As if the abortion issue were not controversial enough, there’s now a new twist. The Supreme Court will soon decide if parents should have the right to know when their daughters have abortions.
According to a 1979 decision by the Supreme Court, a state may require parental involvement in teen abortion. This involvement could include either consent or notification.
Consent means that the teen cannot have the abortion if her parents don’t let her. Notification means that the parents have to know, but they don’t have to give their daughter permission to have the abortion.
However, such laws must offer an alternative way for the teen to prove that she is mature enough to have an abortion without involving her parents. If a girl feels that she can’t tell her parents, she can go before a state judge and get the court’s consent. This option is known as “judicial bypass.”
The Supreme Court has only ruled that judicial bypass is necessary for consent laws, but it has not ruled on it with regard to notification laws.
Twenty states have parental consent and notification laws, but most do not enforce them.
Two Important Cases
In two cases-Hodgson v. Minnesota and Ohio v. Akron Center for Reproductive Health-the Supreme Court will reconsider whether the states may make such laws. They will also review whether judicial bypass must be included as an alternative for notification as well as for consent.
Minnesota law requires that a girl under 18 notify both parents 48 hours before she can have an abortion. This is mandatory even if her parents are divorced, and one parent is not involved in her life. The only way she can get around this condition is to go before a state judge and prove that she is mature enough to have the abortion without her parents’ knowledge.
A similar Ohio law requires the notification of one parent 24 hours ahead of time, and it also includes the option of going before a judge (judicial bypass).
Opponents of these laws-groups of doctors, teenagers, parents, and abortion clinics-have filed suit against Minnesota and Ohio. A Federal court decided to uphold the Minnesota law, but the Ohio law was struck down. Both decisions have been appealed to the Supreme Court.
Both states want to maintain the laws without giving the teenager the option of going before a judge. This would mean that teens would have no choice but to tell their parents if they wanted an abortion.
Opponents want to strike down the laws completely. This would mean that no state could force parental involvement in a teenage girl’s decision.
Supporters of such laws assert that parental involvement protects minors from health risks and trauma, and that it strengthens the family.
They say that many minors aren’t able to make informed choices about their health care. They argue that almost every other medical procedure requires at least one parent’s consent. They contend that a girl’s parents are the most qualified to help her get proper medical attention.
A Parents’ Rights Issue?
Jeanne Head, president of the New York City Right to Life Committee, commented: “Abortion can prevent her [the minor] from ever becoming pregnant again…and she can lose her life. That this procedure does not require the permission of the parents is outrageous.”
Supporters of parental notification laws also believe that minors are often not emotionally ready to confront a situation as frightening as an unplanned pregnancy by herself. They believe that most girls cannot deal with the decision of whether or not to go through with their pregnancies.
Without the parents’ help, explained Head, the teen “Is left bereft, with nobody who really cares about her.”
She added that girls should not see abortion as their only option. Teens should know that they can continue their pregnancies and then either keep the baby or give it up for adoption.
According to groups like Right to Life, this law is a parent’s rights issue. They say that parents have the right to know what is going on in their daughter’s life. In fact, according to a recent New York Times poll, a majority of parents who generally support abortion rights want laws that would require that they know about their daughter’s abortion.
Negative Effects Seen
“This is not an anti-abortion bill necessarily,” explained Head. “It’s a parent’s rights, teenage protection bill…because the parents could just as well consent to the abortion as not.”
But opponents of parental involvement laws argue that the real goal is not to protect minors, but simply to restrict abortions. They point out that these laws have had only negative effects in states that enforce them.
“These laws are meant to make abortion more difficult to get,” remarked Lynn Paltrow, associate director of the Reproductive Freedom Project at the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU). “The facade that’s put on them is that they’ll promote communication in the family…The truth is that these laws, far from helping girls and their families, hurt them.” The ACLU is the main group working to repeal the laws.
Opponents of the laws argue that minors are able to make the abortion decision by themselves. The ACLU cites studies which show that teens can understand health care options and give informed consent-whether to continue or to end their pregnancies.
Pat Maloney, director of public issues and action at Planned Parenthood, asked, “How can people say that a teenager is mature enough to have a baby…and then turn around and say that she’s not mature enough to have an abortion? It’s nonsense.”
In addition, opponents of these laws claim that some adults-doctors and counselors-are always involved in the decision. For example, in New York State a minor can get an abortion without involving her parents; however, her doctor usually tells her exactly what abortion is and what her other options are, as well as encourage her to talk with her parents.
Critics say that laws which restrict easy access to abortion have had only negative effects. They say that the laws do not discourage teen sex and pregnancy, but rather delay abortion and force young women to continue unwanted pregnancies.
