Sex Ed in HS Is Often Too Little, Too Late

In New York City, 30,000 girls under 19 get pregnant each year, approximately 13,000 give birth, and over 6,000 teens contract a sexually transmitted disease (STD).
There is no doubt that students need sex education. But how effective is the current sex ed program in public schools?
Compelled partly by the rise in teen pregnancy rates and partly by the spread of AIDS, mandatory sex education was finally introduced to the New York City public school system in 1986. It took the Board of Education several years to get the sex ed programs moving. In 1986, each school was given three years to work it into the curriculum.
Too Little, Too Late
Sex ed in high school is often described as too little, too late. Some students interviewed never had sex ed until the tenth or eleventh grade. By that time, as many as half of all teens have had sex already. The Board of Education has recently tried to change this by introducing Family Living, a simplified sex ed program taught as early as elementary school.
Some high schools have sex ed incorporated into health education, but others have it as a separate class. Many students say that when sex ed is part of a health education class, it is often crammed in at the end.
Kisha Drumgold, 17, Brandeis HS, felt that students should have “spent more time on [sex ed] instead of learning all that stuff about nutrition. We didn’t learn about [sex] till the end.”
“I had health and we only spent three minutes on sex ed,” said a Brooklyn HS student.
When everything is pushed into the last few weeks of the semester, teachers can’t possibly cover the curriculum and convey the essential information to the students.
“Some teachers don’t like to teach it, or they run out of time. I make sure I never run out of time,” said Celeste Weitz, a health education teacher at Brooklyn Technical HS.
According to Georganne Del Canto, assistant director of the Board of Education’s Office of Health, Physical Education, and School Sports for junior high and elementary schools, there is a school-based advisory council in each school district with student representatives, parent representatives, guidance counselors, teachers, principals, and a health advisor.
“Community school districts look at the curriculum [developed by the Board] and adjust it to the needs of the community,” said Del Canto. They prepare a proposal for junior high schools and elementary schools, and the Board of Education accepts it or sends it back for more work. The high schools, however are centrally organized and all use basically the same curriculum.
Curriculum Not Always Covered
The topics in the high school curriculum include family responsibility, decision-making, sexual health, and forms of sexual expression. But there’s a wide gap between what’s writtenin the text and what’s actually covered in class. Many students don’t get specific information on STDs and birth control.
“If more teenagers were aware, we’d have less teen pregnancy and STD infections,”said Wendy Allard, 15, John Dewey HS.
Asked how he would improve his class, Lander Anderson, 16, Brooklyn Technical HS said, “I would make it more in-depth. I would make it more serious, because nobody really takes it seriously. Maybe give it more credits. I would have less gym and give it in the ninth and tenth grade, or have it as a separate class.”
It is very important for the sex ed teacher to receive proper training because the teacher plays a key role. She has to give accurate information, answer questions, and help students to gain a better understanding of human sexuality. More important, the teacher is what Del Canto calls a “role model.” She must set a mature tone for discussing this sensitive topic. Del Canto said that sex ed teachers should receive 30 hours of training but many do not.
“A teacher can make all the difference in the world,” said Andy Humm, director of education for the Hetrick-Martin Institute for gay and lesbian youth.
Students agree. “At first people were laughing, but as time went on, the teacher was demanding that we use the correct terms for sexual organs, and it got more adult,” said a 17-year-old LaGuardia HS student.
“I try to be as sensitive and tactful as possible, and I let them know that I’m available to speak to them. And if [the topic] is too sensitive and the students are embarrassed, I allow them to write their questions anonymously on a piece of paper,” said Weitz about her sex ed classes at Brooklyn Tech.
However, when another student, who found his sex ed class “inadequate,” was asked how it could have been improved, he answered, “By putting a competent teacher in front of the class.”
Sex Ed Should Begin At Home
Long before students enter the public school system, their attitudes about sex are shaped at home.
“The primary educators are the parents,” said Del Canto. She felt that sex education should begin in the home.
“Most sex ed should take place in the home, but in most homes this subject is taboo. That’s the only reason it should be taught in school,” said one Brooklyn High School student.
“Most parents are uncomfortable, and if we don’t get it from school we’ll probably get it off the streets, and that’s usually wrong,” agreed Andrea Winter, 17, of Edward R. Murrow HS.
Nadine Browne, 17, of FDR HS, agreed, “Half the time their parents don’t teach them. But if it’s mandatory they have to learn it. Parents feel afraid, so they wait. And by the time they tell them something, it’s too late. Especially nowadays with AIDS and all that…I’m 17 and I’m still waiting for my mother to tell me something.”
Some parents oppose what is being taught in schools. Humm suggested that a parent should have the option of removing her child if she makes a written request.
But fear of parent opposition is one of the reasons that some teachers don’t cover all the subjects in the curriculum. In fact, some feel that the curriculum is “watered down” so that parents will accept it.
Humm felt that one of the problems with our sex ed classes is that a lot of teachers aren’t trying hard enough because of embarrassment or apathy. “A lot of issues are not approached directly, or they are avoided altogether.”
When asked about his sex ed teacher, one Brooklyn high school student said, “I guess she was too shy to talk about it in front of us.”
Show Students How To Use Condoms
Humm’s advice to teachers is to be direct. One suggestion he made was to bring a banana to class and show students how to use a condom.
“You could just tell them about it, but if they don’t know what they’re doing, they’re still going to get pregnant or get AIDS,” said Anthony Patten, 17, of South Shore HS.
Weitz felt that it would be interesting to have outside speakers, “maybe a teen mother. Then [the students] could get the information first hand.”
Humm said that sex ed instruction should include role playing which stresses human relations, not just the “facts.” He said that teens need a better understanding of relationships because “Usually their only role models for day in, day out intimate relationships are their parents, and that could be good, [but it] could be bad.” Role playing could expose teens to alternative ways of dealing with relationships.
Del Canto felt that consistency is the key to improving sex education in public schools: She said “It’s not effective if it’s not consistent.” She felt that it should be taught yearly because every year teens have “different questions…different needs.”
Students Have Mixed Feelings
However, students had mixed feelings: Zujiery Batista, 14, of Jane Addams HS agreed that it was a good idea for sex ed to be taught yearly because “every year something new comes out.”
But AnnMarie Hibbert, 16, of Brooklyn Technical HS, felt that “going over the same thing over and over again” might get a little boring.
Browne and several others students felt that sex ed should be a “separate mandatory class for one year.” Another student suggested having one less term of gym and making sex ed a separate class.
Improving sex ed instruction in schools would require devoting more class time to adequately cover the curriculum, and having better trained teachers to give specific information on STDs and birth control, as well as broader issues like decision-making and relationships.
Weitz added that sex education “is a necessary part of life. I had a girl who didn’t know where babies came from. And when I told her, she became hysterical. Sex education is really important.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.