Rules Rules Rules

Look at me, what do your eyes see? A Black girl with an innocent face and big dreams. I’m not a trouble maker, but somehow, thanks to my school’s rules and the way they are enforced, I end up getting into trouble for no good reason.
Have you ever heard of anyone getting detention for cutting lunch? Just ask me.
Usually during our lunch period, my friends and I go to the school library instead of the cafeteria. That’s the best time for us to do homework, or work on other assignments. We don’t like going to the cafeteria because once you’re in, they won’t let you leave until the bell rings, and so we have to hurry to get to our next class.
One day the library was closed during our lunch period. So my friend and I started walking around the building.
Hallways Are For Walking In
A guard stopped us and asked for our IDs and program cards. We gave them to him. Then, even though we weren’t cutting class, and only had lunch that period, he took us straight to detention!
I can understand students getting punished for walking in the hallway instead of going to class. But if students have lunch and don’t feel like sitting in the cafeteria, they should feel free to walk in the hallway, as long as they’re not disturbing anyone by making too much noise or banging on doors. After checking their program cards to make sure that they’re not cutting, I think guards should give students a chance to walk where they want.
Shut Out of the Elevator
That’s not the only one of my school rules that I find so aggravating. We need passes for this, that and everything. When I first entered Columbus HS, every time I tried to take the elevator to my class, some dean would tell me to get off if I didn’t have an elevator pass.
I think this is ridiculous. Say you have a class all the way on the third or fourth floor after gym in the basement. Why should you have to take the stairs if you are feeling dizzy or just so tired that you don’t feel you can make it up the staircase? What if you have a really heavy load of books? If there’s an elevator in the school, students should be able to use it. Otherwise, why have it there in the first place?
I know there are a lot of students at my school and I also know that we all cannot fit in the elevator at once, but students should be able to take the elevator when they’re not feeling up to taking the stairs.
What If You’re Sick
Only staff and those few students with elevator passes get to ride the elevator.
To get an elevator pass, you usually have to have a serious injury that shows that you are in need of the elevator, or else you have to bring in a note from your doctor. But what if you just don’t feel well?
One time I was very sick and not in the mood for gym, but since the gym teacher was giving us our final, I had to concentrate on passing instead of being worried about the headache I had.
For our final, we had to run non-stop for some minutes. Afterwards, I was so tired that I wanted to use the elevator to go to my math class on the fourth floor. I didn’t use the elevator, though, because I knew that I didn’t have an elevator pass.
The last thing I needed was to have some dean or guard asking me the same old question: Where is your elevator pass? When I got to my math class, I was feeling so weak that if you bit me, I wouldn’t have felt it.
Parental Permission Required
Not only can’t you use the elevator without a pass, but you can’t use the Internet without a pass, either. A student’s parent has to sign a paper allowing their kid to use the Internet. If a student doesn have her permission form filled out, she isn’t allowed to use the Internet.
The school may worry about students using the library computer to chat with other Internet users or look at pictures of naked people. If students get caught, the school will kick them off the Internet, contact their parents and tell them what their kids were doing.
But some parents don’t want to be responsible if the student does something wrong on the Internet. They don’t want the school to bother them, so they won’t sign the permission form. Some parents don’t understand that the Internet is an important way of getting information for school.
Banned from Internet
I think students who need the Internet for assignments and don’t have permission forms should be able to use it anyway. Otherwise, they may fail or at least lose points for handing their work in late. How will they get the information they need if they don’t have a computer at home or can’t get to the public library after school?
Even students who do get to use the Internet at school have to deal with some librarians’ harsh enforcement of the rules. One day I was using the Internet and I pushed chat room by mistake and didn’t know how to get back to what I was doing before.
Just then, a librarian came in the room and told me nobody is allowed to chat with anyone. I told her that I didn’t know that and also that I pushed it by mistake. Then she told me that, for chatting, I could not use the Internet until the following week.
She said it out loud to the other librarian, too. I knew that some of the students heard it because they were looking at me strangely when I came out from the computer room. And all I did was make an innocent mistake!
I’m not saying that all rules are terrible. I think it is OK to have rules, but only if there’s a point to them, and only if they’re fairly enforced.
For example, my school has a dress code that says we can’t wear certain types of clothing to school, like short shorts or short skirts above the knee.
I don’t have a problem with that. But some students get told to change their clothes or they will be sent back home, while other students dressed the same way are told nothing.
One day last June, it was very hot and a girl I know came to school wearing a dress that wasn’t terribly short, but it was above her knee. She was stopped when she came in and told to go back home to change.
She explained that she had extra clothes in her gym locker and would put them on, but she wasn’t allowed to take her bag with her to the gym room. The guards must not have trusted her; they held onto her bag so she’d have to come back and show them that she really did change her clothes.
Getting Away with It
On that same day I saw another girl wearing a skirt that was at least as short as the dress the first girl was wearing. Now how come she was allowed in the building wearing that skirt, when the other girl was almost sent home to change? As you can see, even though they
supposedly made the rules for the whole student body, some students get away with breaking them.
Little things like this can make us wish we were never accepted at our school. I came to Columbus to get the kind of education that I need and the help that my teachers will provide. I didn’t come here for others to treat me in a mean way.
Why does the school assume the worst of students? I think they should allow us to do things in our own way as long as we are doing it in a fair and considerate manner. Then maybe we would all have more peace of mind.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.