights usually lead to yelling, “slamming doors, and our parents screaming at us.”
The Parent Factor
Ah yes, parents. They, too, play an important role in rivalries. Many times they unnecessarily (and unintentionally) compare siblings, adding even more tension.
Manjula says, “My parents always compare [my brother and me]. They ask me, ‘Why can’t you be like that? Why can’t you help around the house?’ “
Elizabeth has similar complaints about her mother and father. “They compare us academically, by how we behave, and by who does chores,” she says.
Parents aside, sibling rivalry can spring from things that can’t be controlled, like who was born first. Take the older sibling. While she probably has a later curfew and a bigger allowance, it’s not always fun. She also has a lot of responsibilities.
Older Sibling As Role Model
Both Elizabeth and Isaac say that they are burdened with the job of being “role models” for their younger siblings. This task often entails much more than just setting a good example. It can also involve helping, caring for, and accepting blame for the actions of your younger brothers and sisters.
“Sometimes I feel pressured to help my brother and sister with their work,” Isaac complains. “Having siblings hinders me because they’re two more people to worry about that I don’t want to be seen with.”
He’s also annoyed by the fact that since his brother and sister usually manage to avoid doing their chores, he ends up doing a bulk of the housework.
Elizabeth, meanwhile, remembers how her parents scolded her once because her average was “only” in the upper 90s. Not only did they think it wasn’t high enough but they considered it an inappropriate example for her brother and sister.
Younger Sibling Gets Trounced
The lot of a younger sibling isn’t all “peaches n’cream” either. Most younger siblings, myself included, frequently suffer at the hands of a bossy older sibling.
That’s Manjula’s biggest complaint about her brother. “I’m on the phone and he wants to call someone. He says that he should get the phone…Sometimes he even hangs up on my friends,” she says.
Being born the “wrong” gender can also lead to problems. In Elizabeth’s family the males are favored and that creates tension between her and her brother.
“My sister and I get the most responsibilities. My brother gets to slack off because he’s the youngest, the smallest, and he’s a boy,” she says, adding that the reason is cultural. “In a traditional Chinese family, boys work outside to do ‘men’s work’ and don’t do housework.”
She added, “I get resentful, but it’s not his fault my parents think that way.”
In spite of all the conflicts, each teen I interviewed was able to find something positive to say about their siblings. There seems to be a lot of loyalty (especially in the face of parents) as well as fighting.
Manjula considers her role as a younger sister, “pretty easy, considering Manoj protects me a lot, especially from my parents. If I want to do something, and they won’t let me, he’ll defend me.”
More Good Than Bad
Her brother Manoj also helps by “breaking in” their parents, Manjula said. “For instance, if he gets to go to his senior prom, I have to go,” she said.
The good definitely outweighs the bad in my relationship with my older sister Asha, who’s 20. But Asha and I have gone through our share of troublesome times. We definitely fought over very petty things, like who should hold the remote control and who gets what seat. Still we had a good relationship, and I always knew I could confide in her when I was worried about something, like doing badly on a test.
Two years ago she went away to college, and our relationship got even better. The distance made us appreciate each other more. Instead of rivalry we now have a stronger friendship. Now when she’s home visiting we try to avoid even petty arguments. Instead of wasting time fighting, we’d rather be going out and doing stuff.
Your relationships with your siblings don’t have to be bad. Manjula’s advice for teens with sibling problems is, “Try to understand their feelings towards you. Try to find the reason why you fight a lot. If you can find a reason, you can find a solution.”
After writing this article and reflecting on my own situation, I suggest that all you sisters and brothers start treating your siblings as friends, rather than people you’re genetically obligated to talk to. Give them just as much respect as you would your best friend. You never know, you may actually discover wonderful things you didn’t know about each other.

SIDEBAR: You Can Get Along
To get the scoop on ways for teens to cope with sibling rivalry, I interviewed Adele Faber, author of Siblings Without Rivalry. According to Faber, while debates over control between brothers and sisters will probably never go away, it’s still possible to take a calm, rational approach to the problem. First, instead of screaming and insulting each other, try to solve your problems by talking them out. Discuss how you feel and how your sister or brother feels, and try to reach a compromise. If you feel the problem is too big for you to handle among yourselves, get an outside person, like a parent, to step in. Not that parents are perfect either. Realize it’s not wrong to be annoyed, or even angry, with your parents when they compare you to your siblings or favor them over you. But instead of giving yourself an extra headache by storing all this pent-up anger, you should talk to your parents. Tell them you can deal with them criticizing you, but it hurts when they bring your sister or brother into it. Though Faber can’t guarantee your parents will stop making comparisons, you’ll at least have the satisfaction of getting what you feel off your chest. And next time, perhaps, your parents will think about what you said before judging you by your brother’s or sister’s actions. Faber believes it’s important for parents to recognize that you and your siblings are different people with different needs. “Siblings should be treated as individuals,” she says. Whether you’re the oldest or the youngest, you should let your family, especially your siblings, know how you feel and work from there.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.