Delay in Abortions
For example, the state of Massachusetts requires parental consent. Teen abortions there have declined since the law went into effect, and advocates of consent laws see this as evidence of less teen sex. However, teen abortions in neighboring states have gone up at the same time, which seems to indicate that girls simply go across the state border to get abortions.
But some teens can’t travel to get an abortion and therefore have to go through with their pregnancies.
An ACLU report shows that, in Minnesota, the number of second trimester abortions (between 12 and 24 weeks after conception) went up 26% when the parental notification law went into effect. The reason for this is that teens had to wait longer to get abortions. This delay increases the health risks of teenage abortion, especially after the first six weeks of pregnancy. Opponents point out that this is in direct contrast to the purpose of the law, which is to protect the health of minors.
“The teenager, in having to go through this process,” said Maloney, “Is delayed from getting the health care that she needs immediately when she finds out that she’s pregnant.”
Fear of Telling Parents
According to an ACLU study, the teen birth rate in Minnesota has gone up 38% since the law was passed. More teens keep their babies. The report considers this a problem because of “the enormous burdens of teen motherhood.”
For example, 80% of teen mothers in Minnesota don’t finish high school. Teen mothers are much more likely to be poor and on welfare. Their children often grow up unwanted. Studies show that these children do much worse in school than those of older mothers.
Groups that are fighting parental consent and notification laws explain that children of teen mothers could add to the large underclass that depends on government aid.
Groups like the ACLU don’t consider adoption a real alternative. There are 1.6 million abortions in the U.S. each year. According to Paltrow, there aren’t nearly enough people to adopt all those babies, especially since there are still thousands of unwanted babies waiting to be adopted now.
The ACLU report shows that most teens who seek an abortion voluntarily tell at least one parent. Those who do not, explain that they have good reason.
Some are afraid of being abused. Others talk about parents who are physically and emotionally ill or addicted to drugs and alcohol. Every family situation is different, say the opponents of notification and consent laws, and no one law can solve the problem for everyone.
As Maloney explained, “If it [communication] wasn’t already there, this crisis is the worst time to force it…These laws punish the minority of teenagers who cannot tell their families about their abortions.”
One group that is fighting the laws in the Supreme Court is made up of divorced parents, mostly mothers. An ACLU article explains their position: they are angry that their consent isn’t enough, and that the other parent, who may no longer be a part of the girl’s life, has to know. They’re afraid to include the other parent, because this may lead to hostility and even violence.
According to the ACLU, 25-30% of the girls who went to court in Minnesota came with one parent who approved of the abortion but didn’t want to involve the other parent. In that state, 42% of all minors live with only one parent. These single parent families feel discriminated against by laws that require both parents to be involved in the decision.
Another major criticism of these laws is that they discriminate against poor and minority girls. It is said that restrictive laws hit these girls hardest.
A New York Times article notes that non-White teens are twice as likely as Whites to become pregnant. According to Paltrow, these are the girls who often can’t turn to their families, and they are also the ones who lack the economic and psychological resources to go before a judge instead.
Impact On Poor Teens
Most of the minors who seek judicial bypass in Minnesota are White, middle class, and well-educated. Opponents of the system say that it forces less advantaged girls into teen motherhood. This is why they don’t believe that judicial bypass solves the problem.
“There are already economic and social barriers to them [poor girls],” explained Maloney. “Wealthy women can always get on an airplane and fly somewhere [where abortion is legal].”
Opponents also argue that the experience of going before a judge is traumatic, and that it violates the minor’s right to privacy. Most minors who go before a Minnesota judge have to talk about their private lives in front of more than 20 strangers. In addition, the whole process causes delay, increasing health risks.
In the ACLU report, Judge Paul Garrity of Massachusetts summed it up: “It just gives these kids a hard time. I can’t think it accomplishes a darn thing.”
The Supreme Court now leans to an anti-abortion position. In its last ruling on abortion, in June 1989, it allowed states to place new restrictions on abortion that would make it harder to get and more expensive.
Within the next few weeks, the Court is likely to uphold the states’ right to pass parental consent and notification laws, probably with the judicial bypass option.
However, the Court isn’t likely to make abortion illegal as it was just 16 years ago.
Either way, New York State probably won’t pass a parental consent law. New York was one of the first states to make abortion legal, even before the Supreme Court did. The State Assembly gets a parental consent bill each year, and has always voted against it.
The cases coming before the Supreme Court about parental involvement are very important. According to the New York Times, more than one million American teens become pregnant each year, and 43% get an abortion. Many would be affected by these new requirements.
Both sides emphasize that it’s important for lawmakers to hear as much as possible about the issue. See the action box to find out how you can get involved. Whether you think parental involvement laws protect teens or hurt them, you can make your opinion count.
Should Parents Be Informed About Their Daughter’s Abortion?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.