On a recent Tuesday afternoon, another parent in Manhattan Family Treatment Court was facing Judge Gloria Sosa-Lintner. In a courtroom the size of an ordinary living room, the parent, a recovering drug user, sat in a bright orange plastic chair and told the judge and a roomful of lawyers and child welfare workers that she was 50 days clean.
“How about some applause?” she demanded. Judge Sosa-Lintner and the lawyers gave her some. Then the judge granted her more visiting time with her kids. “You look good today,” Judge Sosa-Lintner told her.
“So do you!” the parent responded. “I love you guys! I love my program! I’m happy.” She turned to the bailiff and said, “I love you too!” She was one day closer to getting her kids back.
A Different Kind of Court
The Manhattan Family Treatment Court (FTC) is for parents who have lost their kids, or are in danger of losing them, because they have drug or alcohol addictions. The court provides intensive services and monitoring to help parents recover and get their kids back.
When I visited the court, I met with Judge Sosa-Lintner and referee Susan Doherty (a referee is a lawyer who hears cases like a judge does). Both of them have worked at the court since it started in 1998.
They told me the FTC was created in response to the crack epidemic of the ’80s and ’90s that put so many kids in foster care.
“The drug treatment programs available to parents back then weren’t really working with crack,” Doherty told me. “There were a lot of kids coming into care and never going back home.”
The court was started as a way to give parents what they needed to get back on track.
The Manhattan court was the first of its kind in New York, and one of the first in the country. Today, there are 48 family treatment courts in New York State alone.
Committing to Change
When a parent charged with neglect is a substance abuser, ACS (New York City’s child welfare agency) sends them right to Manhattan Family Treatment Court. But parents aren’t forced to participate. They are given a lawyer who is trained in addiction issues to help them decide if they are ready for the program.
“What we tell them is that treatment court is harder (than regular family court), because they have to come to court more frequently and follow extra regulations, like taking drug tests. But it gives them a better chance of getting their kids back or of keeping them from going into the system, and it gives them a better chance of getting rid of their drug problem,” Doherty said.
Not every parent says yes. “People have to be ready and willing to change,” said Judge Sosa-Lintner.
Once a parent decides to participate, the first thing they have to do is admit to what they were charged with. “They have to tell the court, yes, I have a drug problem,” Doherty explained. “That’s important for legal reasons (so the court can take the case) but it’s also a first step in recovery.”
The Right Match
Then, each parent meets with a case manager at the court’s on-site clinic.
“The case manager will try to determine what they need and match them with the right kind of drug treatment program,” Doherty said. That might be a day-treatment program, a residential program or a program that meets in the evenings after work.
Once they join a treatment program, the program sends a progress report to the court once a month. Inside the report is information about how the parents are doing, and if they’re making visits with their kids. When parents join the court they agree to let this information be shared with the judge. That way, the court can keep a close watch on the parents.
No Guarantees
To graduate from the FTC, parents need to accomplish a list of goals, including completing a treatment program, staying clean for at least one straight year and being able to support their children. They have to complete a parenting skills program and may have to find a new job or housing to get their kids back.
But even if a parent meets all their goals, there is no guarantee that they will get their kids back. “We can’t make that promise,” Doherty said.
It might take parents so long to finish the program that their kids have made a bond with whomever they are staying with, and it’s not right to move them again. While most parents stay in the treatment court for an average of two years, it takes some people much longer to stay clean and do what they need to do.
I think it’s good that the court doesn’t make any promises to the parents. The court can’t do all the work for them to get their kids back. It has to be a partnership.
Relapse Is Part of Recovery
I wondered what would happen if a parent in the treatment court relapsed. Relapsing is when you fall off the wagon and you start using drugs again. Relapsing is common, because it’s hard for a substance abuser to just turn away from whatever they were using and never go back.
Doherty told me that when parents relapse, they’ll usually get another chance because the program is there for them to get help. “Parents relapse all the time. We recognize relapse is a part of recovery,” Doherty said. “What’s important for us is how they handle it.”
If parents come to them and explain why they relapsed, they can usually get back on track.
Hearing that they give parents chance after chance kind of stunned me. I would have thought that parents would get something like three strikes and then be out of the program. But it makes sense, because a parent who is a substance abuser might need those chances.
On the afternoon that I observed the court, I saw that some cases were going well, and others were going poorly.
Ups and Downs
One parent had tested positive for alcohol when she came to the court (all the parents get tested each time they come to court). When the judge asked her about it, it came out that she had downed some glasses of wine the night before at a party.
The judge turned a little tough on her, but I think the parent needed it. In order to get her kids back she has to start a treatment program and complete it, while the kids live with their father.
There was another mother who was in and out of her program and had missed dates that were not explainable. One of the court workers announced that the woman had tested positive for cocaine that morning.
Judge Sosa-Lintner said that the woman’s children would be placed at their grandmother’s house that night. The mother asked for a referral to a 28-day detox program. After that, she hoped to be clean enough to continue through with the treatment program.
I was looking for more rough words to be said, or for the tension to be dreadful, but it was pretty quiet. And many of the cases were going well.
One woman got a certificate as a reward for entering “Phase Two.” Phase Two is when you have been clean for four months straight and completed the rules and goals they gave you in Phase One.
To get through Phase Two, you have to be clean for another four months and complete yet another set of rules, like starting to take parenting skills classes and making progress toward your treatment plan goals.
Denise Dizzine, an FTC casemanager, explained that the court uses a system of rewards and sanctions (punishments). “Sanctions might be meeting with a case manager every week or writing an essay about why it’s important for them to be in treatment. Rewards could be things like getting a journal with a supportive message from the judge, or getting more visits with their kids,” she said.
“The court acts like a parent figure,” Judge Sosa-Lintner told me. “The people that come before Susan and me are usually young people, who haven’t completed much in their lives. They are looking for praise, and they’re also looking for the court to chastise them if they do wrong. People come to treatment court because they’re hopeful something will click.”
That made sense to me. The parents who were doing badly need to have consequences, because they are there to get their kids back, and to do that they need to work for it. The kids can’t just be handed to them.
The cases that were successful happened with parents who had relapsed in the past but were keeping the prize in mind. I liked that the judge was fair through all of the cases I saw, and gave the parents who didn’t do so well a chance to still be in the program. But she was a little hard when she needed to be.
Making An Impact
The Manhattan Family Treatment Court seems to be very helpful at taking the time to let the parents know what they’re supposed to do and keeping a close eye on them. As of February, 2007, the court had worked with 916 parents from 816 families, and 354 parents had graduated.
Doherty said she thinks the treatment court has had a big impact. “Judges are more knowledgeable about addiction and recovery, and that knowledge helps them better understand what’s happening with parents,” she said.
“I think the court is working great,” she said. “I wish it was working better. I wish that these resourcesâthe close monitoring, the supportâwere available to all parents in family court.”
Second Chances
A court for parents battling addiction
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.